Yoder’s buffet menu and prices in Sarasota offer Amish-style comfort food with daily rotating specials. If you are looking for hearty, homestyle meals in a welcoming setting, this is a place worth knowing about. The restaurant has been a local favorite for years, serving up classic dishes that remind you of grandma’s cooking. You can expect generous portions and a relaxed atmosphere where families gather to share a meal.
When you walk in, the smell of fresh-baked bread and roasted meats hits you right away. The buffet line stretches out with steaming trays of food, from fried chicken to mashed potatoes. Prices are reasonable for the amount of food you get, making it a good value for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Let’s break down what you can expect from the menu and what it will cost you.
Yoder’s Buffet Menu And Prices
The buffet at Yoder’s changes daily, but some staples are always available. You will find a mix of Amish favorites and Southern classics. The menu focuses on fresh ingredients and simple preparation. No fancy sauces or complicated dishes here—just good, honest food.
Prices vary depending on the meal time and day of the week. Breakfast is the most affordable option, while dinner specials might cost a bit more. Kids eat for less, and seniors get a small discount too. Below is a breakdown of what you can typically expect.
Breakfast Buffet Options
Breakfast is served from early morning until 11 a.m. The buffet includes scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage, and made-to-order omelets. You will also find pancakes, French toast, and fresh fruit. Grits and oatmeal are available for a warm start to your day.
- Scrambled eggs and cheese grits
- Bacon, sausage links, and ham
- Pancakes with syrup and butter
- Freshly baked biscuits and gravy
- Seasonal fruit and yogurt
Prices for breakfast buffet are around $12.99 for adults. Kids under 10 pay $7.99. Seniors get a slight reduction at $10.99. Coffee and juice are included in the price, so you don’t have to worry about extra charges.
Lunch Buffet Selections
Lunch starts at 11 a.m. and runs until 2 p.m. The buffet switches to heartier options like fried chicken, meatloaf, and roast beef. Vegetables change daily but often include green beans, corn, and coleslaw. You can also find a salad bar with fresh toppings.
- Fried chicken with mashed potatoes and gravy
- Meatloaf with tomato glaze
- Roast beef with au jus
- Macaroni and cheese
- Seasonal vegetables like green beans or carrots
Lunch buffet costs $14.99 per adult. Kids pay $8.99, and seniors pay $12.99. Dessert is sometimes included, but you can also order pie from the bakery separately.
Dinner Buffet Highlights
Dinner is the main event at Yoder’s. The buffet expands with more options like ham, turkey, and fish. Specials change nightly, so you might find pot roast on Monday and baked fish on Friday. The dinner buffet runs from 2 p.m. until closing.
- Roasted turkey with stuffing and cranberry sauce
- Glazed ham with pineapple
- Baked fish with lemon butter
- Prime rib on weekends (limited availability)
- Homemade soups like chicken noodle or vegetable
Dinner prices are $17.99 for adults. Kids under 10 pay $9.99, and seniors pay $15.99. The dinner buffet includes a dessert station with puddings, cakes, and sometimes ice cream. You can also grab a slice of pie from the bakery counter for an extra fee.
Daily Specials And Rotations
Yoder’s rotates their menu based on the day of the week. This keeps things interesting if you visit often. Monday might feature meatloaf, while Wednesday could have roast turkey. Friday is often fish day, and Saturday brings prime rib.
Check their website or call ahead to see what is being served. The daily specials are listed on a board near the entrance. Some items are only available in limited quantities, so arriving early is a good idea.
Monday Specials
Meatloaf with mashed potatoes and green beans. Also available: baked chicken and rice.
Wednesday Specials
Roast turkey with stuffing and cranberry sauce. Served with corn and dinner rolls.
Friday Specials
Baked fish with lemon butter. Also includes fried shrimp and coleslaw.
Saturday Specials
Prime rib with au jus and horseradish. Limited portions, so come early.
Bakery And Dessert Options
Yoder’s is famous for their bakery. The dessert case is full of pies, cakes, and cookies. You can order a slice to go with your meal or take a whole pie home. The bakery is separate from the buffet, so you pay extra for these items.
Popular pies include apple, pecan, and key lime. They also have sugar-free options for those watching their intake. Cakes range from chocolate to carrot, and cookies are sold by the dozen.
- Apple pie with crumb topping
- Pecan pie with caramel drizzle
- Key lime pie with graham cracker crust
- Chocolate cake with fudge frosting
- Sugar-free cherry pie
Prices for bakery items vary. A slice of pie costs around $4.99. A whole pie is $14.99. Cookies are $1.50 each or $15.00 per dozen. The bakery also sells bread and rolls for takeout.
Drinks And Beverages
Your buffet meal includes a drink. Choices include coffee, tea, soda, and lemonade. Milk and juice are also available for breakfast. If you want something special, you can order a milkshake or float for an extra charge.
Alcoholic beverages are not served at Yoder’s. The restaurant is family-friendly and focuses on non-alcoholic options. Water is always free if you prefer something light.
Included Beverages
- Coffee (regular and decaf)
- Iced tea (sweet and unsweet)
- Soda (Coke, Sprite, Dr Pepper)
- Lemonade
- Milk and chocolate milk
Extra Charge Beverages
- Milkshakes ($5.99)
- Floats ($4.99)
- Smoothies ($6.99)
Kids Menu And Pricing
Kids under 10 have their own pricing tier. The buffet is cheaper for them, but they still get access to the same food. There is also a separate kids’ section with smaller portions of favorites like chicken tenders and macaroni.
Parents appreciate the affordable pricing. A child’s buffet is $7.99 for breakfast, $8.99 for lunch, and $9.99 for dinner. Kids under 3 eat for free with a paying adult.
Kids Buffet Items
- Chicken tenders with fries
- Macaroni and cheese
- Mini burgers
- Fruit cups
- Pizza (on certain days)
Senior Discounts And Specials
Seniors aged 60 and over get a discount on the buffet. The savings are small but appreciated. Breakfast is $10.99, lunch is $12.99, and dinner is $15.99. You just need to show an ID to qualify.
Some days have additional senior specials. Tuesday might be senior day with an extra discount. Check with the restaurant for current promotions.
Takeout And Catering Options
If you cannot stay for the buffet, Yoder’s offers takeout. You can order family-style meals that serve 4-6 people. These include fried chicken, sides, and bread. Prices start at $39.99 for a family meal.
Catering is available for events like parties and reunions. You can choose from a menu of entrees, sides, and desserts. Minimum order is for 10 people. Call ahead to place your order.
Family Takeout Meals
- Fried chicken meal (8 pieces) with 2 sides and rolls – $39.99
- Meatloaf meal with 2 sides and bread – $44.99
- Roast turkey meal with stuffing and 2 sides – $49.99
Catering Packages
- Small group (10-15 people) – $150.00
- Medium group (16-25 people) – $250.00
- Large group (26-40 people) – $400.00
Tips For Visiting Yoder’s Buffet
To make the most of your visit, plan ahead. The buffet can get busy, especially on weekends. Arrive early to avoid long lines. Lunch is less crowded than dinner.
Bring cash or a card. Yoder’s accepts both, but cash is faster. The line moves quickly if you have exact change. Also, consider sharing a plate if you are not very hungry. Portions are large, and you can always go back for seconds.
- Arrive before 11:30 a.m. for lunch to beat the rush
- Check the daily specials board before getting in line
- Save room for dessert from the bakery
- Ask about senior or kids discounts if applicable
- Take a to-go box for leftovers (not always allowed, so ask)
Frequently Asked Questions
What Are The Current Yoder’s Buffet Menu And Prices For Dinner?
Dinner buffet is $17.99 for adults, $9.99 for kids, and $15.99 for seniors. The menu includes roast turkey, ham, fried chicken, and daily specials like prime rib on Saturdays.
Does Yoder’s Offer A Breakfast Buffet Every Day?
Yes, breakfast buffet is served daily from opening until 11 a.m. Prices are $12.99 for adults, $7.99 for kids, and $10.99 for seniors. Includes eggs, meats, pancakes, and more.
Can I Get A Discount On Yoder’s Buffet For Seniors?
Seniors aged 60 and over get a discount on all buffet meals. Show your ID at checkout. Breakfast is $10.99, lunch is $12.99, and dinner is $15.99.
Are There Gluten-free Options On Yoder’s Buffet?
Some items are gluten-free, like grilled meats and vegetables. The salad bar also has options. However, the buffet does not have a dedicated gluten-free section. Ask staff for guidance.
How Often Does Yoder’s Change Their Buffet Menu?
The menu rotates daily with specials on certain days. Staples like fried chicken and mashed potatoes are always available. Check their website for the weekly schedule.
Final Thoughts On Yoder’s Buffet
Yoder’s buffet menu and prices make it a solid choice for homestyle dining in Sarasota. The food is simple but satisfying, and the portions are generous. Whether you come for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, you will leave full and happy.
The bakery is a must-visit on its own. Grab a pie to take home or enjoy a slice with your meal. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is relaxed. It is a place where you can take your time and enjoy good food with good company.
If you are visiting Sarasota for the first time, put Yoder’s on your list. Locals have been coming here for decades, and now you know why. The buffet offers something for everyone, and the prices are fair for the quality and quantity.
Plan your visit around the daily specials to try something new. And don’t forget to save room for dessert. Yoder’s is more than just a restaurant—it is a Sarasota institution that delivers comfort food at its best.