For potbelly sandwich shop menu and prices: “Warm, toasted sandwiches stacked with fresh ingredients make Potbelly a go-to for a quick, affordable meal.” If you are looking for a reliable lunch spot that won’t break the bank, Potbelly Sandwich Shop is a solid choice. Their menu is simple, focusing on toasted subs, salads, and shakes, with prices that stay reasonable even in 2025. You can grab a classic sandwich, a side, and a drink for under $15, which is rare these days. Let’s break down everything you need to know about what they offer and what it costs.
Potbelly has been around since 1977, starting as a small antique shop in Chicago that also sold sandwiches. Today, it has grown into a nationwide chain with hundreds of locations. The menu has stayed true to its roots: warm, toasted bread, fresh veggies, and meats like roast beef, turkey, and meatballs. Prices vary slightly by location, but the core items stay consistent. Whether you are a first-timer or a regular, knowing the menu and prices helps you order with confidence.
Potbelly Sandwich Shop Menu And Prices
The main menu is built around four sandwich sizes: Original, Big, Wreck, and Skinny. Each size has its own price point, and you can customize almost everything. The Original is the standard size, about 6 inches. The Big is larger, closer to 9 inches. The Wreck is a signature sandwich loaded with meats. The Skinny is a lighter option with less bread and fewer calories. Prices for sandwiches range from about $6 to $10, depending on the size and protein.
Sandwich Categories And Core Offerings
Potbelly groups their sandwiches into categories: Classics, Signature, and Limited Time Offers. Classics include the Italian, Turkey Breast, and Roast Beef. Signature sandwiches are unique combos like the Wreck and the Avo Turkey. Limited Time Offers change seasonally, often featuring special meats or sauces. Each category has its own price structure, but generally, you pay a bit more for premium ingredients like avocado or double meat.
Classic Sandwiches
- Italian: Salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil, vinegar. Original: $6.50, Big: $8.50.
- Turkey Breast: Oven-roasted turkey, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Original: $6.25, Big: $8.25.
- Roast Beef: Thin-sliced roast beef, lettuce, tomato, horseradish sauce. Original: $7.00, Big: $9.00.
- Ham and Swiss: Smoked ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard. Original: $6.50, Big: $8.50.
Signature Sandwiches
- The Wreck: Roast beef, turkey, ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, mustard. Original: $7.50, Big: $9.50.
- Avo Turkey: Turkey breast, avocado, provolone, lettuce, tomato, chipotle mayo. Original: $7.75, Big: $9.75.
- Mediterranean: Feta cheese, hummus, cucumber, tomato, onion, lettuce, red pepper spread. Original: $6.75, Big: $8.75.
- Meatball: Italian meatballs, marinara, provolone, Parmesan. Original: $7.25, Big: $9.25.
Skinny Sandwiches
These are served on a thinner bread option, with fewer calories. They come with lettuce, tomato, and onion. Prices are slightly lower than the Original size.
- Skinny Turkey: $5.75
- Skinny Ham: $5.50
- Skinny Italian: $5.75
- Skinny Roast Beef: $6.00
Sides And Extras
You can add sides to your meal for a small upcharge. Popular options include chips, cookies, and pickles. Prices are around $1.50 to $2.50 per item. Combo meals that include a sandwich, side, and drink save you about a dollar compared to buying separately.
- Potbelly Chips: $1.75 (classic, BBQ, salt and vinegar)
- Cookie: $1.50 (chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, sugar)
- Pickle Spear: $1.25
- Side Salad: $3.00
Salads And Bowls
For lighter options, Potbelly offers salads and bowls. These are not as popular as sandwiches, but they are decent. Prices range from $7 to $9.
- Garden Salad: $7.00
- Caesar Salad: $7.50
- Grilled Chicken Salad: $8.50
- Power Bowl: $8.75 (quinoa, black beans, corn, avocado, chicken)
Shakes And Drinks
Potbelly is known for its hand-dipped milkshakes. They come in classic flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry. You can also get a malt or a float. Shakes are around $4.50 to $5.50. Soft drinks, iced tea, and lemonade are about $2.00 for a small.
- Vanilla Shake: $4.50
- Chocolate Shake: $4.50
- Strawberry Shake: $5.00
- Malt: $5.50
- Float: $5.00
- Soft Drink: $2.00 (small), $2.50 (medium), $3.00 (large)
Breakfast Menu
Some Potbelly locations serve breakfast from open until 11 AM. The breakfast menu includes egg sandwiches, oatmeal, and coffee. Prices are similar to lunch items, around $4 to $7.
- Bacon Egg and Cheese: $5.50
- Sausage Egg and Cheese: $5.75
- Veggie Egg Sandwich: $5.00
- Oatmeal: $3.50
- Coffee: $2.00 (small), $2.50 (medium)
Customization And Add-Ons
You can customize almost any sandwich. Extra meat costs about $2.00. Extra cheese is $1.00. Adding avocado is $1.50. You can also request your sandwich “hot” or “cold.” Hot means they toast it in the oven. Cold means they serve it as-is. Most people go for hot, as it brings out the flavors.
Pricing Variations By Location
Prices listed here are averages. In cities like New York or San Francisco, you might pay $1 to $2 more per item. In smaller towns, prices may be slightly lower. Always check the menu board at your local shop or use the Potbelly app for accurate pricing. The app also offers exclusive deals and rewards points.
Value Meals And Combos
Potbelly offers combo deals that bundle a sandwich, side, and drink. The “Original Combo” includes an Original sandwich, chips or cookie, and a small drink for about $8.50. The “Big Combo” is around $10.50. These combos save you about $1.50 compared to buying each item separately. If you are hungry, the Big Combo is a good value.
Nutritional Information
If you are watching calories, Potbelly provides nutritional info online. An Original Turkey sandwich has about 450 calories. A Big Wreck has around 700 calories. Skinny options are lower, around 300 calories. Shakes are high in sugar, so consider skipping them if you are dieting. Salads are a healthier choice, but watch the dressing.
How To Order Efficiently
Ordering at Potbelly is straightforward. Follow these steps for a smooth experience:
- Decide on your sandwich size: Original, Big, Skinny, or Wreck.
- Choose your bread: white, wheat, or rye. Some locations offer gluten-free wraps for an extra $1.00.
- Pick your protein: turkey, ham, roast beef, Italian meats, meatballs, or veggie.
- Select your cheese: provolone, Swiss, cheddar, or American.
- Add veggies: lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, banana peppers, jalapenos.
- Choose your sauce: mayo, mustard, honey mustard, chipotle mayo, oil and vinegar, or red pepper spread.
- Decide on hot or cold. Hot is recommended for most sandwiches.
- Add sides: chips, cookie, pickle, or salad.
- Pick a drink: soft drink, shake, or water.
- Pay at the counter. Cash and cards are accepted. The app also allows mobile ordering.
Tips For Saving Money
Potbelly runs promotions regularly. Sign up for their email list or download the app to get coupons. You can often find buy-one-get-one deals or discounts on combos. Also, consider ordering a Skinny sandwich if you want a smaller portion at a lower price. Skip the shake to save calories and cash.
Popular Menu Items According To Customers
Based on reviews and sales data, the most popular items are:
- The Wreck: A hearty mix of four meats and provolone.
- Italian: Classic combo of salami, pepperoni, and ham.
- Turkey Breast: Simple and reliable.
- Meatball: Rich and saucy.
- Chocolate Shake: Thick and creamy.
Comparison With Competitors
Compared to Subway, Potbelly is slightly more expensive but uses higher quality ingredients. Compared to Jersey Mike’s, Potbelly is similar in price but offers a warmer, toastier sandwich. Compared to Firehouse Subs, Potbelly is cheaper and has a simpler menu. Overall, Potbelly sits in the mid-range of fast-casual sandwich chains.
Seasonal And Limited Time Items
Potbelly introduces seasonal sandwiches a few times a year. For example, in the fall, they might offer a Turkey Cranberry sandwich. In summer, a BBQ Chicken sandwich. These are usually priced similarly to signature sandwiches, around $7 to $9. They are worth trying if you see them on the menu.
Allergen Information
Potbelly provides allergen guides on their website. Common allergens include wheat, dairy, soy, and eggs. If you have allergies, ask the staff to prepare your sandwich with clean utensils. They are generally accommodating, but cross-contamination is possible.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cheapest item on the Potbelly menu?
The cheapest item is the Skinny Ham sandwich at around $5.50. A small soft drink is $2.00. A cookie is $1.50. If you want a full meal, the Skinny combo is the most affordable.
Does Potbelly have a loyalty program?
Yes, Potbelly has a rewards program called Potbelly Perks. You earn points for every purchase. Points can be redeemed for free sandwiches, sides, or drinks. Sign up online or through the app.
Can I order Potbelly online for pickup or delivery?
Yes, you can order through the Potbelly app or website. Pickup is available at most locations. Delivery is offered through third-party services like DoorDash and Uber Eats, but prices may be slightly higher due to fees.
Are there vegetarian options at Potbelly?
Yes, the Mediterranean sandwich is vegetarian. You can also order a veggie salad or a grilled cheese. Ask for no meat on any sandwich to make it vegetarian. Some locations offer a veggie patty.
What are the hours of operation for Potbelly?
Most Potbelly locations are open from 10 AM to 9 PM, Monday through Sunday. Breakfast hours are from open until 11 AM. Hours vary by location, so check your local store’s website or call ahead.
Final Thoughts On The Potbelly Experience
Potbelly Sandwich Shop offers a straightforward menu with fair prices. The food is consistent, and the service is usually fast. If you want a warm, toasted sandwich without spending too much, this is a good option. The menu has something for everyone, from meat lovers to vegetarians. Just remember to check for deals and use the app to save a few bucks. Next time you are hungry for lunch, give Potbelly a try. You will likely find a sandwich that hits the spot.