Carmellas Pizzeria Middletown Menu with Prices is exactly what you need before you call in that order. Carmellas Pizzeria Middletown has built its reputation on thick crust and thin margins, with a menu that rewards those who order by the pie. You get more value when you skip the single slices and go straight for the full tray.
Most locals agree that the regular crust is the way to go. It is crispy on the outside but still has that chewy bite inside. If you are feeding a crowd, the sheet pizza is the smart play because it feeds more people for less money per square inch.
Carmellas Pizzeria Middletown Menu With Prices
Below is the current breakdown of what you can expect to pay. These prices were last confirmed by a recent visit, but they can change without notice. Always call ahead to double-check before you drive over.
Pizza Prices By Size
- Small 12-inch cheese pizza: $10.50
- Medium 16-inch cheese pizza: $13.75
- Large 18-inch cheese pizza: $16.25
- Sheet pizza (feeds 6-8): $22.00
- Extra toppings on any size: $1.75 each
- Gluten-free crust (small only): add $3.00
You should know that the specialty pies are where the kitchen really shows off. The “Carmella Special” comes loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and extra mozzarella. It costs $19.50 for a large, which is fair given how heavy they pile the toppings.
Appetizers And Sides
- Garlic knots (8 pieces): $6.25
- Mozzarella sticks (6 pieces): $7.50
- Chicken wings (10 pieces): $11.00
- French fries with cheese: $5.75
- Side salad: $4.50
The garlic knots come with a side of marinara that tastes like it was simmered all day. They are a solid add-on if you are already ordering a pie.
Calzones And Strombolis
- Plain calzone (ricotta and mozzarella): $9.75
- Meat calzone: $12.50
- Pepperoni stromboli: $11.25
- Veggie stromboli: $11.00
These are big enough to split between two people if you also order a salad. The calzone dough is the same as the pizza crust, so you already know it is going to be good.
Pasta Dinners
- Spaghetti with marinara: $9.25
- Baked ziti: $10.50
- Chicken parmesan with pasta: $14.75
- Eggplant parmesan: $13.00
Each pasta dinner comes with a small side salad and one garlic knot. That makes the baked ziti a pretty good deal for under eleven bucks.
Sandwiches And Heroes
- Meatball hero: $9.50
- Sausage and peppers hero: $10.25
- Chicken cheesesteak: $11.75
- Eggplant hero: $9.00
All heroes are served on fresh bread that they get delivered daily from a local bakery. You can add fries to any sandwich for an extra $2.25.
Drinks And Desserts
- Canned soda: $1.50
- 2-liter bottle: $3.25
- Tiramisu (single serving): $5.50
- Cheesecake: $4.75
If you are ordering for pickup, grab a 2-liter instead of individual cans. It saves you a couple of bucks and goes further with a large pizza.
How To Order Smart
Follow these steps to get the most for your money at Carmellas:
- Order a large or sheet pizza instead of multiple smalls
- Stick to 1-2 toppings because they are generous with them
- Call your order in 20 minutes ahead to skip the wait
- Check if they have a lunch special before 2 PM on weekdays
There is also a combo deal on Tuesdays where you get a medium cheese pizza and a 10-piece wing order for $18.99. That is the best value on the whole menu if you ask me.
One thing to note is that they are cash only on orders under fifteen dollars. They have an ATM inside but it charges a fee, so bring cash if you are just grabbing a slice. The staff is friendly but they move fast, so have your order ready when you get to the counter.
Carmellas Pizzeria Middletown Menu with Prices is pretty straight forward once you see it all laid out. The prices are reasonable for the portion sizes, and the quality has stayed consistent over the years. Go with the sheet pizza if you are feeding a family, and do not skip the garlic knots. They are the sleeper hit on the menu.