At Peter Luger Steakhouse in Brooklyn, the porterhouse for two comes with creamed spinach, and menu prices vary by cut size. If you are looking for the latest Peter Luger Steakhouse Brooklyn menu prices, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down every cost, portion, and tip for dining at this iconic spot.
Peter Luger is not just a steakhouse; it is a Brooklyn institution. Since 1887, it has served some of the best dry-aged steaks in the country. But the prices can be confusing because they change based on market rates and the size of the steak you order. Here is exactly what you need to know before you go.
Peter Luger Steakhouse Brooklyn Menu Prices
Understanding the pricing structure is key. The menu is simple, but the costs are not always listed clearly online. The most famous item is the Porterhouse for two, but you can also order for three or four people. Prices are per person, and they include the steak plus two sides.
Here is a breakdown of the current prices as of late 2023. Keep in mind that these can shift slightly due to beef market fluctuations. Always check the menu at the restaurant for the most up-to-date numbers.
- Porterhouse for Two: Approximately $120–$140 per person (includes steak, creamed spinach, and choice of potato).
- Porterhouse for Three: Approximately $110–$130 per person (includes steak, creamed spinach, and choice of potato).
- Porterhouse for Four: Approximately $100–$120 per person (includes steak, creamed spinach, and choice of potato).
- Steak for One (Filet Mignon or Sirloin): $55–$75 per steak (sides ordered separately).
- Burger (Luger Burger): $18–$22 (served with fries).
- Appetizers (Shrimp Cocktail, Bacon, Onion Rings): $12–$25 each.
- Desserts (Cheesecake, Ice Cream): $10–$15 each.
Notice that the per-person price drops slightly for larger groups. That is because the steak is cut thicker for more people, but the sides are shared. The porterhouse for two is the most popular choice and the best value for two hungry adults.
What Is Included In The Price
When you order the Porterhouse for two, three, or four, the price includes the steak plus two sides: creamed spinach and your choice of potato (baked, french fries, or hash browns). You do not pay extra for these sides. However, if you want additional sides like onion rings or extra vegetables, those are charged separately.
The steak itself is a massive cut of dry-aged beef. It is cooked to medium-rare unless you specify otherwise. The kitchen does not offer well-done steaks, so plan accordingly. The price reflects the quality of the aging process and the size of the portion.
How To Order To Control Costs
If you are on a budget, there are ways to enjoy Peter Luger without spending a fortune. First, consider going for lunch instead of dinner. Lunch prices are often slightly lower, and the portions are the same. Second, share the Porterhouse for two among three people if you are not huge eaters. The steak is generous enough for three moderate appetites.
Another option is to order a steak for one. The filet mignon or sirloin is smaller and cheaper, but you will need to buy sides separately. That can add up quickly, so it is often better to go with the Porterhouse for two if you are dining with someone else.
Appetizers And Sides Prices
Appetizers at Peter Luger are classic and simple. The most famous starter is the thick-cut bacon, which is caramelized and served with a tangy sauce. It is a must-try for first-timers. Here are the typical prices for appetizers and sides.
- Bacon (4 slices): $14–$18
- Shrimp Cocktail (4 jumbo shrimp): $20–$25
- Onion Rings (large portion): $12–$15
- Tomato and Onion Salad: $10–$12
- Extra Creamed Spinach: $10–$12
- Extra Potato (baked, fries, or hash browns): $8–$10
- German Fried Potatoes: $10–$12
The bacon is a standout. It is thick, smoky, and sweet. Many people order it as an appetizer to share. The shrimp cocktail is also excellent, with large, cold shrimp and a spicy cocktail sauce. Onion rings are crispy and not greasy, but they are a bit pricey for what you get.
Drinks And Beverages Costs
Peter Luger has a full bar, but drinks are not cheap. Beer and wine are available, and the cocktail list is short but classic. If you want to save money, stick with water or soda. Here are average drink prices.
- Beer (bottle or draft): $8–$12
- Glass of Wine (house red or white): $12–$18
- Cocktails (Manhattan, Martini): $15–$20
- Soft Drinks (Coke, Diet Coke): $4–$5
- Coffee or Tea: $4–$5
The house wine is decent and pairs well with the steak. If you are a wine lover, you can order a bottle, but that will add significantly to your bill. The cocktail menu is limited, but the bartenders make a solid Manhattan.
Dessert Menu Prices
After a heavy steak dinner, you might not have room for dessert, but the options are worth considering. The cheesecake is famous and very rich. The ice cream is also good, but it is simple. Here are the dessert prices.
- New York Cheesecake: $12–$15
- Ice Cream (vanilla, chocolate, strawberry): $8–$10
- Hot Fudge Sundae: $12–$15
- Apple Strudel: $10–$12
The cheesecake is the standout. It is dense, creamy, and served with a strawberry topping. The hot fudge sundae is also popular, especially for sharing. If you are too full, skip dessert and save room for the complimentary chocolate coins they give at the end of the meal.
Tips For Saving Money At Peter Luger
Dining at Peter Luger can be expensive, but there are a few tricks to keep the bill manageable. First, go with a group. The per-person price drops for larger Porterhouse orders. Second, skip the appetizers if you are on a tight budget. The steak and sides are filling enough.
Third, do not order extra sides unless you really want them. The included creamed spinach and potato are plenty for two people. Fourth, drink water instead of alcohol. That alone can save you $30–$50 per person. Finally, consider going for lunch on a weekday when the restaurant is less crowded and service is faster.
Peter Luger Steakhouse Brooklyn Menu Prices For Special Events
If you are planning a birthday, anniversary, or business dinner, Peter Luger can accommodate large parties. They have private dining rooms upstairs. However, the prices for these events are the same as the regular menu. There is no special event pricing, but you may need to pre-order for large groups.
For parties of six or more, the restaurant automatically adds an 18% gratuity to the bill. Keep that in mind when calculating your total cost. Also, they do not split checks for large groups, so be prepared to pay together or use a payment app.
How To Make A Reservation
Reservations are essential at Peter Luger. They do not accept walk-ins for dinner, and weekends book up weeks in advance. You can call the restaurant directly or use their online reservation system. Be prepared to give a credit card number to hold the reservation. If you cancel less than 24 hours in advance, you may be charged a fee.
For lunch, reservations are easier to get, but still recommended. The restaurant is located at 178 Broadway in Brooklyn, near the Williamsburg Bridge. Parking is limited, so take a cab or subway. The nearest subway stop is Marcy Avenue on the J, M, or Z lines.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the price range for the Porterhouse for two at Peter Luger?
A: The Porterhouse for two typically costs between $120 and $140 per person, including creamed spinach and a choice of potato.
Q: Are Peter Luger Steakhouse Brooklyn menu prices the same for lunch and dinner?
A: Lunch prices are generally the same as dinner, but some specials may be available at lunch. The steak prices do not change between meals.
Q: Does Peter Luger offer any discounts or coupons?
A: No, Peter Luger does not offer discounts or coupons. They are a cash-only restaurant (though they accept debit cards). Bring cash to avoid ATM fees.
Q: Can I order a steak for one person at Peter Luger?
A: Yes, you can order a filet mignon or sirloin for one person. Prices range from $55 to $75, and sides are ordered separately.
Q: Is the price of the steak the same for takeout?
A: Takeout prices are the same as dine-in prices. However, the steak is not as good when reheated, so it is best to eat at the restaurant.
Final Thoughts On Pricing
Peter Luger Steakhouse Brooklyn menu prices are high, but the quality justifies the cost. The dry-aged beef is some of the best you will ever taste. The service is old-school and efficient. The atmosphere is classic and unpretentious. If you are looking for a memorable steak dinner, this is the place.
Just remember to bring cash, make a reservation, and come hungry. The portions are huge, and you will likely have leftovers. They will pack up your steak in a doggie bag with their signature sauce. That is a nice touch.
One thing to note: the restaurant is cash-only for the bill, but they do accept debit cards. However, they do not accept credit cards. There is an ATM inside, but it charges a fee. Plan ahead to avoid extra costs.
Overall, the experience is worth the price. You are paying for tradition, quality, and a meal that you will remember for years. If you can afford it, go for the Porterhouse for two. If you are on a budget, try the burger or a steak for one. Either way, you will leave satisfied.
Now you have all the information you need about Peter Luger Steakhouse Brooklyn menu prices. Go enjoy a fantastic steak dinner without any surprises.