Chelsea Pizza 2 Menu with Prices: “Chelsea Pizza 2 prices its pies by size and crust style, with specialty slices costing more than the plain cheese options on the board.” If you are looking for a quick bite in the neighborhood, this spot keeps things simple. You can order by the slice or grab a whole pie for the table.
The menu is straightforward, but the price differences can catch you off guard if you don’t plan ahead. Here is a breakdown of what you can expect to pay before you walk in.
Cheese And Plain Slices
The base of the menu is the regular cheese slice. This is your standard bar pie with mozzarella and a tangy tomato sauce. It is also the cheapest way to get a quick lunch.
- Plain Cheese Slice: $3.25
- Pepperoni Slice: $3.75
- Extra Cheese Slice: $3.75
You can also ask for a Sicilian slice, which is thicker and doughier. That usually runs about fifty cents more than the regular round slice.
Specialty Pies And Whole Cakes
If you are feeding a group, whole pies are the better value. The pricing here depends on whether you pick a red pie or a white pie.
- Small Cheese Pie (12″): $12.50
- Large Cheese Pie (18″): $18.00
- Large Pepperoni Pie: $21.50
- Grandma Slice: $4.25
Specialty pies like the Margherita or the Vodka pie start at $22.00 for a large. They use fresh mozzarella and a different sauce base, which explains the higher price point.
Toppings And Add-Ons
Adding toppings to a whole pie is not included in the base price. Each additional topping costs extra, so keep that in mind when you customize.
- Extra Topping (per pie): $2.50
- Gluten-Free Crust (small only): +$4.00
- Stuffed Crust: +$3.00
They do not offer a gluten-free option for the large size, so if you need that, you are stuck with the 12-inch pie.
Calzones, Sides, And Drinks
Beyond pizza, the menu includes a few sides that pair well with your order. These are listed on the board behind the counter, so do not be afraid to look up.
- Garlic Knots (6 pcs): $5.50
- Chicken Wings (6 pcs): $8.75
- Caesar Salad: $7.00
- Can of Soda: $1.50
- Bottled Water: $2.00
The calzone is a hidden gem on the menu. It is stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella, and it costs around $10.50. You can add pepperoni or sausage for an extra $1.75.
Combos And Lunch Specials
During the weekdays, they run a lunch special that is not advertised online. You have to ask for it at the register.
- Two slices and a soda: $8.99
- One slice and a side salad: $7.50
- Personal pie (8″) with one topping: $9.25
These deals are only available between 11:00 AM and 2:00 PM. After that, you pay the regular menu price.
Payment And Ordering Tips
Cash is still king at this location, but they do accept cards. There is a small fee if you use a credit card, so bring cash if you want to avoid the surcharge.
If you call ahead for pickup, the price on the phone is the same as the board. They do not have a delivery service, so you have to go there yourself.
One thing to note: the prices on the wall menu are not always updated. The cashier will tell you the current price when you order, so do not be shocked if it is a dollar higher than what is listed. It is a small local spot, so the menu board can lag behind the actual cost.
Overall, you are looking at a fair price for the portion size. A slice is filling enough for a snack, but you might need two if you are really hungry. Plan your order based on the pricing above and you will not have any surprises at the counter.