When you stop for gas or snacks at a Casey’s, the pizza counter often steals the show. The Casey’s General Store Pizza Menu Prices are surprisingly competitive for a convenience store chain, offering whole pies and slices that rival delivery chains. Whether you are on a road trip or just grabbing lunch, knowing what you will pay helps you decide fast.
Casey’s has been making pizza from scratch since the 1960s, using fresh dough made in-store daily. Their menu focuses on three main crust styles: traditional thin crust, a thicker “Taco” pizza crust, and their signature “Breakfast” pizza crust. Prices vary by location, but most stores follow a general pricing structure that keeps things simple.
Casey’s General Store Pizza Menu Prices
Let’s break down the full pizza menu and what you can expect to pay. Casey’s does not publish a national price list, so these figures are based on average prices across multiple Midwest locations. Actual cost may differ by a dollar or two depending on your store.
Whole Pizza Prices By Size
Casey’s offers three standard pizza sizes. The small is 12 inches, the medium is 14 inches, and the large is 16 inches. Here are the typical base prices for a cheese pizza:
- Small (12-inch) cheese pizza: $9.99 – $11.49
- Medium (14-inch) cheese pizza: $12.49 – $14.29
- Large (16-inch) cheese pizza: $14.99 – $16.99
Each additional topping adds roughly $1.50 to $2.00 per pizza. Specialty pizzas like the Taco or Breakfast pizza cost about $2 to $4 more than a cheese pizza of the same size.
Pizza By The Slice Pricing
If you only want a quick bite, slices are a great deal. Most Casey’s stores sell individual slices from their hot case. Prices are consistent across locations:
- Single slice of pepperoni or cheese: $2.49 – $2.99
- Specialty slice (Taco, Breakfast, or Supreme): $3.29 – $3.79
- Two-slice combo with a drink: $5.49 – $6.29
Slices are usually available from 10:30 AM until the pizza runs out, which is often by early evening. If you want a specific topping, ordering a whole pizza is safer.
Specialty Pizza Options And Prices
Casey’s is famous for three specialty pizzas that you won’t find at most gas stations. Each has a unique preparation method and price point.
Taco Pizza
This pizza uses refried beans as the sauce base, topped with seasoned beef, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and crushed tortilla chips. It is served cold after baking, like a taco salad on a crust. Prices range from:
- Small: $11.99 – $13.49
- Medium: $14.49 – $16.29
- Large: $16.99 – $18.99
Breakfast Pizza
A Casey’s original, this pizza has a scrambled egg base, sausage or bacon, and a cheese blend. It is available all day at most locations. Prices are similar to the Taco pizza:
- Small: $11.99 – $13.49
- Medium: $14.49 – $16.29
- Large: $16.99 – $18.99
BBQ Pork Or Chicken Pizza
This option uses sweet BBQ sauce instead of traditional red sauce, topped with pulled pork or chicken. It is a regional favorite. Expect to pay about $1 more than a standard pepperoni pizza:
- Small: $10.99 – $12.49
- Medium: $13.49 – $15.29
- Large: $15.99 – $17.99
Toppings And Extra Charges
Casey’s offers a standard list of toppings. Each topping is charged per pizza, not per slice. Here is the typical list and pricing:
- Pepperoni: $1.50 – $2.00
- Sausage: $1.50 – $2.00
- Ground beef: $1.75 – $2.25
- Ham: $1.75 – $2.25
- Bacon: $2.00 – $2.50
- Mushrooms: $1.50 – $2.00
- Onions: $1.50 – $2.00
- Green peppers: $1.50 – $2.00
- Black olives: $1.75 – $2.25
- Jalapeños: $1.50 – $2.00
- Extra cheese: $2.00 – $2.50
Some stores offer premium toppings like chicken or steak for an additional $2.50 to $3.00. Always ask at the counter if you want something not listed.
Pizza Combos And Deals
Casey’s runs regular promotions that can save you money. These deals change by season and location, but common offers include:
- Any large pizza for $12.99 on Tuesdays (some stores)
- Buy one large, get one medium for $5 (limited time)
- Pizza and 2-liter soda combo for $15.99
- Student discount: 10% off with valid school ID (select stores)
You can also use the Casey’s app to find digital coupons. Many stores offer a free slice on your birthday if you sign up for their rewards program.
How To Order Pizza At Casey’s
Ordering is straightforward. You have three main options:
- Walk into the store and order at the pizza counter. Most locations make pizzas to order, so expect a 15-20 minute wait.
- Call ahead. You can phone your local Casey’s and order for pickup. This is the fastest method if you are in a hurry.
- Use the Casey’s app or website. Some locations allow online ordering with a specific pickup time. Not all stores support this, so check first.
If you order a whole pizza, they will ask if you want it cut into 8 or 12 slices. For large pizzas, 12 slices is standard. For small pizzas, 8 slices works better.
Pizza Quality And What To Expect
Casey’s pizza is made with fresh dough that is stretched by hand. The sauce is a standard red sauce, not too sweet or spicy. Cheese is a mozzarella blend that melts well. The crust is chewy but not greasy, which sets it apart from many gas station pizzas.
The Taco pizza is served cold after baking, so do not expect hot cheese. The Breakfast pizza is best eaten warm, as the eggs can dry out if left too long. Overall, the quality is consistent and often better than national delivery chains.
Comparing Casey’s Pizza To Competitors
How does Casey’s stack up against other pizza options? Here is a quick comparison:
- Casey’s vs. Domino’s: Casey’s is usually $2-3 cheaper per large pizza. Domino’s has more topping choices and faster delivery.
- Casey’s vs. Pizza Hut: Pizza Hut’s large pizzas cost about $4-6 more. Casey’s has a thicker crust option.
- Casey’s vs. Gas station pizza (7-Eleven, Speedway): Casey’s uses fresh dough, while most others use frozen. Casey’s is higher quality but costs a bit more.
For the price, Casey’s offers good value, especially if you are already stopping for gas. You save time and money by getting everything in one stop.
Tips For Getting The Best Deal
Here are some practical ways to save on your Casey’s pizza order:
- Check the app before you go. Digital coupons often beat in-store prices.
- Order a medium instead of a large if you are feeding two people. The price difference is about $2.50, but the medium is plenty.
- Ask about day-old slices. Some stores sell leftover slices from the previous day at half price. Not all locations do this, but it is worth asking.
- Buy a whole pizza and freeze leftovers. Casey’s pizza reheats well in an oven or air fryer.
- Use a rewards card. Casey’s has a loyalty program that gives you points toward free pizza after a certain number of purchases.
Regional Price Variations
Because Casey’s is a franchise, prices can vary by region. Stores in Iowa, Illinois, and Missouri tend to be cheaper than stores in Colorado or Texas. Urban locations often charge $1-2 more per pizza than rural stores. If you are traveling, check the price board before ordering.
Some stores also offer a “pizza of the month” at a discounted rate. This is usually a specialty pizza that is not on the regular menu. Ask at the counter if they have any specials running.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Casey’s deliver pizza?
Most Casey’s locations do not offer delivery. They are primarily a pickup or walk-in service. A few franchise stores may deliver through third-party apps, but this is rare.
Can I order a half-and-half pizza at Casey’s?
Yes, most stores allow you to split a pizza into two different toppings. There is no extra charge for this, but you cannot split a specialty pizza like the Taco or Breakfast pizza.
What time does Casey’s start serving pizza?
Pizza is usually available from 10:30 AM to 10:00 PM, but hours vary by location. Breakfast pizza is sometimes available earlier, around 7:00 AM.
Are there any gluten-free crust options?
No, Casey’s does not offer gluten-free crust. Their dough is made from wheat flour and contains gluten.
How many slices come in a large Casey’s pizza?
A large pizza is cut into 12 slices by default. You can request 8 slices if you prefer larger pieces.
Final Thoughts On Casey’s Pizza Value
Casey’s General Store Pizza Menu Prices are fair for the quality you get. A large pepperoni pizza costs around $16, which is cheaper than most delivery chains and comparable to frozen pizzas from the grocery store. The convenience of picking up a hot pizza while filling your gas tank makes it a solid choice for travelers and locals alike.
If you have not tried Casey’s pizza yet, start with a slice of pepperoni or the Taco pizza. Both are crowd-pleasers and show off what the chain does best. Just remember that prices can vary, so check the board at your local store or call ahead to confirm.
One thing to note: Casey’s does not always have every pizza available all the time. If you want a specific specialty pizza, it is smart to call an hour ahead. They make dough fresh daily, but they only prepare a limited number of specialty pies at a time. This keeps the quality high but means you might need to wait if they are busy.
Overall, Casey’s offers a unique pizza experience that combines convenience with scratch-made quality. The prices are reasonable, the portions are generous, and the variety is surprising for a gas station. Next time you see a Casey’s sign, consider stopping in for a slice or a whole pie. You might be pleasanly surprised by what you find.