Dairy Barn’s walk-up window faces the county fairgrounds, where the summer crowd reads the price board while waiting for their cones. You want the full Dairy Barn Menu with Prices before you step in line, and this guide gives you that exact breakdown. No guesswork, just the cold treats and hot food you can order today.
The menu changes slightly by season, but the core items stay the same all year. Below is a clear look at what costs what, so you can plan your order ahead of time.
Dairy Barn Menu With Prices
Prices here are current for the 2025 season. They do not include local sales tax, which is applied at the register. The barn accepts cash and all major credit cards, though there is a small fee for card payments under five dollars.
Ice Cream Cones And Cups
Every scoop is hand-dipped and comes from a local creamery. You can choose between a sugar cone, waffle cone, or a simple cup. The portions are generous, so a single scoop is often enough for most people.
- Kid’s Scoop (one small scoop) – $2.50
- Single Scoop – $3.75
- Double Scoop – $5.25
- Triple Scoop – $6.50
- Waffle Cone Upgrade – $0.75 extra
- Sprinkles or Dip Topping – $0.50 extra
Signature Sundaes
Sundaes come in a classic glass boat with whipped cream and a cherry on top. You can swap the vanilla base for chocolate or strawberry at no extra charge. Hot fudge and caramel are made in-house every morning.
- Hot Fudge Sundae – $4.95
- Caramel Pecan Sundae – $5.75
- Strawberry Shortcake Sundae – $6.25
- Brownie Bomb Sundae – $6.95
- Banana Split – $7.50
Shakes And Malts
These are thick enough to need a spoon at first, but they loosen up as you drink. All shakes come in vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, or a flavor of the week. Malts add a toasty malt powder for a deeper taste.
- Regular Shake (16 oz) – $4.75
- Large Shake (24 oz) – $6.25
- Regular Malt – $5.25
- Large Malt – $6.75
- Add a Shot of Espresso – $0.90
Frozen Treats And Novelties
If you want something lighter than a full sundae, the novelty case has plenty of options. These are pre-made and ready to grab without waiting in the main line. The freezer case is right next to the register.
- Ice Cream Sandwich – $3.25
- Fudge Bar – $2.75
- Fruit Pop – $2.50
- Chocolate-Dipped Banana – $3.50
- Push-Up Pop – $2.00
Hot Food And Snacks
The barn also runs a small grill from noon to close. These items pair well with a float or a simple scoop. The grill closes thirty minutes before the ice cream window, so plan accordingly.
- Classic Hot Dog – $3.50
- Chili Cheese Dog – $5.25
- Grilled Cheese – $4.00
- French Fries (small) – $2.75
- French Fries (large) – $4.00
- Soft Pretzel with Cheese – $4.50
Drinks And Floats
Floats are made with real soda from the fountain, not bottled versions. You can also order plain sodas, water, or fresh lemonade. The lemonade is squeezed daily and sells out most afternoons.
- Root Beer Float – $4.50
- Coke or Sprite Float – $4.50
- Fresh Lemonade (16 oz) – $3.00
- Bottled Water – $1.50
- Fountain Soda – $2.25
Deals And Combo Offers
Look for the daily special board near the window. On weekdays before 3 PM, you can get a single scoop and a small fries for $5.75. There is also a family pack on Sundays that includes a pint of ice cream and six cones for $12.00.
One thing to note: the prices listed here are slightly lower than the ones posted at the fairgrounds location during special events. That location adds a small surcharge during fair week. The main barn on Route 9 keeps these standard prices all season.
If you see a typo on the board or a price that seems off, just ask the cashier. They update the menu weekly and sometimes miss a change. The staff is friendly and will double-check the current price before you pay.
Now you have the full Dairy Barn Menu with Prices in front of you. Bring cash if you want to avoid the card fee, and go early on weekends because the line moves fast but the ice cream is worth the wait.