Coney islands thrive on loyal regulars, and Classic Coney Cafe keeps them coming back with stable, printed pricing. If you are searching for the Classic Coney Cafe Menu with Prices before you visit, you are in the right place. We broke down the most ordered items so you can plan your meal without any surprises at the register.
Classic Coney Cafe Menu With Prices
Classic Coney Cafe does not change their menu every season. That is good news for you. The pricing below reflects the standard dine-in and take-out menu as of this year. Keep in mind that drink prices might shift a few cents depending on your local store location.
Breakfast Favorites
Breakfast is served all day here. That makes it easy for you to grab a morning plate even at 2 PM. Here are the core items and their usual costs.
- Two Eggs Any Style with Toast – $6.49
- Classic Pancake Stack (3 pieces) – $7.29
- Denver Omelette with Home Fries – $9.99
- Country Fried Steak and Eggs – $11.49
- Biscuits and Gravy (single serving) – $6.99
Signature Coney Dogs And Burgers
You cannot visit without trying the namesake dog. The chili recipe is consistent and slightly sweet. If you want a full meal, the burger combos are the better value.
- Single Coney Dog – $3.79
- Double Coney Dog – $5.49
- Bacon Cheeseburger (1/4 lb) – $8.99
- Double Smash Burger with Cheese – $10.79
- All combos add fries and a drink for $3.50 extra
Lunch Plates And Dinners
These plates come with your choice of two sides. The portions are generous, so you might have leftovers for later. Check the board for the daily meatloaf special, but the printed menu has steady options.
- Roast Turkey Dinner – $10.29
- Grilled Pork Chops (2 pieces) – $12.99
- Fish and Chips (3 pieces) – $9.79
- Chicken Stir Fry Bowl – $8.49
Salads And Light Bites
Not everyone wants a heavy plate. The cafe offers a few lighter choices that are still filling. The grilled chicken salad is a popular pick for regulars.
- Side Salad – $3.29
- Cobb Salad with Chicken – $9.49
- Tuna Salad Sandwich on Rye – $7.99
- Chicken Wrap with Chips – $7.49
Kid’s Menu
Kids eat for less here. Every kid’s meal includes a small drink and a side of fries or apple slices. The pricing is straightforward for parents.
- Mini Corn Dog (2 pieces) – $4.99
- Grilled Cheese – $4.49
- Spaghetti with Meat Sauce – $5.29
- Chicken Tenders (2 pieces) – $5.79
Desserts And Shakes
Save room for a shake. They make them thick with real ice cream. The hot fudge sundae is also a solid choice if you want something simpler.
- Hand-Spun Milkshake (Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry) – $4.99
- Hot Fudge Sundae – $4.49
- Slice of Homemade Pie (seasonal) – $3.99
Tips For Ordering
You can save a little money by skipping the combo and ordering water. Also, ask for the senior discount if you qualify, it is applied without a fuss. The menu prices are printed clearly, but the cashier will always confirm your total before you pay.
One thing to note, the prices listed here are for the standard menu. Some franchise locations add a small upcharge for extra chili or cheese. The printed menu at the counter is the final say. If you see a discrepancy, just point it out, they usually honor the printed board.
Bring cash if you want to avoid the small card fee. The line moves fast during lunch, so have your order ready. The Classic Coney Cafe menu with prices is simple enough to memorize after one visit, but this guide helps you get started.