Peter Luger in Brooklyn is famous for its dry-aged steaks, and their menu prices reflect the quality of this iconic institution. If you are planning a visit, understanding the Peter Luger menu Brooklyn prices is the first step to a great meal. This guide breaks down everything you need to know, from steak cuts to sides and drinks.
You are not just paying for food. You are paying for history, service, and a steak that has been perfected since 1887. Let us walk through the menu and costs so you can budget your trip.
Peter Luger Menu Brooklyn Prices Overview
The menu at Peter Luger is not huge. That is on purpose. They focus on doing a few things extremely well. The star is the steak, but there are also appetizers, sides, desserts, and a full bar.
Prices have gone up over the years, like everywhere else. But for the quality, many people say it is still a good value. Here is a quick look at what you will spend.
- Steaks for one person: $50 to $70
- Steaks for two people: $100 to $130
- Steaks for three or four people: $150 to $250
- Appetizers: $15 to $25
- Sides: $10 to $15
- Desserts: $10 to $15
- Drinks: Beer $8, Wine $12 per glass, Cocktails $16
These are rough estimates. The exact Peter Luger menu Brooklyn prices change. Always check the menu when you arrive or look online for the most current numbers.
Steaks: The Main Event
The steak is why you come. Peter Luger uses only USDA Prime beef. They dry-age it in-house for about four weeks. This gives the meat a deep, beefy flavor and a tender texture.
Steak For One
If you are dining alone, you can order a steak for one. It is a generous portion. You will get a thick cut of either a porterhouse or a sirloin. The price is usually around $55 to $65.
This includes the steak cooked to your liking. It comes with the famous Luger sauce on the side. The sauce is a tangy, creamy mix that balances the rich meat.
Steak For Two
This is the most popular order. The steak for two is a large porterhouse. It has both a filet mignon side and a strip steak side. It is sliced tableside by your server.
Price for two people is typically $110 to $130. It is plenty of meat. Most people find it filling, especially with sides.
Steak For Three Or Four
For bigger groups, you can order a steak for three or four. This is a massive porterhouse. It is perfect for sharing. The price runs from $170 to $250 depending on the size.
If you have a very hungry group, you might need two steaks. The servers are good at helping you decide how much to order.
Other Steak Options
Sometimes the menu has a daily special steak. This could be a ribeye or a bone-in filet. These are not always available. Ask your server what is special that day.
There is also a hamburger on the lunch menu. It is made from the same dry-aged beef. It is cheaper, around $20, but only served at lunch.
Appetizers To Start
Before the steak, you might want a starter. The appetizers are classic and simple. They are meant to wake up your taste buds.
Bacon-Wrapped Shrimp
This is a signature starter. Jumbo shrimp are wrapped in thick-cut bacon. They are grilled until crispy. The price is about $20 for four pieces.
They are salty, smoky, and rich. A great way to begin your meal.
Tomato And Onion Salad
For something lighter, try the tomato and onion salad. It is thick slices of ripe tomato with raw onion rings. It comes with a simple vinaigrette.
Price is around $15. It is refreshing and cuts through the richness of the steak.
Luger’s German Potato Pancake
This is a classic side that can also be an appetizer. It is a crispy potato pancake served with applesauce. Price is about $12.
It is crunchy on the outside and soft inside. A nice comfort food start.
Other Appetizers
The menu also has shrimp cocktail ($18), crabmeat cocktail ($22), and a few soups. The soup of the day is usually around $10. All are good, but the bacon-wrapped shrimp is the fan favorite.
Sides To Share
Sides are served family-style. They are meant to be shared by the table. Portions are generous. Order one or two sides for every two people.
Creamed Spinach
This is the most popular side. It is creamy, rich, and full of flavor. The spinach is cooked down and mixed with a cream sauce. Price is about $12.
It pairs perfectly with the steak. Many people say it is a must-order.
German Fried Potatoes
These are sliced potatoes fried with onions and bacon. They are crispy and savory. Price is around $11.
They are a great alternative to french fries. They soak up the steak juices nicely.
Luger’s Baked Potato
A classic baked potato served with butter and sour cream. It is huge. Price is about $10.
You can also get it loaded with cheese and bacon for a few dollars more.
Other Sides
There is also creamed corn ($10), asparagus ($12), and a side salad ($9). All are good, but the creamed spinach and German potatoes are the standouts.
Desserts To Finish
After steak, you might think you are full. But the desserts are worth saving room for. They are old-school and delicious.
Luger’s Famous Cheesecake
This is a dense, creamy cheesecake. It is not too sweet. It comes with a berry sauce. Price is about $12.
It is a classic finish to a heavy meal.
Chocolate Mousse
Rich and airy chocolate mousse. It is served in a big bowl. Price is around $11.
Chocolate lovers will enjoy this one.
Apple Strudel
A warm apple strudel with ice cream. It is flaky and spiced. Price is about $12.
It is a nod to the German heritage of the restaurant.
Ice Cream And Sorbet
Simple vanilla or chocolate ice cream. Also fruit sorbets. Price is about $9.
Good for a light end to the meal.
Drinks And Beverages
Peter Luger has a full bar. They are known for their cocktails and beer selection.
Beer
They have German beers like Warsteiner and Spaten. Also domestic options like Budweiser. A bottle is around $8 to $10.
Wine
The wine list is extensive. They focus on red wines that pair with steak. By the glass, prices start at $12. Bottles start at $40 and go up to hundreds.
Cocktails
Classic cocktails like martinis, old fashioneds, and manhattans. Price is about $16 each. They are well-made and strong.
Non-Alcoholic
Sodas, iced tea, and coffee are available. A soda is about $4. Coffee is $5.
Lunch Vs Dinner Pricing
Peter Luger serves lunch and dinner. Lunch is usually a bit cheaper. The lunch menu has a few items not available at dinner.
For example, the hamburger is only at lunch. Also, some appetizers might be slightly lower priced. But the steak prices are the same for lunch and dinner.
If you want to save a little, go for lunch. But dinner is the classic experience.
Tips For Saving Money
Peter Luger is not cheap. But you can manage your budget with a few tips.
- Share a steak for two if you are two people. It is plenty.
- Order one side for every two people. You do not need more.
- Skip the appetizers if you are on a tight budget. The steak is the star.
- Drink water or iced tea instead of alcohol. That saves a lot.
- Go for lunch instead of dinner. Same steak, slightly lower prices on some items.
- Split dessert. The cheesecake is big enough for two.
These tips help keep the total bill lower. But remember, this is a special occasion place. It is okay to spend a bit more.
What To Expect When You Visit
The restaurant is old-school. The waiters are professional but can be brusque. They have been doing this for decades. Do not expect a lot of small talk.
The dress code is casual but neat. No shorts or flip-flops after 5 PM. Jackets are not required but some people wear them.
Reservations are essential. They book up weeks in advance. Call ahead or use OpenTable. Walk-ins are rarely possible for dinner.
The atmosphere is lively and loud. It is a place for conversation and eating. Not a quiet romantic spot.
Peter Luger Menu Brooklyn Prices: A Sample Meal Cost
Let us imagine you are going with one other person. Here is what a typical dinner might cost.
- Steak for two: $120
- Creamed spinach: $12
- German fried potatoes: $11
- Two beers: $16
- Cheesecake to share: $12
- Coffee: $5
Subtotal: $176. Add tax and tip (20%): about $230 total. That is for two people. So about $115 per person.
If you add appetizers and more drinks, it goes up. But this is a realistic budget for a nice dinner.
Comparing To Other Steakhouses
Peter Luger is not the most expensive steakhouse in NYC. Places like Cote or Gallaghers can be higher. But it is not cheap either.
Compared to chains like Ruth’s Chris or Morton’s, Peter Luger is similar in price. But the quality of the dry-aged beef is often better. Many people say it is the best value for prime dry-aged steak.
The unique thing is the atmosphere and history. You are paying for an experience, not just food.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the price of a steak for one at Peter Luger?
A steak for one is usually around $55 to $65. It is a generous portion of porterhouse or sirloin.
Does Peter Luger have a dress code?
Yes, casual but neat. No shorts or flip-flops after 5 PM. Collared shirts are common.
Can I see the Peter Luger menu online with prices?
Yes, the restaurant has a website with a menu. Prices are listed, but they may change. Always confirm at the restaurant.
Is the Peter Luger menu in Brooklyn the same as in other locations?
Yes, the menu is very similar. The Brooklyn location is the original. The other locations in Great Neck and Las Vegas have the same core items.
How much should I tip at Peter Luger?
Standard tipping is 20% of the total bill. The service is professional, so tip accordingly.
Final Thoughts On Peter Luger Menu Brooklyn Prices
Knowing the Peter Luger menu Brooklyn prices helps you plan a great meal. You can expect to spend about $100 to $150 per person for a full dinner with drinks and dessert.
It is not an everyday place. But for a celebration or a special night out, it is worth it. The steak is some of the best you will ever have.
Remember to make a reservation. Bring your appetite. And enjoy the old-school charm of this Brooklyn institution.
Whether you are a first-timer or a regular, the experience is memorable. The prices reflect the quality. And the quality is world-class.
So go ahead, treat yourself. You will not regret it.