Der Dutchman Sarasota buffet menu with prices shows you pay one price for all-you-can-eat Amish-style comfort food. This restaurant is a local favorite for hearty meals and homestyle cooking. You get a full spread of meats, sides, salads, and desserts for a single cost.
Located on Bahia Vista Street, Der Dutchman is part of a small chain known for its Pennsylvania Dutch roots. The Sarasota location brings that tradition to Florida. Families, seniors, and visitors all come here for the generous portions and friendly service.
This article breaks down everything you need to know. You will learn the current prices, what foods are available, and how to make the most of your visit. We cover breakfast, lunch, and dinner buffets plus the bakery and gift shop.
Der Dutchman Sarasota Buffet Menu With Prices
The buffet is the main attraction here. You pay one price and eat as much as you want. The menu changes slightly by day and meal period, but the core items stay consistent.
Prices vary based on the time of day and your age. Children under a certain age eat for less. Seniors also get a small discount on most meals.
Breakfast Buffet Prices
Breakfast is served daily from 7:00 AM to 11:00 AM. The buffet includes made-to-order omelets, scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage, pancakes, french toast, and fresh fruit.
- Adults: $12.99
- Seniors (55+): $11.99
- Children (4-10): $6.99
- Kids under 4: Free
You also get coffee, juice, or milk included with the breakfast buffet. The omelet station lets you pick your own fillings like cheese, ham, peppers, and onions.
Lunch Buffet Prices
Lunch runs from 11:00 AM to 4:00 PM. The lunch buffet has a different selection than dinner. You will find soups, salads, sandwiches, and hot entrees.
- Adults: $14.99
- Seniors (55+): $13.99
- Children (4-10): $7.99
- Kids under 4: Free
Popular lunch items include fried chicken, meatloaf, mashed potatoes, and corn. There is also a salad bar with fresh vegetables and dressings. The soup rotation includes chicken noodle, vegetable beef, and cream of broccoli.
Dinner Buffet Prices
Dinner is served from 4:00 PM until closing. The dinner buffet is the largest spread. It includes multiple meats, sides, and a dessert bar.
- Adults: $19.99
- Seniors (55+): $18.99
- Children (4-10): $9.99
- Kids under 4: Free
Dinner items often include roast beef, ham, turkey, and fish. You also get mashed potatoes, gravy, green beans, and macaroni and cheese. The dessert bar has pies, puddings, and ice cream.
Sunday Brunch Buffet
On Sundays, Der Dutchman serves a brunch buffet from 7:00 AM to 2:00 PM. This combines breakfast and lunch items. The price is slightly higher than regular breakfast.
- Adults: $16.99
- Seniors (55+): $15.99
- Children (4-10): $8.99
- Kids under 4: Free
The Sunday brunch includes carving stations, omelets, and specialty items like bread pudding. It is a popular choice for families after church.
What Foods Are On The Buffet
The buffet changes daily, but certain items are always available. Der Dutchman focuses on Amish and Pennsylvania Dutch recipes. The food is simple, filling, and made from scratch.
Hot Entrees
You can expect at least four hot entrees at each meal. Fried chicken is a signature item. It is crispy on the outside and juicy inside. Other common entrees include:
- Roast beef with gravy
- Baked ham with pineapple glaze
- Meatloaf with tomato sauce
- Grilled or fried fish (usually cod or tilapia)
- Turkey breast with stuffing
Vegetarian options are limited but available. You can build a meal from sides and salads. The macaroni and cheese is a popular choice for non-meat eaters.
Side Dishes
Sides are a big part of the Amish cooking tradition. You will find classic comfort foods like:
- Mashed potatoes with brown gravy
- Buttered corn
- Green beans with bacon
- Macaroni and cheese
- Coleslaw
- Applesauce
- Baked beans
- Dinner rolls with butter
The mashed potatoes are real, not instant. The corn is sweet and tender. These sides are simple but well-prepared.
Salad Bar
Every meal includes access to the salad bar. It is not a huge selection, but it covers the basics. You will find:
- Mixed greens and romaine lettuce
- Cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots
- Shredded cheese and croutons
- Several dressings (ranch, Italian, thousand island)
- Pre-made salads like pasta salad or potato salad
The salad bar is a good way to add some freshness to your meal. It is kept cold and restocked often.
Soup Station
Lunch and dinner include a soup station. There are usually two soups available. Common options are:
- Chicken noodle soup
- Vegetable beef soup
- Cream of broccoli
- Tomato basil
- Bean and ham soup
The soups are made in-house. They are hearty and flavorful. You can pair soup with a dinner roll or crackers.
Dessert Bar
Dessert is included in the buffet price. The dessert bar has a rotating selection of pies, cakes, and puddings. Popular items include:
- Apple pie with crumb topping
- Pecan pie
- Chocolate cream pie
- Banana pudding
- Bread pudding with caramel sauce
- Ice cream cups
- Cookies and brownies
The pies are a highlight. Many customers come just for the dessert. The portions are generous, so save room.
Bakery And Gift Shop
Der Dutchman has a bakery and gift shop connected to the restaurant. You can buy items to take home. The bakery sells fresh breads, pies, cakes, and cookies.
Popular bakery items include:
- Amish friendship bread
- Apple fritters
- Whoopie pies
- Pumpkin rolls
- Homemade cinnamon rolls
Prices in the bakery range from $3 to $15 depending on the item. Whole pies cost around $12 to $15. You can order custom cakes for special occasions.
The gift shop sells Amish-themed items like cookbooks, jams, jellies, and kitchen gadgets. It is a nice place to browse after your meal.
Tips For Visiting Der Dutchman Sarasota
Here are some practical tips to make your visit better. These come from regular customers and staff observations.
- Go early for dinner. The buffet gets busy around 5:30 PM. Arriving at 4:00 PM gives you the freshest food and shortest lines.
- Check the daily specials. Some days have unique items like fried catfish or roast pork. Ask the hostess about specials.
- Bring a group. The buffet is ideal for families or groups. Everyone pays one price and picks what they want.
- Save room for dessert. The pies are worth the extra calories. Try the apple or pecan pie.
- Use the senior discount. If you are 55 or older, you save a dollar or two per meal. It adds up over multiple visits.
- Ask about takeout. You can order buffet items to go. The price is based on weight, not the flat buffet rate.
- Join the email list. Der Dutchman sends coupons and special offers. You can get a free meal on your birthday.
How The Buffet Compares To Other Options
Sarasota has many buffet restaurants. Der Dutchman stands out for its Amish-style cooking and consistent quality. Here is how it compares to similar places.
Der Dutchman Vs. Golden Corral
Golden Corral is a national chain with a larger selection. However, Der Dutchman has better quality on core items like fried chicken and pies. The atmosphere is also quieter and more relaxed.
Der Dutchman Vs. Sweet Tomatoes
Sweet Tomatoes focuses on salads and soups. Der Dutchman has more hot entrees and comfort food. If you want a hearty meal, Der Dutchman is the better choice.
Der Dutchman Vs. Local Diners
Local diners offer similar food but at a la carte prices. The buffet value is better if you eat multiple servings. For a single plate, a diner might be cheaper.
Hours And Location
Der Dutchman Sarasota is located at 4850 Bahia Vista Street. The restaurant is open seven days a week. Hours are:
- Monday – Saturday: 7:00 AM to 8:00 PM
- Sunday: 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM
The buffet is available during all open hours. Breakfast ends at 11:00 AM. Lunch runs from 11:00 AM to 4:00 PM. Dinner starts at 4:00 PM.
Parking is free and plentiful. The lot can fill up on weekends, especially Sunday after church. Arrive early to avoid waiting.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Der Dutchman Sarasota Offer A Senior Discount On The Buffet?
Yes, seniors aged 55 and older get a discount of about $1 to $2 off the regular adult price. The discount applies to breakfast, lunch, and dinner buffets.
Can I Get The Der Dutchman Sarasota Buffet Menu With Prices Online?
Yes, the official Der Dutchman website lists current menu items and prices. However, prices can change, so call ahead to confirm. The buffet menu with prices is also posted at the restaurant entrance.
Is There A Gluten-free Option On The Buffet?
Der Dutchman does not have a dedicated gluten-free buffet. However, some items like plain meats, vegetables, and salads are naturally gluten-free. Ask the staff for guidance on specific items.
How Much Does The Der Dutchman Sarasota Dinner Buffet Cost For Children?
Children aged 4 to 10 pay $9.99 for the dinner buffet. Kids under 4 eat for free. The children’s price is about half the adult price.
Does Der Dutchman Sarasota Accept Reservations For The Buffet?
No, Der Dutchman does not take reservations for the buffet. It is first-come, first-served. Large groups can call ahead to notify the restaurant, but seating is not guaranteed.
What Customers Say About The Buffet
Online reviews are generally positive. Customers praise the fried chicken, mashed potatoes, and pies. The service is described as friendly and efficient.
Common compliments include:
- “The chicken is always crispy and hot.”
- “The pie selection is amazing.”
- “Great value for the price.”
- “Clean restaurant and nice staff.”
Some negative reviews mention that the buffet can be crowded during peak hours. A few customers say the food is sometimes lukewarm. Overall, the restaurant maintains a 4-star rating on most platforms.
Final Thoughts On Der Dutchman Sarasota Buffet
Der Dutchman Sarasota buffet menu with prices offers a straightforward deal. You pay one price and eat as much as you want. The food is simple, comforting, and made with care.
The prices are reasonable for the amount and quality of food. Breakfast is the cheapest option. Dinner gives you the most variety. Seniors and children get discounts.
If you enjoy homestyle cooking, this buffet is worth trying. The bakery and gift shop add extra value. Plan your visit for a weekday to avoid crowds. Save room for pie.
Remember to check the official website or call ahead for the most current prices. Menus and prices can change without notice. The information in this article is accurate as of the time of writing.
Der Dutchman is a reliable choice for a filling meal in Sarasota. Whether you are a local or a tourist, the buffet delivers on its promise of all-you-can-eat comfort food.