Heftys Coney Island sticks to its roots with coney dogs, burgers, and breakfast items served at diner-friendly prices. If your looking for the Heftys Coney Island Menu with Prices, this guide breaks down what you’ll pay for every meal of the day.
The menu stays simple on purpose. You get classic diner food, fast service, and prices that wont empty your wallet.
Heftys Coney Island Menu With Prices
Below is a breakdown of the most popular items. Prices can vary slightly by location, so treat these as close estimates.
Coney Dogs And Chili Favorites
- Coney Dog – $2.99
- Coney Dog with Cheese – $3.49
- Chili Cheese Fries – $4.99
- Loose Hamburger (Coney Style) – $5.49
- Chili Bowl – $4.29
The coney dog is the reason most people walk in. It’s cheap, filling, and covered in that signature chili sauce.
Burgers And Sandwiches
- Hamburger – $6.99
- Cheeseburger – $7.49
- Double Cheeseburger – $9.99
- Bacon Cheeseburger – $8.99
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich – $7.99
- BLT Sandwich – $5.99
- Fish Sandwich – $6.49
Burgers come with basic toppings. Adding fries turns any sandwich into a full meal for a few dollars more.
Breakfast Menu And Prices
- Two Eggs with Toast – $5.49
- Egg and Cheese Sandwich – $4.29
- Bacon and Egg Sandwich – $5.29
- Ham and Egg Sandwich – $5.29
- Western Omelette – $8.99
- Short Stack Pancakes – $5.99
- Full Stack Pancakes – $7.49
- Breakfast Combo (Eggs, Meat, Potatoes, Toast) – $9.49
Breakfast runs early. If you show up after the cutoff, you’ll have to wait until the next morning.
Sides And Extras
- French Fries – $2.99
- Onion Rings – $3.99
- Hash Browns – $2.49
- Side of Bacon – $3.49
- Side of Sausage – $3.49
- Toast – $1.99
Drinks And Desserts
- Coffee – $1.99
- Soft Drink – $2.29
- Orange Juice – $2.99
- Milkshake – $4.49
- Slice of Pie – $3.99
- Ice Cream Sundae – $3.49
How To Save Money At Heftys Coney Island
- Order the coney dog combo instead of separate items.
- Visit during breakfast hours for the lowest priced meals.
- Skip the drinks and ask for water if your watching your budget.
- Share a large fries between two people.
- Check for daily specials posted near the register.
Combo deals usually save you between one and two dollars. It adds up fast if you eat there often.
What Makes Heftys Coney Island Popular
Heftys has been a local staple for decades. The recipes havent changed much, and thats the point. People come back for the same coney sauce they remember from years ago.
Service is quick. Most orders are ready in under ten minutes, which makes it a good stop for a fast lunch break.
Final Thoughts
The Heftys Coney Island menu with prices stays affordable across breakfast, lunch, and dinner. You can eat a full meal here for under ten dollars, which is rare these days.
Next time your near a Heftys location, stop in and try the coney dog. It’s the item that built the brand, and it still holds up.