Old Cutler Inn’s menu prices highlight their Mediterranean-inspired dishes served in a historic setting near the water. If you are looking for the Old Cutler Inn menu with prices, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down every section of their offerings, from appetizers to desserts, so you know exactly what to expect before you visit.
The Old Cutler Inn sits in a charming old building that dates back to the 1800s. It overlooks the water, making it a popular spot for both locals and tourists. The menu focuses on fresh seafood, grilled meats, and classic Mediterranean flavors like olive oil, lemon, and herbs. Prices are moderate for the area, with most main courses falling between $18 and $35.
Below you will find a complete breakdown of the menu, organized by course. I have included approximate prices based on recent visits and online sources. Keep in mind that prices can change slightly depending on the season or special events.
Old Cutler Inn Menu With Prices
Appetizers And Small Plates
Start your meal with one of their shareable starters. These are perfect for two people or as a light meal on their own.
- Hummus with warm pita bread – $9.00
- Spanakopita (spinach and feta in phyllo dough) – $11.00
- Grilled octopus with lemon and oregano – $16.00
- Fried calamari with marinara sauce – $13.00
- Bruschetta with tomato, basil, and mozzarella – $10.00
- Roasted red pepper and eggplant dip – $8.50
- Soup of the day (usually a seafood chowder) – $7.00
Most appetizers are generous enough to share. The grilled octopus is a standout dish, cooked until tender and served with a squeeze of fresh lemon. If you are on a budget, the hummus and pita is a filling option for under ten dollars.
Salads And Light Options
For a lighter meal, the salad section offers several choices. You can add grilled chicken or shrimp for an extra charge.
- Greek salad with feta, olives, and cucumber – $12.00
- Caesar salad with homemade dressing – $11.00
- Mediterranean chopped salad – $13.00
- Grilled chicken salad with mixed greens – $14.00
- Add grilled chicken to any salad – $4.00
- Add grilled shrimp to any salad – $6.00
The Greek salad is particularly fresh, with tangy feta and ripe tomatoes. It is a good choice if you want something light before a heavier main course. The Caesar salad dressing is made in-house and has a nice garlic kick.
Main Courses: Seafood
Seafood is the star of the Old Cutler Inn menu. Most dishes come with a choice of two sides, such as rice, roasted potatoes, or seasonal vegetables.
- Grilled salmon with lemon butter sauce – $24.00
- Pan-seared snapper with caper and tomato sauce – $26.00
- Shrimp scampi over linguine – $22.00
- Lobster ravioli in cream sauce – $28.00
- Whole fried snapper with garlic and herbs – $32.00
- Seafood platter (shrimp, clams, mussels, and fish) – $35.00
The grilled salmon is cooked perfectly medium-rare unless you ask for it well done. The whole fried snapper is a showstopper, served with the head and tail on. It is a bit messy to eat but worth it for the crispy skin and flaky meat.
Main Courses: Meat And Poultry
If you prefer land over sea, the meat section has several hearty options. These dishes also include two sides.
- Grilled lamb chops with mint sauce – $30.00
- Chicken souvlaki with tzatziki – $19.00
- Beef kebab with peppers and onions – $22.00
- Pork tenderloin with fig glaze – $26.00
- Veal piccata with capers and lemon – $28.00
The lamb chops are a favorite among regulars. They come in a rack of four chops, seasoned simply with salt, pepper, and oregano. The chicken souvlaki is a more affordable option and is served with warm pita bread on the side.
Pasta And Vegetarian Dishes
For those who do not eat meat or seafood, there are several pasta and vegetarian options available.
- Penne arrabbiata with spicy tomato sauce – $15.00
- Fettuccine alfredo with broccoli – $16.00
- Eggplant parmesan with marinara and mozzarella – $17.00
- Vegetable moussaka (layered eggplant, potato, and béchamel) – $18.00
- Spinach and ricotta ravioli with sage butter – $17.00
The vegetable moussaka is a hearty dish that even meat-eaters enjoy. It is baked until golden and served with a side salad. The penne arrabbiata has a good amount of heat, so ask for it mild if you are sensitive to spice.
Burgers And Sandwiches
Lunchtime visitors often choose from the burger and sandwich selection. These are available all day.
- Old Cutler burger (beef patty with lettuce, tomato, and onion) – $14.00
- Grilled chicken sandwich with pesto – $13.00
- Fish sandwich with tartar sauce – $15.00
- Lamb gyro with tzatziki and fries – $14.00
- Vegetarian wrap with hummus and grilled vegetables – $12.00
The lamb gyro is a popular choice for a quick meal. It comes stuffed with sliced lamb, tomato, onion, and a generous amount of tzatziki sauce. The fish sandwich uses the same snapper as the main course, so it is fresh and flaky.
Sides And Extras
You can order additional sides if you want more than the two that come with your main course.
- Roasted potatoes – $4.00
- Seasonal vegetables – $4.00
- Rice pilaf – $3.50
- French fries – $4.00
- Greek salad (small) – $5.00
- Pita bread with olive oil – $3.00
The roasted potatoes are crispy on the outside and soft inside. The seasonal vegetables change depending on what is fresh, but you can expect things like green beans, zucchini, or carrots.
Kids Menu
For younger diners, the Old Cutler Inn offers a separate kids menu with smaller portions and lower prices.
- Grilled cheese sandwich with fries – $8.00
- Chicken tenders with fries – $9.00
- Buttered pasta with parmesan – $7.00
- Mini burger with fries – $8.00
- Fish sticks with fries – $9.00
Each kids meal comes with a small drink and a scoop of ice cream for dessert. The portions are appropriate for children under twelve.
Desserts
Save room for dessert. The pastry chef makes everything in-house daily.
- Baklava with honey and walnuts – $7.00
- Greek yogurt with honey and berries – $6.00
- Chocolate mousse cake – $8.00
- Lemon sorbet – $5.00
- Rice pudding with cinnamon – $6.00
The baklava is flaky and sweet, with layers of phyllo and crushed walnuts. The Greek yogurt is thick and creamy, a refreshing end to a heavy meal. The chocolate mousse cake is rich and decadent, perfect for sharing.
Beverages
The drink menu includes soft drinks, coffee, tea, and a selection of alcoholic beverages.
- Soft drinks (Coke, Sprite, lemonade) – $2.50
- Iced tea – $2.50
- Fresh orange juice – $3.50
- Coffee or hot tea – $2.50
- Greek coffee – $3.00
- House wine (glass) – $7.00
- House wine (bottle) – $26.00
- Beer (domestic) – $5.00
- Beer (imported) – $6.50
- Signature cocktails – $10.00 to $14.00
The signature cocktails include a Mediterranean mojito made with fresh mint and lime, and a ouzo-based drink called the Aegean Breeze. If you are not sure what to order, the bartender can recommend something based on your taste.
Daily Specials
In addition to the regular menu, the Old Cutler Inn offers daily specials that change based on what is fresh. These are not listed on the printed menu, so ask your server.
- Monday: Lobster bisque and grilled fish of the day
- Tuesday: Two-for-one appetizers from 4 PM to 6 PM
- Wednesday: Half-price bottles of wine
- Thursday: Paella night (seafood and chicken paella) – $28.00
- Friday: Fresh catch of the day, market price
- Saturday: Lamb shank with rosemary and potatoes – $32.00
- Sunday: Brunch buffet from 10 AM to 2 PM – $22.00 per person
The Sunday brunch buffet is a great value. It includes omelets, pancakes, salads, and a carving station. The paella night on Thursday is also popular, so you might want to make a reservation.
Tips For Ordering
Here are a few practical tips to help you get the most out of your visit to the Old Cutler Inn.
- Come early for dinner. The restaurant fills up quickly, especially on weekends. Arriving before 6 PM helps you avoid the wait.
- Ask about the catch of the day. The fish is usually very fresh, and the preparation is simple but flavorful.
- Share appetizers. The portions are large enough for two people to share two or three starters.
- Check the specials board. Sometimes the best dishes are not on the regular menu.
- Save room for baklava. It is one of the best desserts on the menu.
- Bring cash for small purchases. While the restaurant accepts cards, the bar area sometimes has a minimum for credit card use.
What To Expect In Terms Of Service
The staff at the Old Cutler Inn are friendly and knowledgeable. They can explain how each dish is prepared and make recommendations based on your preferences. Service is generally prompt, but during peak hours, you might wait a bit longer for your food.
The restaurant has both indoor and outdoor seating. The outdoor patio overlooks the water and is a lovely spot for a romantic dinner or a casual lunch. Indoor seating is cozy with exposed brick walls and wooden beams.
Reservations are recommended for parties of six or more. You can call ahead or book through their website. For smaller groups, walk-ins are usually fine, but expect a wait on busy nights.
Price Range Summary
To give you a quick overview, here is the general price range for each category on the Old Cutler Inn menu with prices.
- Appetizers: $7.00 to $16.00
- Salads: $11.00 to $14.00
- Seafood mains: $22.00 to $35.00
- Meat mains: $19.00 to $30.00
- Pasta and vegetarian: $15.00 to $18.00
- Burgers and sandwiches: $12.00 to $15.00
- Sides: $3.00 to $5.00
- Kids meals: $7.00 to $9.00
- Desserts: $5.00 to $8.00
- Beverages: $2.50 to $14.00
Overall, a meal for two with appetizers, mains, and a drink each will cost around $60 to $90 before tip. That is reasonable for the quality and location.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Old Cutler Inn have a lunch menu?
Yes, they serve lunch from 11 AM to 3 PM daily. The lunch menu includes sandwiches, salads, and smaller portions of some dinner items. Prices are slightly lower than dinner prices.
Is the Old Cutler Inn menu with prices available online?
You can find a PDF version of the menu on their official website. However, prices may not always be up to date. It is best to call ahead or check recent reviews for current pricing.
Does the restaurant accommodate dietary restrictions?
Yes, the kitchen can modify most dishes for gluten-free, vegetarian, or dairy-free diets. Just inform your server of any allergies or restrictions when you order.
What is the corkage fee at the Old Cutler Inn?
If you want to bring your own wine, the corkage fee is $15 per bottle. They also have a decent wine list if you prefer to order from them.
Is there parking near the Old Cutler Inn?
Yes, there is a small parking lot behind the restaurant. Street parking is also available but can be limited during peak hours. Valet parking is offered on weekends for $5.
Final Thoughts
The Old Cutler Inn menu with prices offers a wide range of Mediterranean dishes in a historic, waterfront setting. Whether you are in the mood for fresh seafood, grilled meats, or a simple salad, there is something for everyone. The prices are fair for the quality and portion sizes, and the atmosphere adds to the overall experience.
Next time you are near the water, stop by the Old Cutler Inn. Grab a seat on the patio, order the grilled octopus and a glass of house wine, and enjoy a relaxing meal. You will likely want to come back again.