Cold Stone Creamery prices menu items by base size and the number of mix-ins you choose for your ice cream. This guide breaks down every cost, size option, and add-on so you know exactly what to expect before you order. Whether you are a first-time visitor or a regular looking to save, this article covers everything from the classic Creation to custom combinations.
Ice cream at Cold Stone is not just scooped; it is mixed on a frozen granite stone with your choice of toppings. This process is part of the experience, but it also affects the final price. Understanding the pricing structure helps you avoid surprises at the register.
Cold Stone Creamery Prices Menu Overview
The core of the Cold Stone Creamery prices menu is built around three main components: the base ice cream size, the number of mix-ins, and optional extras like waffle bowls or additional toppings. Each size has a standard price, and you pay extra for each mix-in you add.
Most locations follow a similar pricing model, but individual franchise owners can adjust prices slightly. Always check the menu board at your local shop for the most accurate numbers. The prices listed here are based on national averages as of early 2025.
Base Size Options And Their Prices
Cold Stone offers four standard cup or cone sizes. The size names are unique to the brand, so do not expect small, medium, and large. Here are the typical sizes and their base prices (without mix-ins):
- Like It – This is the smallest size, roughly equivalent to a single scoop. Average price: $4.49 to $5.29.
- Love It – The medium size, about two scoops. Average price: $5.79 to $6.79.
- Gotta Have It – The largest standard size, around three scoops. Average price: $7.29 to $8.49.
- Kids Size – A smaller portion designed for children, often priced around $3.99 to $4.79.
These base prices include the ice cream only. You will pay extra for any mix-ins you choose. The base ice cream flavor is usually vanilla or chocolate, but you can upgrade to a premium flavor for a small additional charge.
Mix-In Pricing Structure
Mix-ins are the candy, fruit, nuts, and other toppings that get folded into your ice cream. Each mix-in costs extra, and the price depends on the number you add. Here is the typical pricing:
- 1 Mix-In – Adds approximately $0.89 to $1.29 to the base price.
- 2 Mix-Ins – Adds approximately $1.49 to $1.99.
- 3 Mix-Ins – Adds approximately $1.99 to $2.49.
- 4 Mix-Ins – Adds approximately $2.49 to $2.99.
Some locations offer a flat rate for unlimited mix-ins on certain sizes, but this is rare. Most stores charge per mix-in. Popular mix-ins include brownie pieces, cookie dough, M&Ms, Oreos, strawberries, and pecans.
Signature Creations And Their Prices
Cold Stone also sells pre-designed ice cream combinations called Signature Creations. These include specific ice cream flavors and mix-ins chosen by the company. They are often slightly cheaper than building a custom creation with the same ingredients. Here are some popular Signature Creations and their average prices for the Love It size:
- Cookie Doughn’t You Want Some? – Vanilla ice cream with cookie dough, fudge, and caramel. Price: $6.49 to $7.49.
- Birthday Cake Remix – Vanilla ice cream with cake pieces, sprinkles, and fudge. Price: $6.29 to $7.29.
- Strawberry Banana Rendezvous – Strawberry ice cream with bananas and strawberries. Price: $6.49 to $7.49.
- Chocolate Devotion – Chocolate ice cream with brownies and fudge. Price: $6.79 to $7.79.
- Peanut Butter Cup Perfection – Chocolate ice cream with peanut butter cups and fudge. Price: $6.99 to $7.99.
Signature Creations are a good value if you like the combination. They save you from paying for each mix-in separately.
Cold Stone Creamery Prices Menu For Custom Orders
Building your own ice cream is where the Cold Stone Creamery prices menu really shines. You choose your base ice cream flavor, then select your mix-ins. The final price is the base size price plus the cost of each mix-in.
Here is a step-by-step breakdown of how to calculate your total cost:
- Choose your size: Like It, Love It, or Gotta Have It.
- Pick your base ice cream flavor. Standard flavors are included in the base price. Premium flavors like cheesecake or coffee may cost $0.50 to $1.00 extra.
- Select your mix-ins. Each mix-in adds a fixed amount to the total.
- Decide on a cup, cone, or waffle bowl. Cones are usually free, but waffle bowls cost extra.
- Add any optional toppings like whipped cream or a cherry. These are often free.
For example, a Love It size with two mix-ins might cost $5.79 (base) + $1.49 (mix-ins) = $7.28. A Gotta Have It size with three mix-ins might cost $7.29 + $1.99 = $9.28.
Waffle Bowl And Cone Upcharges
If you want your ice cream in a waffle bowl instead of a regular cup or cone, expect to pay an additional fee. Waffle bowls are made fresh and add a crunchy texture. Typical upcharges are:
- Waffle Bowl – Adds $1.00 to $1.50.
- Chocolate-Dipped Waffle Bowl – Adds $1.50 to $2.00.
- Waffle Cone – Usually free or adds $0.50.
- Chocolate-Dipped Cone – Adds $0.50 to $1.00.
Some locations include the waffle cone in the base price for certain sizes. Always ask if you are unsure.
Extra Toppings And Add-Ons
Beyond mix-ins, you can add extra toppings on top of your ice cream. These are separate from the mix-ins that get folded in. Common extra toppings include:
- Whipped cream – Usually free.
- Hot fudge or caramel sauce – Adds $0.50 to $1.00.
- Cherry – Usually free.
- Sprinkles – Often free or $0.25.
- Nuts – Adds $0.50 to $1.00.
These add-ons are optional and not included in the mix-in count. They are applied after the ice cream is mixed.
Cold Stone Creamery Prices Menu For Shakes And Smoothies
Cold Stone also offers milkshakes and smoothies. These are blended drinks made with ice cream and milk or fruit. Their pricing is separate from the ice cream menu.
Milkshake Prices
Milkshakes come in two sizes: Like It and Love It. They are made with your choice of ice cream flavor and mix-ins. Average prices are:
- Like It Shake – $5.49 to $6.49.
- Love It Shake – $6.79 to $7.79.
You can add extra mix-ins to your shake for an additional cost, similar to the ice cream pricing.
Smoothie Prices
Smoothies are fruit-based and do not contain ice cream. They are blended with yogurt or sherbet. Prices are generally:
- Like It Smoothie – $4.99 to $5.99.
- Love It Smoothie – $6.29 to $7.29.
Smoothies are a lighter option and are popular during warmer months.
Cold Stone Creamery Prices Menu For Cakes And Pies
For special occasions, Cold Stone sells ice cream cakes and pies. These are pre-made or custom ordered. Prices vary by size and complexity.
Ice Cream Cake Prices
Ice cream cakes come in round or sheet shapes. They feature layers of ice cream, cake, and frosting. Typical prices:
- 8-inch Round Cake – Serves 8 to 10 people. Price: $29.99 to $39.99.
- 10-inch Round Cake – Serves 12 to 16 people. Price: $39.99 to $49.99.
- Quarter Sheet Cake – Serves 16 to 20 people. Price: $49.99 to $59.99.
- Half Sheet Cake – Serves 24 to 32 people. Price: $69.99 to $79.99.
Custom messages and decorations may add $5.00 to $15.00 to the total.
Ice Cream Pie Prices
Ice cream pies are smaller and often cheaper than cakes. They come in a standard size:
- 8-inch Pie – Serves 6 to 8 people. Price: $19.99 to $29.99.
Pies are a good option for smaller gatherings.
Cold Stone Creamery Prices Menu For Seasonal And Limited-Time Offers
Cold Stone frequently introduces seasonal flavors and promotions. These items are available for a limited time and may have different pricing. For example, during the summer, you might find a watermelon sorbet or a pumpkin flavor in the fall.
Seasonal items are usually priced similarly to standard menu items, but they can be slightly higher if they use specialty ingredients. Always check the current promotions on the Cold Stone website or app.
Some locations offer discounts for military personnel, students, or loyalty program members. Signing up for the Cold Stone rewards program can earn you free mix-ins or a free creation on your birthday.
How To Save Money On The Cold Stone Creamery Prices Menu
Ice cream from Cold Stone can add up quickly, especially if you order a large size with multiple mix-ins. Here are some practical tips to keep your bill lower:
- Choose a Signature Creation instead of building your own. They often cost less than custom orders with the same ingredients.
- Stick to one or two mix-ins. Each additional mix-in increases the price significantly.
- Order a Kids Size if you want a small treat. It is much cheaper than the Like It size.
- Skip the waffle bowl. A regular cup or cone is free or cheaper.
- Look for coupons or promotions. Cold Stone often runs buy-one-get-one deals or discounts on certain days.
- Join the Cold Stone loyalty program. You earn points for every purchase that can be redeemed for free items.
Another way to save is to share a larger size with a friend. A Gotta Have It size with two mix-ins can easily serve two people for less than the cost of two separate Like It orders.
Cold Stone Creamery Prices Menu Vs Competitors
Comparing Cold Stone to other ice cream chains helps you see if it is a good value. Here is a quick comparison with similar brands:
- Dairy Queen – Blizzards are similar to Cold Stone creations. A medium Blizzard costs around $5.00 to $6.00, which is slightly cheaper than a Love It size with mix-ins.
- Baskin-Robbins – A medium scoop with mix-ins costs about $5.50 to $6.50. Cold Stone is generally a bit more expensive due to the mixing process.
- Ben & Jerry’s – A scoop shop serving Ben & Jerry’s ice cream costs around $5.00 to $6.00 per scoop. Cold Stone is comparable but offers more customization.
Cold Stone’s prices are on the higher end of the spectrum, but the experience of watching your ice cream being mixed on the stone and the wide variety of mix-ins justify the cost for many customers.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cold Stone Creamery Prices Menu
Here are answers to common questions about the Cold Stone Creamery prices menu.
Does Cold Stone Creamery have a secret menu?
Cold Stone does not have an official secret menu, but some customers create custom combinations that are not listed. You can ask for any mix-in combination, even if it is not on the menu board. The price will be based on the number of mix-ins you choose.
Are there any discounts for kids at Cold Stone?
Yes, Cold Stone offers a Kids Size option that is smaller and cheaper than the Like It size. Some locations also have special promotions for children on certain days. Check with your local store for details.
Can I order Cold Stone ice cream online?
Yes, you can order through the Cold Stone app or website for pickup or delivery. Prices online are the same as in-store, but delivery fees may apply. The app also shows current promotions and rewards.
How much does a Cold Stone ice cream cake cost?
Ice cream cakes range from about $29.99 for an 8-inch round cake to $79.99 for a half sheet cake. Custom decorations add extra cost. Prices vary by location and complexity.
Does Cold Stone charge extra for premium ice cream flavors?
Yes, some premium flavors like cheesecake, coffee, or seasonal specialties may cost $0.50 to $1.00 more than standard flavors. This is usually noted on the menu board.
Final Thoughts On The Cold Stone Creamery Prices Menu
Understanding the Cold Stone Creamery prices menu helps you make informed choices and avoid overspending. The key factors are the base size, number of mix-ins, and any optional upgrades like waffle bowls or premium flavors. Signature Creations offer good value if you like the combinations, while custom orders give you full control over your treat.
Remember that prices can vary slightly between locations due to franchise ownership. Always check the menu board at your local store for the most accurate pricing. With the tips in this article, you can enjoy a delicious ice cream experience without breaking the bank.
Whether you are craving a simple vanilla cone or a loaded Gotta Have It creation, knowing the cost structure makes the process smoother. Next time you visit Cold Stone, you will be ready to order with confidence and get the best value for your money.