Carol of Casey’s built her pizza shop on the principle that a great slice shouldn’t require a second mortgage. When you look at the Carol Of Caseys Pizza Shop Menu with Prices, you will see fair deals that respect your wallet. This guide breaks down the full menu, so you know exactly what to order and what it will cost you.
Carol started this business with a simple goal. She wanted to serve the neighborhood food that tasted like a family recipe. Every item on the list reflects that homestyle touch, from the hand-tossed dough to the rich, slow-cooked sauce.
Carol Of Caseys Pizza Shop Menu With Prices
Below is the current price list, which is accurate as of this month. Please note that prices can shift slightly based on seasonal ingredient costs. It is always a good idea to call ahead for the daily special, but this gives you a solid baseline for budgeting your meal.
Signature Pizzas And Pricing
Carol’s pizzas come in three sizes: Small (10″), Medium (14″), and Large (16″). You can choose between a classic hand-tossed crust or a thinner, crispy style at no extra charge.
- Cheese Pizza: Small $9.99, Medium $12.99, Large $14.99
- Pepperoni Classic: Small $11.49, Medium $14.49, Large $16.99
- The Carol Special (Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushroom, Onion): Small $13.99, Medium $17.49, Large $19.99
- BBQ Chicken: Small $13.49, Medium $16.99, Large $19.49
- Veggie Delight: Small $12.99, Medium $15.99, Large $18.49
Gluten-free crusts are available for an additional $2.50 on any size. Vegan cheese is also an option, adding $3.00 to the base price.
Build Your Own Slice Bar
If you are eating alone or want a quick lunch, the slice bar is the best value. You can grab a single slice for $3.50 or a double slice for $6.00.
- Choose your base: Plain Cheese or Pepperoni.
- Add unlimited veggies from the hot bar (mushrooms, peppers, olives, onions).
- Pay at the counter and enjoy.
This option is very popular during the lunch rush, so get there before noon if you want the freshest selection.
Wings, Sides, And Salads
Pizza is the star, but the supporting cast is strong. The wings are baked, not fried, which keeps them crispy but lighter.
- Classic Wings (6 pcs): $7.99 / (12 pcs): $13.99
- Garlic Knots (8 pcs): $5.49
- Breadsticks with Marinara: $4.99
- House Salad (Large): $8.99
- Caesar Salad (Large): $8.49
Desserts And Drinks
Do not skip the dessert. The cannoli are filled fresh every morning. They often sell out by 7 PM.
- Cannoli (1 pc): $3.25
- Chocolate Chip Cookie (Giant): $2.75
- Soft Drinks (20 oz Bottle): $2.19
- Fresh Brewed Iced Tea: $2.49
Deals And Combos To Save Money
Carol knows that feeding a family is expensive. She offers a few specific combos that lower the total cost compared to buying items separately.
- The Family Feast: One Large 2-Topping Pizza + 12 Wings + 8 Garlic Knots for $29.99.
- The Lunch Box: Two Slices + Small Drink + Cookie for $7.99 (available 11 AM – 2 PM).
- Tuesday Special: 50% off all Medium Pizzas when you order online.
These deals are the best way to get the most food for your money. If you are feeding a crowd, the Family Feast is the way to go.
One thing to remmeber is that the prices listed here are for pick-up orders. If you use a third-party delivery app, the prices will be higher due to service fees. For the best value, call the shop directly and pick up your order yourself. You will save a few dollars and your pizza will be hotter when you get home.
Carol’s is located on the corner of 5th and Main. The parking lot is small, but there is usually street parking available right out front. They are open Tuesday through Sunday, closed on Mondays. If you have any questions about the menu or want to place a large order, just give them a call. The staff is friendly and they will make sure your order is right.