Barbetta Menu with Prices is something you will want to review before booking a table at this historic New York institution. Located in the Theater District, Barbetta’s prix fixe dinner menu bundles multiple courses into a single, elegant price point, which makes budgeting for a night out much simpler.
You are probably wondering what the current costs look like. While menus change seasonally, the structure has remained consistent for years, offering a classic fine dining experience that has been serving guests since 1906.
Barbetta Menu With Prices
To give you a clear picture of what to expect, we have broken down the standard dining options. Keep in mind that these are the base rates and do not include the 20% service charge that is typically added to every bill.
Prix Fixe Dinner Options
The main draw here is the multi-course dinner. You generally have two distinct paths to choose from, depending on how hungry you are.
- Traditional Prix Fixe: This usually runs around $85.00 per person. It includes a starter, a pasta course, a main entree, and a dessert.
- Vegetarian Tasting: A dedicated plant-based menu is available for roughly $75.00. It follows the same structure but highlights seasonal vegetables and homemade pastas.
These are not “small plate” portions. You will receive full, generous servings for each course, so come prepared for a long, leisurely meal.
À La Carte Selections
If you prefer to order individually, you can. The kitchen offers a limited à la carte list, though it is less common than the fixed price options.
- Appetizers: Expect to pay between $18.00 and $24.00 for items like the vitello tonnato or the grilled octopus.
- Main Courses: These range from $38.00 to $52.00. The white truffle risotto is often the most expensive item on the list when in season.
- Desserts: The famous panna cotta or the chocolate torte are priced around $14.00.
Pre-Theater Special
Because of its location near Broadway, they offer a slightly earlier seating that is faster. This is a great way to see the restaurant without spending the whole evening.
- Cost: $65.00 per person.
- Time Limit: You must be seated by 6:00 PM and finish by 7:30 PM.
- Courses: This is a condensed version with three courses instead of four.
Be aware that the pre-theater menu is not available on Sundays or Mondays.
Wine Pairings And Beverages
Barbetta is famous for its cellar, which holds over 20,000 bottles. They have a sommelier on staff to help you choose.
- By the Glass: House wines start at $15.00.
- Pairing Flight: A five-glass pairing for the prix fixe menu is $55.00.
- Barolo: If you want a specific Piedmontese bottle, prices start at $120.00 and go up significantly from there.
One thing to note is that they do not offer a “bottomless” brunch or any happy hour specials. The pricing is premium, reflecting the white tablecloth service and the antique furnishings in the dining room.
Final Pricing Notes
When you calculate the total cost, remember to factor in tax and the mandatory service charge. A dinner for two with a moderate bottle of wine will easily reach $250.00 to $300.00 total.
If you are on a tighter budget, the bar area offers a limited menu that is slightly cheaper than the main dining room. You can get a plate of pasta there for around $28.00.
It is always wise to check their official website for the most current PDF of the menu, as prices do shift slightly with inflation and seasonal sourcing. Reserving a table is also highly recommended, especially during the opera season.
Make sure to confirm the exact pricing when you are seated, as the printed menu may have slight variations from what is listed online. The staff are very professional and will walk you through the options if you ask.
We hope this guide helps you plan your visit. The food is traditional, the service is impeccable, and now you know exactly what the bill will look like before you go.