Scanning a bagel menu for the first time can feel overwhelming with all the flavor combinations available, so this price guide breaks down every option clearly. If you are looking for the Bagels On Broadway Menu with Prices, you have landed in the right spot. We have organized the costs and portions so you can order with confidence, whether you are a local or just visiting for the day.
This spot is known for hand-rolled bagels and generous schmears. Below, you will find the current standard pricing for their most popular items. Keep in mind that prices can shift slightly based on the season or specific daily specials, but this gives you a solid baseline for budgeting your meal.
Bagels On Broadway Menu With Prices
Here is the full breakdown of the standard menu categories. You will notice that the pricing structure is simple, which makes it easy to mix and match your order without doing complex math at the counter.
Classic Bagels And Spreads
These are the building blocks of any good bagel shop visit. You can get them toasted or untoasted, and they always come out fresh.
- Plain Bagel (single) – $1.85
- Everything Bagel (single) – $1.85
- Multigrain Bagel (single) – $2.10
- Baker’s Dozen (13 plain or assorted) – $19.50
- Schmear (Plain Cream Cheese) – $2.25
- Flavored Cream Cheese (Scallion, Veggie, or Strawberry) – $3.00
Specialty Breakfast Sandwiches
These are the heavier options that work well for lunch too. They are served on your choice of bagel unless you request otherwise. The kitchen builds them fast, so they are great for a quick pickup.
- The Broadway Classic (Egg, Cheese, Bacon) – $8.75
- Smoked Lox Sandwich (Lox, Capers, Red Onion, Tomato) – $14.50
- Veggie Delight (Avocado, Spinach, Tomato, Swiss) – $9.25
- Turkey Club Bagel (Turkey, Lettuce, Mayo, Provolone) – $10.95
Build Your Own Combo
If you want to customize, follow these simple steps to get exactly what you want without confusing the cashier.
- Choose your bagel base from the classic list above.
- Pick your protein (Egg, Tofu, Turkey, or Bacon) for an additional $3.50.
- Add your cheese (Cheddar, Swiss, or American) for $1.00.
- Select unlimited standard veggies (Onion, Lettuce, Tomato) at no extra cost.
One thing to watch out for is the “Premium Toppings” section. Items like imported lox or guacamole carry a higher upcharge. The menu board lists these clearly, but it is easy to miss them if you are in a hurry. Always double check your receipt before you step away from the register.
Beverages And Sides
You can round out your meal with a drink or a side salad. These prices are consistent across all their locations.
- Fresh Brewed Coffee (12 oz) – $2.50
- Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice – $4.75
- Side of Fruit (Seasonal) – $3.95
- Potato Salad (Small Cup) – $3.25
If you are ordering for a group, the baker’s dozen is the best value. However, if you want variety, you can mix and match the single bagels to try different flavors. The staff is usually happy to split a dozen into separate bags if you ask nicely.
Prices are subject to change, so it is always a good idea to check the official menu board if you need exact figures. The portions are quite filling, so a single sandwich is often enough for most people. I have been here several times and the quality is consistent, though the line can get long during the morning rush on weekends.
That covers the main items. If you see a daily special board near the counter, those prices are usually listed separately and are not included in this guide. Enjoy your meal, and remember to grab extra napkins because the schmear can get messy.