Andy’s menu with prices helps you decide between a concrete, a shake, or a sundae on a hot afternoon. You don’t want to guess what you’ll pay when you pull up to the drive-thru. This guide breaks down every item, so you can order with confidence and cash in hand.
Andy’s Frozen Custard is famous for its thick, creamy treats. But the menu can feel a bit overwhelming at first. There are concretes, shakes, sundaes, floats, and even a few food items. Knowing the cost ahead of time makes the whole experience smoother.
Let’s walk through the entire menu. We’ll cover prices, sizes, and what makes each item special. By the end, you’ll know exactly what to order on your next visit.
Andy’s Menu With Prices: The Complete Breakdown
This section covers every major category on the Andy’s menu. Prices can vary slightly by location, but these are the typical ranges you can expect. Always check your local store for the most accurate numbers.
Concretes: The Signature Treat
Concretes are Andy’s claim to fame. They take vanilla or chocolate frozen custard and blend it with mix-ins like candy, fruit, or cookies. The result is so thick they serve it upside down. If it falls, you get it free.
Here are the standard concrete sizes and prices:
- Small (8 oz) – $4.29 to $4.79
- Medium (12 oz) – $5.29 to $5.79
- Large (16 oz) – $6.29 to $6.79
- Giant (20 oz) – $7.29 to $7.79
You can choose from dozens of flavors. Some popular options include:
- Snickers
- Oreo
- Strawberry Cheesecake
- Peanut Butter Cup
- Banana Split
- Mint Chocolate Chip
Each concrete comes with one mix-in included. If you want extra mix-ins, they cost about $0.50 each. The custard base is always fresh and made in small batches.
Shakes And Malts
Shakes are thinner than concretes but still very thick. They use the same frozen custard but with more milk. Malts add malted milk powder for a toasty flavor.
Prices for shakes and malts:
- Small (12 oz) – $4.49 to $4.99
- Medium (16 oz) – $5.49 to $5.99
- Large (20 oz) – $6.49 to $6.99
You can get classic flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry. Or choose from seasonal specials. Shakes come with a whipped cream topping and a cherry if you ask.
Sundaes
Sundaes are a simpler option. You get a dish of custard topped with hot fudge, caramel, or fruit sauce. Then they add whipped cream and a cherry.
Andy’s sundae prices:
- Small – $3.99 to $4.49
- Medium – $4.99 to $5.49
- Large – $5.99 to $6.49
Popular sundae choices include:
- Hot Fudge Sundae
- Caramel Sundae
- Strawberry Sundae
- Banana Split (extra $1.00)
The banana split is a full meal. It comes with three scoops of custard, three toppings, and a whole banana. It’s priced around $6.99 to $7.49.
Floats
Floats combine custard with soda. You get a scoop of custard floating in a fizzy drink. It’s a refreshing choice for hot days.
Float prices:
- Regular – $3.99 to $4.49
- Large – $4.99 to $5.49
Flavors include root beer, coke, and orange. You can also mix in a flavor shot for an extra $0.50.
Food Items
Andy’s isn’t just about dessert. They also serve a small menu of food. These items are perfect if you want a quick meal before your treat.
Food menu with prices:
- Hot Dog – $2.49 to $2.99
- Chili Dog – $3.49 to $3.99
- Grilled Cheese – $3.29 to $3.79
- Chicken Sandwich – $4.49 to $4.99
- Fries (small) – $1.99 to $2.49
- Fries (large) – $2.99 to $3.49
You can also get a combo meal. A hot dog or sandwich with fries and a drink costs about $5.99 to $6.99. It’s a solid value for a quick lunch.
Kids Menu
Andy’s offers a kids menu for younger customers. Portions are smaller and prices are lower.
Kids menu items:
- Kids Concrete (4 oz) – $2.99 to $3.49
- Kids Shake (8 oz) – $3.49 to $3.99
- Kids Sundae – $2.99 to $3.49
- Kids Hot Dog – $2.29 to $2.79
Each kids meal comes with a small treat or toy sometimes. Check with your location for current promotions.
Seasonal And Limited-Time Offers
Andy’s rotates special flavors throughout the year. These are often tied to holidays or seasons. For example, you might see pumpkin concrete in the fall or peppermint in winter.
Limited-time items usually cost the same as regular menu items. But some premium flavors might be $0.50 to $1.00 more. Always ask about the current specials when you visit.
Popular seasonal flavors include:
- Pumpkin Pie
- Eggnog
- Peppermint Bark
- Strawberry Shortcake
- Lemon Bar
How To Order From Andy’s Menu
Ordering at Andy’s is straightforward. But there are a few tips to make it easier and save you money.
Step 1: Choose Your Base
Decide if you want a concrete, shake, sundae, or float. Each has a different texture and price point. Concretes are the most popular and offer the most mix-in options.
Step 2: Pick Your Size
Think about how hungry you are. A small concrete is plenty for one person. A large can easily serve two. If you’re sharing, go with a medium or large.
Step 3: Select Your Flavor
Andy’s has a long list of flavors. You can choose from classic combos or build your own. If you build your own, pick one mix-in for free. Extra mix-ins cost extra.
Step 4: Add Toppings
You can add whipped cream, nuts, or a cherry for free. Some locations charge a small fee for extra toppings. Always ask before you order.
Step 5: Pay And Enjoy
Andy’s accepts cash, credit cards, and most mobile payments. Some locations have a drive-thru, while others are walk-up only. Check your local store for details.
Tips For Saving Money At Andy’s
Andy’s is not the cheapest frozen treat option. But you can still save a few dollars with these strategies.
- Share a large concrete between two people. It’s cheaper than buying two smalls.
- Skip the extra mix-ins. One mix-in is plenty for most flavors.
- Order a sundae instead of a concrete. It’s simpler and costs less.
- Look for coupons on the Andy’s app or website.
- Visit during happy hour if your location offers discounts.
- Stick with classic flavors. Seasonal specials sometimes cost more.
Also, consider the kids menu. A kids concrete is only about $3.00 and is a good size for a light treat.
Comparing Andy’s To Other Frozen Custard Chains
Andy’s competes with chains like Culver’s and Freddy’s. Here’s how the prices and menu compare.
Andy’s Vs. Culver’s
Culver’s also serves frozen custard. Their concretes are called “concrete mixers.” Prices are similar, but Culver’s often has a larger food menu. Andy’s custard is generally thicker and creamier.
Price comparison:
- Andy’s small concrete: $4.29 to $4.79
- Culver’s small concrete mixer: $4.19 to $4.69
Both are close in price. But Andy’s offers more mix-in options.
Andy’s Vs. Freddy’s
Freddy’s has a similar menu with concretes, shakes, and sundaes. Their prices are slightly lower in some areas. But Andy’s custard is often considered higher quality.
Price comparison:
- Andy’s medium shake: $5.49 to $5.99
- Freddy’s medium shake: $5.19 to $5.69
Freddy’s also has a larger food menu, including steakburgers and hot dogs.
Nutritional Information For Andy’s Menu Items
If you’re watching your calories, here’s what you need to know. Andy’s treats are rich and high in sugar. A small concrete can have 400 to 600 calories. A large can exceed 1,000 calories.
Approximate calorie counts:
- Small concrete (vanilla with Oreo): 450 calories
- Medium concrete (chocolate with peanut butter): 650 calories
- Large sundae (hot fudge): 700 calories
- Small shake (vanilla): 500 calories
Food items are lower in calories. A hot dog has about 250 calories. Fries add another 300 to 400 calories.
Andy’s does not post full nutritional info on their website. You can ask at the store for details. Some locations have pamphlets with allergen information.
Frequently Asked Questions About Andy’s Menu
What is the most popular item on Andy’s menu?
The concrete is the most popular item. The Oreo concrete and Snickers concrete are top sellers. They are thick, creamy, and packed with mix-ins.
Does Andy’s have a secret menu?
Andy’s does not have an official secret menu. But you can create custom flavors by asking for specific mix-ins. Some locations have off-menu items like the “kitchen sink” concrete, which includes multiple mix-ins.
Are Andy’s prices the same at every location?
No, prices vary by location. Stores in high-cost areas may charge more. Always check the menu board at your local store for exact prices.
Can I order Andy’s online?
Some locations offer online ordering through their website or third-party apps. Check if your local store participates. Delivery is available in some areas through services like DoorDash or Uber Eats.
Does Andy’s have a rewards program?
Yes, Andy’s has a loyalty program called “Andy’s Rewards.” You earn points with every purchase. Points can be redeemed for free treats. Download the app to sign up.
Final Thoughts On Andy’s Menu With Prices
Andy’s menu with prices gives you everything you need to plan your visit. Whether you want a thick concrete, a creamy shake, or a simple sundae, you now know what to expect. The prices are fair for the quality and portion sizes.
Remember that prices can shift slightly by location. Always check the board before ordering. And don’t forget to ask about seasonal specials. They often offer unique flavors you won’t find year-round.
Next time you’re craving a frozen treat, head to Andy’s. Bring a friend to share a large concrete. Or grab a small sundae for yourself. Either way, you’ll leave happy and satisfied.
Andy’s is a great choice for a hot afternoon. The custard is fresh, the service is fast, and the menu is simple. Now you know exactly what to order and how much it costs. Enjoy your next visit.