Andy’s menu prices cover their frozen custard treats and sundaes in a straightforward format that makes ordering easy. Whether you are a first-time visitor or a regular, knowing what to expect helps you plan your visit. This guide breaks down every item, size, and cost so you can decide before you step up to the counter.
Andy’s Frozen Custard has built a loyal following with its rich, creamy treats made fresh daily. The menu is simple but offers enough variety to satisfy any sweet tooth. From classic cones to elaborate sundaes, each item has a clear price point. Let’s walk through the full menu and see what fits your budget.
Andy’s Menu Prices Overview
The core of Andy’s menu is their frozen custard, which comes in vanilla and chocolate flavors daily. They also feature a rotating flavor of the day, adding variety for regular customers. Prices are consistent across most locations, though some franchise stores may vary slightly.
Andy’s keeps things simple with three main size options for most items: small, medium, and large. The small is perfect for a light treat, while the large is generous enough to share. Below is a breakdown of the base custard prices.
- Small cup or cone: $3.49
- Medium cup or cone: $4.29
- Large cup or cone: $5.09
- Kids size (smaller portion): $2.79
These prices reflect the standard custard without any mix-ins or toppings. Adding extras will increase the cost, which we cover in the next sections. Remember that tax is not included in these listed prices.
Cones And Cups
Andy’s offers both cake cones and waffle cones for their custard. The cake cone is included in the base price, but the waffle cone costs a little extra. If you prefer a cup, that is also included in the standard price.
Here are the specific options for cones and cups:
- Plain cake cone: no extra charge
- Waffle cone: add $0.75
- Chocolate-dipped waffle cone: add $1.25
- Plain cup: no extra charge
Many customers choose the waffle cone because it adds a crunchy texture. The chocolate-dipped version is a popular upgrade for special occasions. If you are watching your budget, the cake cone or cup keeps costs lower.
Concrete Cones And Cups
A concrete is Andy’s signature item, blending custard with mix-ins like candy or fruit. The custard is so thick that the cup can be turned upside down without spilling. This is a fun party trick that Andy’s is known for.
Concrete prices are higher than plain custard because of the mix-ins. You can choose one mix-in for the base price, with additional mix-ins costing extra. Here is the pricing structure:
- Small concrete: $4.99
- Medium concrete: $5.79
- Large concrete: $6.59
- Each additional mix-in: $0.50
Popular mix-ins include Oreo pieces, M&M’s, and fresh strawberries. The concrete is a filling treat, so the small size is often enough for one person. The large can easily serve two.
Sundaes And Specialty Treats
Andy’s sundaes are layered with custard, hot fudge, caramel, or other toppings. They also offer specialty items like banana splits and sundaes with nuts. These are more elaborate than a simple cup or cone.
The sundae menu includes several classic options. Each sundae comes in one size, typically medium, unless specified otherwise. Here are the main sundae choices and their prices:
- Hot fudge sundae: $4.79
- Caramel sundae: $4.79
- Strawberry sundae: $4.79
- Pineapple sundae: $4.79
- Banana split: $6.29
- Brownie sundae: $5.49
The banana split is a larger portion with three scoops of custard and multiple toppings. The brownie sundae includes a warm brownie base, making it a richer option. All sundaes come with whipped cream and a cherry on top.
Andy’s Menu Prices For Shakes And Malts
Shakes and malts are blended drinks made with custard and milk. Malts include malted milk powder, which gives a slightly different flavor. Both are available in the same sizes as custard cups.
Here are the prices for shakes and malts:
- Small shake or malt: $4.49
- Medium shake or malt: $5.29
- Large shake or malt: $6.09
You can add mix-ins to shakes for an extra $0.50 per ingredient. Popular choices include chocolate chips, cookie dough, and peanut butter. Shakes are thick but drinkable through a straw, while malts are slightly thicker.
Floats And Freezes
Andy’s also offers floats, which combine custard with soda. The most common is the root beer float, but you can also choose cola or other flavors. Freezes are similar but blended into a slushy consistency.
Float and freeze prices are comparable to shakes. They come in the same three sizes:
- Small float or freeze: $4.49
- Medium float or freeze: $5.29
- Large float or freeze: $6.09
Root beer floats are a nostalgic favorite, especially during summer. Freezes are less common but offer a unique texture that some customers prefer. Both are refreshing options on hot days.
Andy’s Menu Prices For Kids
Andy’s has a dedicated kids menu with smaller portions and lower prices. These are designed for children under 12, but adults can order them too if they want a smaller treat. The kids menu includes cones, cups, and sundaes.
Here are the kids menu items and their prices:
- Kids cone or cup: $2.79
- Kids sundae: $3.49
- Kids concrete: $3.99
The kids sundae comes with one topping and whipped cream. The kids concrete includes one mix-in. These are great for young children or anyone who wants a small, affordable treat.
Seasonal And Limited-Time Offerings
Andy’s occasionally introduces seasonal flavors and special items. These might include pumpkin custard in the fall or peppermint in the winter. Prices for these items are usually the same as regular menu items, but some specialty sundaes may cost more.
Limited-time offerings are announced on Andy’s website and social media. They often feature unique combinations like candy cane crunch or eggnog custard. If you see a seasonal item you like, try it quickly because it won’t last long.
Some locations also offer holiday-themed sundaes with extra toppings. These can range from $5.49 to $7.99 depending on the complexity. Check with your local store for current seasonal options.
Toppings And Add-Ons
Andy’s allows you to customize your treat with various toppings. These include hot fudge, caramel, strawberry, pineapple, and butterscotch. You can also add nuts, sprinkles, or extra whipped cream.
Here are the prices for common toppings:
- Hot fudge or caramel: $0.75
- Strawberry or pineapple: $0.75
- Nuts (pecans or walnuts): $0.50
- Sprinkles: $0.25
- Extra whipped cream: $0.25
Adding multiple toppings can quickly increase the total cost. If you are on a budget, stick to one or two toppings. The sundaes already include toppings, so you may not need extras.
Andy’s Menu Prices Comparison With Competitors
Andy’s prices are competitive with other frozen custard chains like Culver’s and Freddy’s. Culver’s custard prices are similar, with a small concrete around $4.79. Freddy’s tends to be slightly cheaper, with small concretes at $4.49.
However, Andy’s uses a higher butterfat content in their custard, which some customers prefer. The quality difference justifies the slightly higher prices for many. Also, Andy’s portions are generous, so you get good value for your money.
Compared to ice cream shops like Dairy Queen, Andy’s is more expensive but offers a richer product. Dairy Queen’s small blizzard is about $4.29, while Andy’s small concrete is $4.99. The extra cost is worth it if you prioritize creaminess.
How To Save Money At Andy’s
There are a few ways to reduce your total bill at Andy’s. First, order a kids size if you only want a small treat. The kids cone at $2.79 is a great deal for a quick dessert.
Second, skip the waffle cone upgrade. The cake cone is free and still tastes good. You can also avoid extra toppings unless you really want them.
Third, look for coupons or promotions on Andy’s app or website. Some locations offer buy-one-get-one deals on certain days. Signing up for their email list can also get you occasional discounts.
Finally, consider sharing a large size with a friend. A large concrete at $6.59 is cheaper than two smalls at $4.99 each. Splitting a large saves you about $3.39.
Frequently Asked Questions About Andy’s Menu Prices
Are Andy’s Menu Prices The Same At All Locations?
Most Andy’s locations use the same base prices, but franchise stores may adjust slightly. Taxes also vary by state and city. Always check the menu board at your local store for exact prices.
Does Andy’s Offer Any Discounts For Seniors Or Military?
Some locations offer a small discount for seniors or military personnel, but this is not guaranteed. Ask at the counter if they have any specials. You might get 10% off on certain days.
Can I Order Andy’s Menu Items Online For Pickup?
Yes, many Andy’s locations accept online orders through their website or third-party apps. Prices are the same as in-store. You can pay online and pick up your order without waiting in line.
What Is The Most Expensive Item On Andy’s Menu?
The banana split at $6.29 is typically the most expensive regular item. Large concretes with multiple mix-ins can exceed $7.00. Seasonal sundaes may also be priced higher.
Do Andy’s Menu Prices Include Tax?
No, the listed prices do not include sales tax. Tax is added at checkout based on your location. Expect to pay an additional 5-10% depending on where you live.
Final Thoughts On Andy’s Menu Prices
Andy’s menu prices are fair for the quality and portion sizes you receive. The custard is thick, creamy, and made fresh daily. Whether you want a simple cone or a loaded sundae, there is an option for every budget.
Remember that the small sizes are often enough for one person, while large sizes work well for sharing. Adding toppings and upgrades increases the cost, so plan accordingly. With a little planning, you can enjoy Andy’s without overspending.
Next time you visit, use this guide to order confidently. Know what you want before you reach the counter, and you will leave satisfied. Andy’s is a treat worth every penny, especially on a hot summer day.
If you have questions about specific items not listed here, ask the staff at your local Andy’s. They are friendly and happy to help. Enjoy your custard!