The menu prices at Benny’s Pizza tell a story of dough fermentation times and imported San Marzano tomatoes. If you are looking for the Bennys Pizza Menu with Prices before you call, you are in the right place. We have broken down the costs so you know exactly what to expect when you order.
Benny’s keeps things simple. They focus on classic pies, fresh toppings, and a few hearty sides. You won’t find crazy experimental dishes here. Instead, you get consistent quality for a fair price.
Bennys Pizza Menu With Prices
Below is the current price list for their most popular items. Remember that prices can shift slightly based on location or delivery fees. It is always smart to confirm when you place the order.
Classic Cheese And Tomato Pies
This is the base of everything. The sauce is bright and the crust has a nice chew.
- Small 12″ Cheese Pizza – $12.50
- Medium 14″ Cheese Pizza – $15.75
- Large 16″ Cheese Pizza – $18.95
- Extra Cheese (any size) – $2.50
Specialty Signature Pizzas
These pies come fully loaded. You don’t need to add anything else to them.
- The Benny Special (Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers) – Large $24.50
- Margherita D.O.C. (Fresh mozzarella, basil) – Medium $19.00
- Spicy Diavola (Spicy salami, hot honey) – Large $23.75
- White Pie (Ricotta, garlic, mozzarella) – Medium $20.25
Build Your Own Toppings
If you want to customize, each topping costs the same amount. This makes budgeting easy.
- Choose your size (Small, Medium, Large).
- Pick your sauce (Red, White, or BBQ).
- Add toppings for $2.00 each.
Popular topping choices include pepperoni, Italian sausage, fresh garlic, and roasted red peppers. They also have vegan cheese available for an extra $3.00.
Sides And Appetizers
You will want some starters while you wait for the main pie.
- Garlic Knots (8 pieces) – $6.50
- House Salad (Large, feeds 3) – $9.75
- Chicken Wings (10 pieces, choice of sauce) – $13.25
- Breadsticks with Marinara – $5.95
Drinks And Desserts
They carry standard sodas and a few Italian sodas. For dessert, the tiramisu is the standout.
- Canned Soda – $2.00
- Italian Soda (Blood Orange or Lemon) – $3.50
- Tiramisu (Single serving) – $6.00
- Canoli (2 pieces) – $5.50
Deals And Combos
Benny’s offers a Tuesday night special. You can get a large cheese pizza and a salad for $22.99. They also do a family bundle for $45.00 that includes two large pies and a dozen wings. This is the best value if you are feeding a crowd.
One thing to note is that delivery prices are higher than pickup. The menu prices listed above are for pickup orders. If you want it delivered, expect a $3.00 service fee plus tip for the driver. They also charge a small packaging fee for online orders, usually around $0.50.
If you are watching your budget, the slice counter is a great option. You can get a large slice of cheese for $3.75. Pepperoni slices are $4.25. They are open until 11 PM on weekends, so this is a solid late-night stop.
We hope this guide to the Bennys Pizza Menu with Prices helps you plan your meal. The quality is high for the cost, especially compared to national chains. Go ahead and call in your order. Your stomach will thank you later.