Thin-crust loyalists and deep-dish fans alike can settle the debate at Hartleys Pizza once they see how the menu and prices break down across sizes and toppings. This guide covers the full Hartleys Pizza Menu with Prices so you can plan your order before you call or walk in.
Prices can shift by location, so treat the numbers below as a close estimate. Most shops stay within a dollar or two of these figures.
Hartleys Pizza Menu With Prices
Hartleys keeps things simple. You pick a size, then a style, then your toppings. That makes the total easy to guess before you order.
Classic Pizza Sizes And Base Prices
- Small (10 inch): $9.99
- Medium (12 inch): $12.99
- Large (14 inch): $15.99
- X-Large (16 inch): $18.99
Cheese is the base price. Every extra topping adds to it.
Topping Prices
Toppings come in two tiers. Simple items cost less then premium ones.
- Veggies and basics (onions, peppers, mushrooms, olives): $1.25 each
- Meats and premium items (pepperoni, sausage, bacon, chicken): $1.75 each
- Extra cheese: $1.50
A large pepperoni and mushroom pie, for example, lands near $19.49. A loaded meat lovers can push past $23.
Specialty Pies
- Margherita: $13.99 (medium)
- BBQ Chicken: $16.99 (medium)
- Veggie Supreme: $15.99 (medium)
- Meat Lovers: $17.99 (medium)
Specialty pies already include their toppings. You save a bit versus building your own.
Sides, Drinks, And Extras
- Garlic knots (6): $4.99
- Cheesy bread: $6.49
- Chicken wings (8): $9.99
- Caesar salad: $5.99
- 2-liter soda: $2.99
- Canned drinks: $1.49
Deals And Combos
Hartleys runs a few standing deals. They change by day, so ask when you order.
- Two medium pizzas with two toppings: $24.99
- Large pizza, wings, and a 2-liter: $27.99
- Family combo (two larges and breadsticks): $34.99
How To Order And Save
Follow these steps to keep your total low.
- Pick the deal that matches your group size first.
- Compare a specialty pie against a build-your-own.
- Add sides only if the combo does not already include them.
- Call the shop direct for pickup specials.
Pickup usually costs less than delivery. Delivery fees run about $3 to $5, plus a small service charge in some areas.
What Affects The Final Price
Your total depends on a few things:
- Store location and local taxes
- Crust style (stuffed crust adds around $2)
- Number of toppings
- Delivery versus pickup
Taxes add roughly 6 to 10 percent depending on your state. A $20 order can end up near $22 after tax and tip.
Quick Tips Before You Order
- Check the app for coupon codes.
- Ask about the daily special.
- Order the larger size if you want leftovers, the per-slice cost is lower.
- Confirm prices by phone since menus update often.
Now you have a clear picture of what to expect. Use this breakdown to build your order, compare deals, and avoid surprises at checkout.