Some pizza joints change hands over the years, but Alfies Pizza has maintained consistent menu prices while preserving its original recipes. You can check the Alfies Pizza Menu with Prices before you even grab a seat, which makes ordering fast and stress-free. Whether you are a first-timer or a regular, knowing what you will pay helps you plan a solid meal without surprises.
Below is a clear breakdown of what you can order today, including current pricing for pies, sides, and drinks.
Alfies Pizza Menu With Prices
Alfies keeps things simple. They focus on classic pizzas, fresh toppings, and a few hearty sides. Prices have stayed steady for the last few seasons, which is rare in the pizza business. Here is the full rundown.
Classic Pizzas And Pricing
All pizzas come in two sizes: Medium (12″) and Large (16″). You can also order a personal 10″ pie for lunch. The crust is hand-tossed daily, and the sauce is the same recipe from the original owner.
- Cheese Pizza – Medium $12.99 / Large $16.99
- Pepperoni – Medium $14.49 / Large $18.49
- Sausage & Mushroom – Medium $15.49 / Large $19.99
- Supreme (pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, olives) – Medium $17.99 / Large $22.49
- BBQ Chicken – Medium $16.99 / Large $21.49
- Veggie Delight – Medium $15.99 / Large $20.49
Each pizza includes mozzarella and your choice of red or white sauce. No extra charge for thin crust. Gluten-free dough adds $2.50 to any size.
Specialty Pies Worth Trying
If you want something beyond the standard menu, Alfies offers three signature pies. These are the ones locals talk about.
- Alfies Original – Double pepperoni, extra cheese, and a honey drizzle. Medium $18.99 / Large $23.99
- Meat Lovers – Bacon, ham, sausage, and beef. Medium $19.49 / Large $24.99
- White Garlic Pie – Ricotta, garlic butter, and spinach. Medium $17.49 / Large $22.99
Add any extra topping for $1.75 on a medium and $2.25 on a large. Bacon and anchovies are slightly more at $2.00 and $2.50 respectively.
Sides, Salads, And Drinks
You can round out your order with a few simple sides. Portions are generous, so sharing is easy.
- Garlic Knots (8 pieces) – $6.49
- Breadsticks with marinara – $5.99
- Chicken Wings (6 or 12) – $8.99 / $15.49
- House Salad – $7.49
- Caesar Salad – $7.99
- 2-Liter Soda – $3.49
- Can of Soda – $1.79
Wings come in mild, hot, or BBQ. Ranch or blue cheese dressing is an extra $0.75 per cup. Salads do not include chicken by default, but you can add grilled chicken for $3.00.
Deals And Combos
Alfies offers a few bundles that save you a couple of bucks. These are not advertised heavily, so you have to ask or check the counter board.
- Lunch Special (11am–2pm, Mon–Fri): Personal cheese pizza, small salad, and a drink for $9.99
- Family Deal: One large two-topping pizza, 8 garlic knots, and a 2-liter soda for $27.99
- Wing & Pizza Combo: Large cheese pizza plus 6 wings for $23.49
These deals are solid if you are feeding a group or just want leftovers for tomorrow.
How To Order And Pay
You can order online, by phone, or in person. The online menu shows the same Alfies Pizza Menu with Prices, so there is no confusion between platforms. They accept cash, all major credit cards, and contactless payments.
Delivery is available within a 5-mile radius. The fee is $2.99, and there is no minimum order. Pickup orders are usually ready in 15 to 20 minutes. If you call ahead, you can skip the line entirely.
One small note: the prices listed here were accurate at the time of writing. The owner sometimes runs a weekly special on Wednesdays, but that is the only time you will see a discount. Otherwise, the menu stays the same all year round.
So next time you are thinking about pizza, you already know what to expect. Grab the menu, pick your toppings, and enjoy a slice that has not changed in all the right ways.