Old Chicago Pizza menu prices reflect their Italian-inspired pizzas, pastas, and craft beer pairings. If you are looking for a detailed breakdown of what you will pay at this popular chain, you have come to the right place. We cover everything from classic pies to daily deals, so you can plan your meal without any surprises.
Old Chicago has been around since 1976, starting in Boulder, Colorado. They are known for their World Beer Tour and hearty food. Their menu is big, but the prices are reasonable for the quality and portions you get. Let’s break it down.
Old Chicago Pizza Menu Prices Overview
Before we get into specific items, here is a quick look at what you can expect to spend. Prices vary by location, but these are typical ranges for 2024 and 2025. You will find that appetizers start around $8, pizzas range from $10 to $20, and pastas are usually between $12 and $16.
The menu is split into sections: Starters, Salads, Pizzas, Pastas, Calzones, Sandwiches, and Desserts. They also have a solid kids menu and gluten-free options. Keep in mind that lunch specials can save you a few dollars on select items.
Appetizer Prices
Start your meal with something sharable. The appetizer section is perfect for groups or if you just want a light bite. Here are some common items and their prices:
- Buffalo Chicken Wings (6 pieces) – $9.99
- Bacon Cheese Fries – $8.49
- Spinach Artichoke Dip – $9.29
- Fried Mozzarella (8 pieces) – $7.99
- Loaded Nachos – $10.49
- Chicken Tenders (4 pieces) – $8.79
Most appetizers are enough for two people. If you are dining alone, consider ordering a small salad or just a pizza. The nachos are huge, so be careful if you want to save room for the main course.
Pizza Prices
Pizza is the star here. They offer three sizes: Small (10-inch), Medium (12-inch), and Large (14-inch). You can also get a Personal Pizza (7-inch) for lunch or a lighter meal. Prices depend on the crust type and toppings.
Here is a breakdown of classic cheese pizza prices:
- Small Cheese – $8.49
- Medium Cheese – $10.99
- Large Cheese – $13.49
- Personal Cheese – $6.29
Specialty pizzas cost a bit more. For example, the “Old Chicago” pizza with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and green peppers is around $12.99 for a small and $18.49 for a large. Other popular options include:
- BBQ Chicken Pizza – Small $11.99, Large $17.49
- Margherita Pizza – Small $10.49, Large $15.99
- Meat Lovers – Small $12.49, Large $18.99
- Veggie Pizza – Small $10.99, Large $16.49
You can also build your own pizza. Each additional topping costs about $1.00 to $1.50 depending on size. Premium toppings like chicken or shrimp are slightly more. Gluten-free crust is available for an extra $2.00.
Pasta Prices
If you are not in the mood for pizza, the pasta section is solid. Portions are generous, and most dishes come with garlic bread. Here are the typical prices:
- Spaghetti with Marinara – $10.49
- Spaghetti with Meatballs – $12.99
- Fettuccine Alfredo – $11.49
- Chicken Alfredo – $14.49
- Lasagna – $13.99
- Baked Ziti – $11.99
You can add grilled chicken to any pasta for $2.50. Shrimp is also an option for $3.00 extra. The pasta dishes are filling, so you might not need an appetizer.
Calzone And Stromboli Prices
These are like pizza but folded. They come with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of fillings. Prices are similar to personal pizzas:
- Cheese Calzone – $9.49
- Pepperoni Calzone – $10.29
- Supreme Calzone – $11.49
- Stromboli (with ham, salami, pepperoni) – $10.99
Calzones are served with marinara sauce on the side. They are a good option if you want something portable or less messy than a pizza slice.
Sandwich And Burger Prices
Old Chicago also has a selection of sandwiches and burgers. They come with fries or a side salad. Here are some examples:
- Classic Cheeseburger – $10.49
- BBQ Bacon Burger – $11.99
- Philly Cheesesteak – $12.49
- Chicken Sandwich (grilled or crispy) – $10.99
- Italian Sub – $11.29
Burgers are cooked to order. You can add bacon for $1.50 or extra cheese for $0.75. The sandwiches are big, so consider sharing if you are not very hungry.
Salad Prices
Salads are fresh and come in two sizes: half and full. Half salads are good as a side, while full salads are a meal on their own. Prices:
- House Salad (half) – $4.99, (full) – $7.49
- Caesar Salad (half) – $5.49, (full) – $8.29
- Cobb Salad (full only) – $10.99
- Grilled Chicken Salad (full only) – $11.49
You can add grilled chicken to any salad for $2.50. Dressings include ranch, blue cheese, Italian, and vinaigrette. The Cobb salad is popular because it has bacon, egg, and avocado.
Kids Menu Prices
If you have children, the kids menu is affordable. Each meal comes with a drink and a side. Options include:
- Kids Cheese Pizza – $5.49
- Kids Spaghetti with Marinara – $4.99
- Kids Chicken Tenders (3 pieces) – $5.29
- Kids Mac and Cheese – $4.79
Kids meals are designed for children under 12. Portions are smaller but still filling. You can also order a personal pizza for a child if they want more variety.
Dessert Prices
Finish your meal with something sweet. Desserts are simple but satisfying:
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae – $5.99
- Brownie Sundae – $6.49
- Tiramisu – $5.79
- Cheesecake (seasonal) – $6.29
The cookie sundae is a warm chocolate chip cookie topped with ice cream and chocolate sauce. It is enough for two people to share.
Old Chicago Pizza Menu Prices For Lunch Specials
If you visit during lunch hours (usually 11 AM to 3 PM), you can save money. Lunch specials include smaller portions at lower prices. Here are some common lunch deals:
- Personal Pizza with one topping and a side salad – $7.99
- Half Sandwich with cup of soup – $8.49
- Lunch Pasta (small portion) – $7.49
- Soup and Salad Combo – $6.99
These deals are only available on weekdays. They are a great way to try the food without spending too much. The personal pizza lunch is especially popular among office workers.
Drink Prices
Old Chicago is famous for its beer selection. They have a World Beer Tour where you try 110 different beers. Drink prices vary, but here is a general idea:
- Soft Drinks (refillable) – $2.49
- Iced Tea – $2.49
- Draft Beer (16 oz) – $4.50 to $6.00
- Bottled Beer – $3.50 to $5.00
- Wine (glass) – $5.99 to $7.49
- Cocktails – $6.00 to $8.00
Happy hour is from 3 PM to 6 PM daily. During that time, draft beers are $1 off, and appetizers are half price. This is a good time to visit if you want to save money.
Gluten-Free And Allergen Options
Old Chicago offers gluten-free crust for pizzas. It costs an extra $2.00. They also have gluten-free pasta for an additional $1.50. However, cross-contamination is possible, so inform your server if you have celiac disease.
Other allergen-friendly options include salads without croutons and grilled chicken dishes. The menu does not have a separate allergen section, but the staff can help you customize orders.
Catering And Party Prices
If you are hosting an event, Old Chicago offers catering. You can order large pizzas, salad bowls, and pasta trays. Prices for catering are:
- Large Pizza (feeds 4-6) – $13.49 each
- Party Salad (feeds 8-10) – $18.99
- Pasta Tray (feeds 6-8) – $24.99
- Wing Platter (24 pieces) – $29.99
Call your local store for exact pricing and availability. Catering orders usually need 24 hours notice. They also provide delivery for large orders.
How To Save Money At Old Chicago
Everyone likes a good deal. Here are some tips to keep your bill low:
- Visit during happy hour (3-6 PM) for half-price appetizers and discounted drinks.
- Order lunch specials instead of dinner portions.
- Share a large pizza with friends instead of ordering individual meals.
- Sign up for the Old Chicago email list for coupons and birthday offers.
- Check for online coupons before you go. Many sites have printable deals.
- Skip the appetizer if you are ordering a pasta dish, which comes with bread.
- Drink water instead of soda to save a few dollars.
These small changes can save you $5 to $10 per person. Over time, that adds up.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some common questions people have about Old Chicago Pizza menu prices.
Does Old Chicago have a senior discount?
Some locations offer a senior discount, usually 10% off for guests over 60. It is not advertised, so ask your server.
Are prices the same at all Old Chicago locations?
No, prices vary by location. Franchise-owned stores may have different pricing than corporate stores. Check your local menu for exact numbers.
Does Old Chicago offer military discount?
Yes, many locations give a 10% discount to active military and veterans. Show your ID to get the discount.
Can I order Old Chicago pizza online?
Yes, you can order through their website or apps like DoorDash and Uber Eats. Delivery prices may be slightly higher due to service fees.
What is the most expensive item on the menu?
The Large Meat Lovers pizza is usually the priciest, around $18.99. The Family Feast (which includes a large pizza, salad, and dessert) can cost up to $30.
Old Chicago Pizza Menu Prices Comparison
How do Old Chicago prices compare to other pizza chains? Let us look at a few examples. A large cheese pizza at Old Chicago is about $13.49. At Pizza Hut, a large cheese is around $12.99. At Domino’s, it is $10.99. So Old Chicago is slightly more expensive than Domino’s but comparable to Pizza Hut.
However, Old Chicago offers a wider variety of craft beers and a sit-down dining experience. You are paying for the atmosphere and the beer selection. If you just want cheap pizza, you might choose a different place. But if you want a full meal with drinks, Old Chicago is a good value.
Their pasta dishes are similarly priced to Olive Garden. For example, fettuccine alfredo at Old Chicago is $11.49, while Olive Garden charges $12.49. So you get a slight savings on pasta.
Seasonal And Limited-Time Offers
Old Chicago sometimes introduces limited-time menu items. These might include seasonal pizzas like a pumpkin spice pizza (unlikely) or a summer salad. Prices for these items are usually similar to regular menu items, around $10 to $15.
They also have a “Pizza of the Month” which is a specialty pizza at a discounted price. For example, in October, they might offer a “Harvest Pizza” with butternut squash and sage for $11.99. These deals are worth trying if you visit frequently.
Nutritional Information
If you are watching calories, Old Chicago provides nutritional info on their website. A slice of cheese pizza (medium) has about 250 calories. A personal pizza has around 600 calories. Pasta dishes range from 700 to 1,000 calories per serving.
For healthier options, choose a salad with grilled chicken and light dressing. The half salad is a good choice if you want a lighter meal. Avoid the loaded nachos if you are counting calories, as they have over 1,200 calories.
Final Thoughts On Old Chicago Pizza Menu Prices
Old Chicago Pizza menu prices are fair for the quality and variety you get. Whether you want a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a beer tasting experience, this chain has something for you. The prices are competitive with other casual dining restaurants, and the daily deals can make your meal even more affordable.
Remember that prices can change, so always check the menu at your local store. Use the tips in this article to save money and enjoy your meal. If you are a beer lover, the World Beer Tour is a fun challenge that adds value to your visits.
We hope this guide helps you navigate the menu with confidence. Next time you are at Old Chicago, you will know exactly what to order and how much it will cost. Enjoy your pizza and your beer!