When you are feeding a family of four on a Saturday morning, the per-dozen pricing at this shop becomes the most important number on the entire menu. You need to know exactly what a Bagelicious Bagels Menu with Prices looks like before you walk in the door. This guide breaks down the costs, the combos, and the best ways to order without any surprises at the register.
Bagelicious Bagels Menu With Prices
Bagelicious keeps things simple. They focus on fresh dough, boiled daily, and baked in small batches. You will not find a massive wall of confusing options here. Instead, you get a clear list of bagels, schmears, and breakfast sandwiches. Below is the current price structure, which was last updated this month.
Single Bagels And Spreads
If you only need a quick bite, the single item pricing is fair. But remember, the per-unit cost drops significantly when you buy in bulk.
- Plain, Everything, Sesame, Poppy, or Cinnamon Raisin: $1.25 each
- Specialty Bagels (Asiago, Jalapeno Cheddar, Salt): $1.75 each
- Regular Cream Cheese (Plain or Veggie): $1.50 per serving
- Flavored Schmears (Honey Walnut, Chive, Strawberry): $2.00 per serving
- Butter or Jelly: $0.75
Dozen Deals And Family Packs
This is where the real savings appear. If you are feeding more than two people, skip the singles entirely. The dozen pricing is the anchor of the whole menu.
- Dozen Assorted Regular Bagels: $10.99 (Save $4.01 vs. singles)
- Dozen Specialty Bagels: $15.99
- Dozen with Two Tub Schmears: $14.99
- Bagel Box (18 bagels, 3 tubs, serves 6-8): $22.99
Breakfast Sandwiches
They build these to order on any bagel you choose. The egg is always cooked fresh, never from a pre-made patty. You can swap bacon for sausage or add avocado for a small upcharge.
- Egg and Cheese: $4.49
- Bacon, Egg, and Cheese: $5.79
- Sausage, Egg, and Cheese: $5.99
- Turkey Sausage, Egg, and White Cheddar: $6.29
- Veggie Deluxe (Spinach, Tomato, Onion, Egg): $6.49
Coffee And Drinks
Bagelicious uses a local roaster. The coffee is strong but not bitter. They also offer fresh squeezed orange juice on weekends only.
- Small Coffee: $2.25
- Medium Coffee: $2.75
- Large Coffee: $3.25
- Cold Brew: $3.75
- Bottled Water or Soda: $1.99
How To Order For The Best Value
You can save money if you follow a few simple rules. Do not order individual bagels if you need more than three. The math is clear.
- Count your guests first. If you have 4 people, buy the Dozen with Schmears.
- Ask for “sliced and toasted” if you plan to eat within the hour. They will do it for free.
- Check the day-old rack. It is 50% off and perfect for making croutons or bread pudding.
- Order online through their website to skip the line. The prices are identical to in-store.
- Bring cash. They offer a 5% discount on cash transactions over $20.
Customization Charges To Watch
Some add-ons are free, but others cost extra. Be aware before you order so your total does not spike unexpectedly.
- Extra Egg on any sandwich: $1.00
- Avocado Spread: $1.50
- Gluten-Free Bagel (limited supply): +$2.00 per bagel
- Toasting a single bagel: Free
- Cutting a dozen into halves: Free
Hours And Location Notes
They open at 6:00 AM on weekdays and 7:00 AM on weekends. They close at 2:00 PM sharp, or earlier if they sell out of dough. The shop is located at 412 Main Street, next to the old bank building. There is limited street parking, but a free lot is behind the store.
One last tip. The menu prices listed here are accurate for the downtown location. The airport kiosk charges a 15% surcharge on all items. If you are near the main shop, you get the better deal. Also, they sometimes run a “Tuesday Two Dozen” special for $19.99, but it is not advertised in store. Just ask at the counter.
That is the full breakdown. You now have the exact numbers to plan your next breakfast run. Bring a friend if you are buying a dozen, because you will not finish it alone. And remember, the cream cheese is always served cold on the side unless you ask for it schmeared.