Toojay’s Menu With Prices

Toojay’s menu with prices offers a straightforward look at classic New York-style deli food that has made this Florida chain a favorite for decades. You get big portions, familiar flavors, and a menu that hasn’t changed much because it works.

Whether you are planning a first visit or just want to know what to expect before you go, this guide breaks down the full menu, item by item. We will cover breakfast, lunch, dinner, and all the sides, plus the famous bakery case.

Let’s get right into the main categories. The menu is divided into breakfast, lunch, dinner, and a separate bakery section. Prices vary slightly by location, but the ranges below are accurate for most stores as of early 2025.

Breakfast Menu

Breakfast is served all day, which is a big plus. You can order eggs, pancakes, or a classic bagel with lox anytime.

Two Eggs Any Style – $9.99. Comes with home fries and toast. You can add bacon or sausage for $2.50 extra.
French Toast – $11.49. Thick challah bread, served with butter and syrup. A side of fruit adds $2.00.
Bagel with Lox and Cream Cheese – $14.99. A generous portion of smoked salmon, capers, tomato, and onion. This is a classic deli item.
Omelettes – $12.49 to $14.99. Choices include Western, veggie, or a loaded “kitchen sink” omelette. All come with home fries and toast.
Pancakes – $10.49 for a short stack. Blueberry or chocolate chip add $1.50.
Kids Breakfast – $6.99. One egg, one pancake, and a small drink.

Breakfast combos are a good value. The “Toojay’s Special” at $13.99 includes two eggs, your choice of meat, home fries, and a bagel or toast. It is filling for one person.

Appetizers And Soups

Before the main event, you might want a starter. The soups are especially popular.

Matzo Ball Soup – $6.99 for a cup, $8.99 for a bowl. This is a signature item. The matzo ball is light and fluffy, and the broth is rich with chicken flavor.
French Onion Soup – $7.49. Topped with melted Swiss cheese and served with a crouton.
Potato Pancakes – $8.99 for four. Served with applesauce and sour cream. They are crispy on the outside, soft inside.
Stuffed Cabbage – $9.99. Two rolls in a sweet tomato sauce. A comfort food classic.
Fried Pickles – $7.49. A modern addition, but they fit the deli vibe.

If you are sharing, the combo appetizer platter at $15.99 gives you potato pancakes, egg rolls, and fried pickles. It is enough for two or three people.

Sandwiches

This is where Toojay’s shines. The sandwiches are stacked high with meat. You can order them on rye, white, wheat, or a bagel. Most sandwiches come with a pickle spear and coleslaw.

Corned Beef Sandwich – $15.99. Thinly sliced, piled high. This is the benchmark deli sandwich.
Pastrami Sandwich – $16.49. Similar to corned beef but with a peppery crust. Very tender.
Reuben – $16.99. Corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on grilled rye. A top seller.
Turkey Club – $14.49. Triple-decker with bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on toast.
BLT – $12.99. Simple but done well. Thick-cut bacon.
Grilled Cheese – $9.99. American cheese on white bread. Add tomato or bacon for $1.50 each.
Rachel Sandwich – $16.99. Like a Reuben but with turkey instead of corned beef.

You can also get a half-sandwich with a cup of soup for $13.99. That is a good lunch option if you do not want a huge meal.

Delicatessen Classics

These are the platters that come with two sides. They are basically the sandwiches but served open-faced or on a plate.

Corned Beef Platter – $17.99. Served with coleslaw and a choice of potato salad or fries.
Pastrami Platter – $18.49. Same deal, different meat.
Roast Beef Platter – $17.49. Sliced thin, served with au jus.
Turkey Platter – $16.99. Oven-roasted, not processed.
Brisket Platter – $19.99. Braised until tender. This is a weekend special at some locations.

These platters are big. One platter can easily feed two people if you also order a side or two.

Salads

If you want something lighter, the salads are decent. They are not the main draw, but they are fresh.

Caesar Salad – $11.99. Romaine, croutons, parmesan, and house dressing. Add grilled chicken for $3.00.
Cobb Salad – $13.99. Turkey, bacon, egg, avocado, tomato, and blue cheese.
Greek Salad – $12.49. Feta, olives, cucumber, tomato, and red onion.
Chef Salad – $13.49. Turkey, ham, Swiss cheese, egg, and tomato.
Tuna Salad Plate – $12.99. Served on a bed of lettuce with tomato and cucumber.

All salads can be made into a wrap for no extra charge. Dressings are house-made, and the ranch is particularly good.

Entrees And Dinner Plates

Dinner items are available after 4 PM at most locations. These are full meals with two sides and bread.

Roasted Half Chicken – $16.99. Juicy, seasoned well. Served with mashed potatoes and a vegetable.
Beef Brisket Dinner – $19.99. Slow-cooked, served with gravy. A popular choice.
Meatloaf – $15.99. Classic style, with tomato glaze. Comes with mashed potatoes and green beans.
Grilled Salmon – $18.99. A lighter option. Served with rice pilaf and steamed broccoli.
Chicken Parmesan – $16.49. Breaded cutlet, marinara, and melted mozzarella over spaghetti.
Stuffed Cabbage Dinner – $14.99. Three rolls with mashed potatoes.

These dinners are not fancy, but they are satisfying. The portions are large enough that you might have leftovers.

Sides

Sides are ordered separately unless you get a platter or dinner. Prices range from $3.49 to $5.99.

French Fries – $4.49. Crispy, salted well.
Sweet Potato Fries – $5.49. Slightly sweet, good with the chipotle mayo.
Coleslaw – $3.49. Creamy or vinegar-based. You can choose.
Potato Salad – $3.99. Classic deli style, with celery and egg.
Mac and Cheese – $5.99. Baked with a breadcrumb topping.
Steamed Vegetables – $4.49. Broccoli, cauliflower, and carrots.
Home Fries – $4.99. Available all day, not just breakfast.

If you are unsure, the fries and coleslaw are safe bets. The mac and cheese is rich, so share it if you can.

Bakery And Desserts

Toojay’s has a full bakery counter. You can order whole cakes or individual slices. The bakery is a big part of the experience.

Cheesecake – $6.99 per slice, $29.99 for a whole cake. New York-style, dense and creamy.
Chocolate Layer Cake – $7.49 per slice. Rich fudge frosting.
Carrot Cake – $7.49 per slice. With cream cheese frosting and walnuts.
Apple Strudel – $5.99 per slice. Flaky pastry with cinnamon apples.
Rugelach – $2.49 each. Small, rolled pastries with jam or chocolate.
Black and White Cookie – $3.49. A classic deli cookie, soft and sweet.
Bagels – $1.99 each, $11.99 for a dozen. Plain, everything, sesame, poppy, and cinnamon raisin.

The bakery also sells challah bread on Fridays. It is $5.99 for a loaf and sells out fast.

Beverages

Drinks are standard. Prices are typical for a casual restaurant.

Soda – $2.99. Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr Pepper. Free refills.
Iced Tea – $2.99. Unsweetened or sweetened. Free refills.
Lemonade – $3.49. Fresh-squeezed, not from concentrate.
Coffee – $2.49. Regular or decaf. Free refills.
Hot Tea – $2.49. Selection of black, green, and herbal.
Milkshakes – $5.99. Chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry. Thick and old-fashioned.
Bottled Water – $1.99.

The milkshakes are worth the extra cost. They are made with real ice cream and are very thick.

Kids Menu

For children under 12, there is a separate menu. Prices are $6.99 to $8.99.

Grilled Cheese with Fries – $6.99.
Chicken Tenders with Fries – $7.99.
Hot Dog with Fries – $6.99.
Spaghetti with Marinara – $7.49.
Small Burger with Fries – $8.49.

Each kids meal comes with a small drink and a cookie. Portions are appropriate for younger children.

Catering And Family Meals

Toojay’s offers catering trays for parties. You can order by the pound or by the tray.

Deli Meat Tray – $12.99 per pound. Corned beef, pastrami, turkey, or roast beef.
Cheese Tray – $10.99 per pound. Swiss, cheddar, provolone.
Salad Tray – $8.99 per pound. Coleslaw, potato salad, or macaroni salad.
Bagel Platter – $24.99 for 12 bagels with cream cheese.
Cookie Platter – $18.99 for 24 cookies.

Family meals serve 4 to 6 people. The “Family Dinner” at $49.99 includes a whole roasted chicken, two large sides, and a salad. It is a good deal for a weeknight.

Seasonal And Limited-Time Items

Toojay’s rotates a few items based on the season. These are not always available, so ask your server.

Corned Beef and Cabbage – $17.99. Available around St. Patrick’s Day.
Latkes – $8.99. Available during Hanukkah.
Pumpkin Cheesecake – $7.99 per slice. Fall only.
Eggnog Milkshake – $6.99. December only.

These items are popular and often sell out. If you see them on the menu, order them.

Tips For Ordering

Here are a few practical tips to make your visit smoother.

Go early for lunch. The restaurant gets busy between 12 PM and 1:30 PM. Arrive before noon to avoid a wait.
Share a sandwich. Most sandwiches are huge. Split one with a friend and add a cup of soup or a side.
Check the specials board. There is often a daily special not on the printed menu. Ask your server.
Order a whole cake in advance. If you want a cheesecake for a party, call a day ahead. They sometimes run out.
Bring cash for tips. The restaurant accepts cards, but tipping in cash is appreciated by the staff.
Ask for extra pickles. They are free and delicious. Just ask.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Toojay’s have a senior menu?

Yes, there is a senior menu for guests 55 and older. It offers smaller portions at lower prices. Items include a half-sandwich with soup for $10.99 and a senior breakfast for $8.99. You need to ask for this menu specifically.

Are there any gluten-free options on Toojay’s menu?

Yes, but limited. You can get salads without croutons, grilled meats, and steamed vegetables. They do not have gluten-free bread or buns. The matzo ball soup is not gluten-free because of the matzo meal. Always tell your server about allergies.

Can I order Toojay’s menu online for delivery?

Yes, you can order through third-party apps like DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub. Prices on these apps are slightly higher than in-restaurant prices. You can also call the location directly for takeout.

Does Toojay’s offer any vegetarian or vegan options?

Vegetarian options exist, like the grilled cheese, veggie omelette, and salads. Vegan options are very limited. The French fries are cooked in vegetable oil, so they are vegan. The vegetable soup is also vegan. Most other items contain dairy or eggs.

What is the most popular item on Toojay’s menu?

The Reuben sandwich and the matzo ball soup are the two most ordered items. The cheesecake is also a top seller. If you are visiting for the first time, start with the matzo ball soup and a Reuben.

Final Thoughts On Toojay’s Menu

Toojay’s menu with prices is easy to navigate once you know what you want. The portions are generous, the quality is consistent, and the prices are fair for the amount of food you get. Whether you stop in for a quick breakfast, a leisurely lunch, or a full dinner, you will leave full.

The key is to not overorder. A sandwich alone is often enough for one meal. If you want dessert, consider sharing a slice of cheesecake. The bakery items are rich and sweet.

One thing to note: service can be slow during peak hours. Be patient. The food is made to order, and the staff are usually friendly. If you are in a hurry, call ahead for takeout.

Overall, Toojay’s delivers exactly what a New York-style