Culver’s ice cream flavors menu with prices rotates seasonal specialties alongside their famous frozen custard concretes. If you’ve ever stood at the counter wondering which flavor to pick or how much it’ll cost, you’re in the right place. This guide breaks down every option, from classic vanilla to limited-time treats, with real prices you can expect in 2025.
Let’s be honest—Culver’s isn’t just about butterburgers. Their frozen custard is the real star. Made fresh daily with real cream, eggs, and sugar, it’s denser and creamier than regular ice cream. And the menu changes often, so staying updated helps you plan your visit.
Culver’s Ice Cream Flavors Menu With Prices
Below is the full breakdown of what you can order, including concrete mixers, sundaes, shakes, and scoops. Prices vary by location, but these are averages based on current data from multiple stores across the Midwest and South.
Classic Frozen Custard Flavors
These are the everyday staples you’ll find at almost every Culver’s. They don’t rotate out, so you can count on them year-round.
- Vanilla Frozen Custard – Smooth, rich, and perfect for mix-ins. A single scoop runs about $2.79, a double is $3.99, and a pint to-go is $4.49.
- Chocolate Frozen Custard – Deep cocoa flavor, not too sweet. Same pricing as vanilla: $2.79 single, $3.99 double, $4.49 pint.
- Strawberry Frozen Custard – Made with real strawberry puree. Priced identically to vanilla and chocolate.
- Butter Pecan Frozen Custard – Buttery, nutty, and slightly salty. Same price point: $2.79 single, $3.99 double.
Seasonal And Limited-Time Flavors
Culver’s rotates flavors every few weeks, often tied to holidays or local events. These are the ones you’ll want to watch for.
- Mint Chocolate Chip – Appears around St. Patrick’s Day and summer. Single scoop $2.99, double $4.29.
- Pumpkin Spice – Available September through November. Same pricing as mint.
- Eggnog – December only. Single $2.99, double $4.29.
- Blueberry Cheesecake – Summer release, often June-July. Single $3.19, double $4.49.
- Salted Caramel Pretzel – A fan favorite, usually spring. Single $3.19, double $4.49.
- Cherry Amaretto – Late winter. Single $3.19, double $4.49.
Concrete Mixers (The Signature Item)
A concrete mixer is frozen custard blended with mix-ins like candy, cookies, or fruit. It’s served upside down—if it falls out, you get a free one. Prices depend on size and number of mix-ins.
- Small Concrete Mixer (one mix-in) – $4.29
- Medium Concrete Mixer (two mix-ins) – $5.19
- Large Concrete Mixer (three mix-ins) – $6.09
- Extra Mix-In – $0.50 each
Popular combinations include:
- Vanilla custard with Oreo pieces and hot fudge
- Chocolate custard with peanut butter and banana
- Strawberry custard with cheesecake bites and graham cracker
Shakes And Malts
These are thicker than fast-food shakes, made with frozen custard and real milk. Malts add malted milk powder for a toasty flavor.
- Small Shake or Malt – $4.49
- Medium Shake or Malt – $5.29
- Large Shake or Malt – $6.09
- Flavor Add-Ins (like strawberry or chocolate syrup) – $0.50
Sundaes
Classic sundaes come with hot fudge, caramel, or strawberry topping, plus whipped cream and a cherry.
- Single Scoop Sundae – $3.79
- Double Scoop Sundae – $4.99
- Brownie Sundae – $5.49 (includes a warm brownie)
- Cookie Sundae – $5.49 (includes a chocolate chip cookie)
Floats And Root Beer Floats
A float is two scoops of vanilla custard in a frosty mug of root beer or other soda.
- Root Beer Float – $4.29
- Orange Float – $4.29
- Coke Float – $4.29
Pints And Quart To-Go
Perfect for taking home. You can mix flavors if you order a quart.
- Pint of Frozen Custard – $4.49
- Quart of Frozen Custard – $7.99
- Flavor Mix-In for Quart – $1.50
How To Order Like A Pro
Ordering at Culver’s is simple, but there are a few tricks to get the best value.
Step 1: Choose Your Base Flavor
Start with vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, or butter pecan. If a seasonal flavor is available, that’s your chance to try something new.
Step 2: Pick Your Format
Decide if you want a scoop, concrete mixer, shake, sundae, or float. Each has a different price point.
Step 3: Add Mix-Ins Or Toppings
For concrete mixers, you get one mix-in free per size. Extra mix-ins cost $0.50 each. Popular choices include:
- Oreo pieces
- Reese’s peanut butter cups
- M&M’s
- Hot fudge
- Caramel
- Strawberry puree
- Banana
- Cheesecake bites
- Graham cracker
- Brownie chunks
Step 4: Confirm The Price
Prices vary by location, so ask before you order if you’re on a budget. The total for a medium concrete mixer with two mix-ins is usually around $5.69 to $6.19.
Seasonal Flavor Calendar
Knowing when flavors drop helps you plan. Here’s a rough timeline based on past years.
- January-February – Cherry Amaretto, Chocolate Cherry
- March-April – Mint Chocolate Chip, Salted Caramel Pretzel
- May-June – Blueberry Cheesecake, Lemon Sorbet
- July-August – Peach, Blackberry, Strawberry Cheesecake
- September-October – Pumpkin Spice, Caramel Apple
- November-December – Eggnog, Peppermint Bark
These dates can shift by a week or two. Check your local store’s Facebook page or call ahead to confirm.
Nutritional Information
If you’re watching calories or sugar, here’s what you need to know. A single scoop of vanilla frozen custard (about 4 ounces) contains roughly:
- Calories: 280
- Fat: 16g
- Sugar: 24g
- Protein: 6g
A medium concrete mixer with two mix-ins can easily hit 600-800 calories. Shakes are similar. If you want a lighter option, order a small scoop without toppings.
Comparing Culver’s To Other Ice Cream Chains
How does Culver’s stack up against competitors like Dairy Queen or Cold Stone? Here’s a quick comparison.
- Dairy Queen – Soft serve is lighter and less dense. Blizzards are similar to concrete mixers but often cheaper by about $0.50 to $1.00.
- Cold Stone – More mix-in options, but prices are higher (a small creation starts around $5.50). Custard is creamier at Culver’s.
- Baskin-Robbins – More flavor variety (31 flavors), but custard is not their specialty. Prices are comparable.
- Local Ice Cream Shops – Often more expensive, but may offer unique flavors. Culver’s is more consistent.
Overall, Culver’s offers good value for the quality. The frozen custard is richer than most soft serve, and the prices are reasonable for what you get.
Tips For Saving Money
Nobody wants to overpay for ice cream. Here are a few ways to keep costs down.
- Order a small concrete mixer instead of a medium. It’s still plenty of custard.
- Skip extra mix-ins. One is usually enough.
- Share a large shake with a friend. It’s big enough for two.
- Check the app for coupons. Culver’s occasionally offers buy-one-get-one deals.
- Visit on a Tuesday. Some locations have a “Terrific Tuesday” special on concrete mixers.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is The Most Popular Flavor At Culver’s?
Vanilla frozen custard is the top seller, but the seasonal Salted Caramel Pretzel concrete mixer is a fan favorite when it’s available.
Does Culver’s Have Sugar-free Ice Cream?
No, Culver’s does not offer sugar-free frozen custard. Their custard is made with real sugar and cream. However, they do have a few no-sugar-added toppings like hot fudge.
Can I Order Culver’s Ice Cream Online?
Yes, you can order through the Culver’s app or website for pickup. Delivery is available through third-party apps like DoorDash and Uber Eats, but prices may be higher.
How Often Does The Flavor Menu Change?
New seasonal flavors are introduced every 4 to 6 weeks. The classic flavors stay year-round.
Are There Any Gluten-free Options?
The frozen custard itself is gluten-free, but mix-ins like Oreo pieces and cookie dough contain gluten. Ask for a gluten-free mix-in list at the counter.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
Culver’s ice cream flavors menu with prices offers something for everyone, whether you’re a vanilla purist or a seasonal adventurer. The key is knowing what’s available and when. Stick to the classics if you want consistency, or try a limited-time flavor for a change of pace.
Remember that prices can vary by location, so always check the board before ordering. And if you’re unsure, ask for a sample—Culver’s staff is usually happy to let you taste a flavor before committing.
One more thing: don’t forget to order your concrete mixer upside down. It’s a tradition, and if it falls, you get a free one. That’s a win-win in my book.
So next time you’re near a Culver’s, you’ll know exactly what to order and how much it’ll cost. No more guessing. No more standing at the counter feeling overwhelmed. Just good frozen custard, fair prices, and a smile.
Enjoy your next visit. And maybe try that Salted Caramel Pretzel—it’s worth the hype.