Morning regulars at Benny’s Cafe know the menu prices shift slightly with the seasons, reflecting what’s freshest from local suppliers. If you are looking for the Bennys Cafe Menu with Prices before you head out the door, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down the current costs for breakfast, lunch, and coffee so you can plan your order without any surprises.
Benny’s keeps things simple. They focus on hearty portions and fair pricing. Below is a clear breakdown of what you can expect to pay on your next visit.
Bennys Cafe Menu With Prices
The menu is split into three main parts: Breakfast, Lunch, and Drinks. Prices include tax, but tipping your server is always appreciated. Here is the current price list, based on the latest seasonal update.
Breakfast Favorites
Breakfast is served all day, which is great for late risers. The portions are generous, so you might want to share a side of toast.
- The Standard Benny (Two eggs, bacon or sausage, hash browns, toast): $11.50
- Avocado Smash Toast (Sourdough, feta, chili flakes): $13.25
- Buttermilk Pancake Stack (Three pancakes, maple syrup): $9.75
- Veggie Omelette (Bell peppers, onion, spinach, cheddar): $12.00
- Steel Cut Oatmeal (Brown sugar, berries): $8.50
Lunch Plates And Sandwiches
Lunch kicks off at 11:00 AM. The grill gets busy, so expect a short wait during the noon rush. The Reuben is a local favorite, but the Turkey Club is also a solid choice.
- Classic Reuben (Corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss, rye): $14.75
- Benny’s Bacon Burger (Half-pound patty, cheddar, house sauce): $15.50
- Grilled Chicken Wrap (Lettuce, tomato, ranch): $12.95
- Soup Of The Day (With half sandwich): $10.25
- Cobb Salad (Egg, avocado, blue cheese): $13.75
Coffee And Cold Drinks
The coffee here is strong. They use a local roaster, and the beans change weekly. If you are not a coffee drinker, the fresh squeezed orange juice is worth the extra cost.
- Drip Coffee (Bottomless cup): $3.25
- Cappuccino: $4.50
- Iced Latte: $4.95
- Fresh Orange Juice: $5.00
- House Lemonade: $3.75
Kid’s Menu And Sides
Bringing the family? The kid’s menu is affordable, and the sides are perfect for sharing. The fries are cooked in peanut oil, so let your server know if you have allergies.
- Grilled Cheese (With fries): $7.50
- Chicken Tenders (Two pieces): $8.00
- Side Of Bacon: $4.25
- Side Of Avocado: $2.50
Daily Specials And Pricing Tips
Benny’s runs a “Blue Plate Special” on weekdays. This is usually a meatloaf or pot roast dish that is not on the regular menu. It costs around $13.00 and includes a drink.
If you want to save a little money, consider the following:
- Visit before 9:00 AM for the “Early Bird” discount on breakfast combos.
- Skip the bottled water and ask for tap water instead.
- Share a side of fries; the portion is big enough for two people.
- Check the chalkboard by the register for daily soup flavors.
One thing to note is that the prices listed above are accurate for the current season. However, the cost of eggs and dairy can fluctuate. If you see a price that seems higher than last week, it is likely due to supplier costs, not a mistake.
Also, they have a loyalty card. If you buy nine coffees, the tenth one is free. Just ask your server for a card at the start of your meal. It is a simple way to get a little value back if you are a regular.
For the most accurate pricing, you can call the cafe directly. The staff are friendly and will happily read the menu to you over the phone. They can also tell you if any seasonal specials are currently running that might not be listed here.
Overall, Benny’s offers decent value for the quality. The ingredients are fresh, and the service is quick. Whether you are stopping by for a quick breakfast or a leisurely lunch, you now have a solid idea of what you will be spending. Bring cash if you can, as the card machine sometimes has a small processing fee on weekends.