Few things divide a family faster than pizza toppings, but this menu offers common ground for every sibling. If you are trying to figure out what to order without breaking the bank, checking the Brothers Of New York Pizza Menu with Prices is your first smart move. The good news is that this spot keeps things simple, classic, and honest to the New York style.
You do not need to guess what a slice will cost. The prices are straightforward, and the portions are generous. Let us walk through the main categories so you can plan your next order with confidence.
Brothers Of New York Pizza Menu With Prices
This is the section you came for. The menu is split into classic pies, specialty pies, and sides. Below, you will find the standard pricing structure that most locations follow. Remember that delivery apps might add a small markup, so calling directly often saves you a couple of bucks.
Classic Cheese And Pepperoni Pies
You cannot go wrong with the basics. These are the slices that taste like they came straight from a Brooklyn corner joint.
- Small Cheese Pie (12″) – $12.99
- Large Cheese Pie (18″) – $18.99
- Small Pepperoni Pie (12″) – $14.99
- Large Pepperoni Pie (18″) – $21.99
- Single Cheese Slice – $3.50
- Single Pepperoni Slice – $4.00
If you are feeding two people, a small pie is enough. For a family gathering, go straight for the large. The crust is thin, foldable, and holds up well.
Specialty Pies Worth Trying
These options add a little flair without getting too fancy. Each one is priced for a large 18-inch pie unless noted.
- Margherita Pie – $22.99
- White Pie (Ricotta & Mozzarella) – $23.99
- BBQ Chicken Pie – $25.99
- Supreme Pie (Pepperoni, Sausage, Peppers, Onions) – $26.99
- Meat Lovers Pie – $27.99
The White Pie is a sleeper hit. It is creamy, garlicky, and does not need tomato sauce to shine.
Calzones And Stromboli
Sometimes you want the filling folded into the dough. These are baked fresh and come with a side of marinara.
- Cheese Calzone – $10.99
- Pepperoni Calzone – $12.49
- Chicken Stromboli – $13.99
- Veggie Stromboli – $12.99
Each one is big enough for a full meal. Split one with a friend if you are also grabbing a salad.
Wings, Sides, And Drinks
Pizza is the star, but the sides hold their own. Prices are friendly for adding extras to your order.
- Buffalo Wings (6 pcs) – $8.99
- Garlic Knots (6 pcs) – $5.99
- Garlic Bread with Cheese – $6.49
- House Salad – $7.99
- 2-Liter Soda – $3.49
- Can of Soda – $1.99
The garlic knots are a must-buy. They come drenched in butter and herbs, and the price is hard to beat.
Deals And Combos To Save Money
If you are ordering for a group, look for the combo deals. They are not always printed on the main menu, so ask when you call.
- Large Cheese Pie + 6 Wings + 2-Liter Soda – $29.99
- Two Large Specialty Pies – $45.00
- Large Pie + Garlic Knots + Salad – $27.99
These combos shift slightly by location. It is worth asking if they have a current special that is not listed online.
How To Order And Check Local Prices
Prices can vary by a dollar or two depending on the franchise location. Here is the best way to get accurate numbers.
- Visit the official website for your nearest store.
- Call the store directly and ask for the menu with current prices.
- Check third-party delivery apps for real-time pricing, but expect a service fee.
Do not forget to ask about lunch specials. Many locations offer a two-slice deal with a drink for around $8.99 before 3 PM.
One thing to note: the menu is not overly complicated. That is a good thing. You will not find weird fusion toppings or overpriced artisanal nonsense. It is just solid pizza at a fair price.
The portions are big, so do not over-order. A large pie easily feeds three to four people if you also get a side. If you are a light eater, leftovers reheat well in a skillet the next day.
So next time the family argues over dinner, pull up this menu and settle it fast. Everyone finds somthing they like, and the prices keep the peace. Order the large pepperoni, grab some garlic knots, and call it a win.