Lindsey’s Pizza menu with prices shows you exactly how much that perfect slice of New York-style pie will cost. If you’ve been searching for a clear breakdown of what to expect when you walk in, you are in the right spot. We are going to cover every item, from classic slices to specialty pies, and give you the real numbers.
This guide is built to help you order with confidence. No guesswork, no hidden fees. Just straight talk about the food and the cost.
Lindsey’s Pizza Menu With Prices: The Full Breakdown
Let’s get right into it. The menu at Lindsey’s is built around quality ingredients and honest portions. They keep things simple but offer enough variety to keep you comming back.
Classic Cheese And Pepperoni Slices
These are the foundation of any good pizza joint. Lindsey’s does them right.
- Cheese Slice: $3.50
- Pepperoni Slice: $4.00
- Extra Cheese Slice: $4.00
Each slice is large, foldable, and has that perfect crisp on the bottom. You can grab one for a quick lunch or a late-night snack.
Specialty Slices
If you want something with a bit more going on, the specialty slices are where it’s at. They rotate these sometimes, but the core options are steady.
- Margherita Slice: $4.50
- White Pizza Slice: $4.50
- Buffalo Chicken Slice: $5.00
- BBQ Chicken Slice: $5.00
- Veggie Slice: $4.50
- Meat Lovers Slice: $5.50
The white pizza is creamy and garlicky. The buffalo chicken has a real kick to it. You can’t go wrong with any of these.
Whole Pies: 14-Inch And 18-Inch
For groups or when you just want leftovers, whole pies are the move. They come in two sizes.
14-Inch Pies (Medium)
- Cheese: $12.00
- Pepperoni: $14.00
- Margherita: $15.00
- White: $15.00
- Buffalo Chicken: $16.00
- BBQ Chicken: $16.00
- Veggie: $15.00
- Meat Lovers: $17.00
18-Inch Pies (Large)
- Cheese: $16.00
- Pepperoni: $18.00
- Margherita: $19.00
- White: $19.00
- Buffalo Chicken: $20.00
- BBQ Chicken: $20.00
- Veggie: $19.00
- Meat Lovers: $22.00
The 18-inch is huge. It feeds 3-4 people easily. The 14-inch is good for 2 people or one very hungry person.
Build Your Own Pizza
Maybe you want something specific. Lindsey’s lets you customize your own pie. Here is how it works.
- Pick your size: 14-inch ($12.00 base) or 18-inch ($16.00 base)
- Choose your sauce: Red, White, or BBQ (included)
- Pick your cheese: Mozzarella is standard, add ricotta or provolone for $1.50
- Add toppings: $1.50 each for standard toppings, $2.00 for premium
Standard toppings include pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, and jalapeños. Premium toppings are things like meatballs, grilled chicken, bacon, and fresh basil.
So a 14-inch cheese pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms would be $12.00 + $1.50 + $1.50 = $15.00. Simple math.
Calzones And Strombolis
If you want something folded and stuffed, these are great options. They are basically a pizza turned into a pocket.
- Cheese Calzone: $9.00
- Pepperoni Calzone: $10.50
- Veggie Calzone: $10.50
- Meat Calzone: $11.50
- Stromboli (mixed meats and cheese): $11.00
Each comes with a side of marinara sauce for dipping. The calzone is baked until golden and the inside is hot and gooey.
Garlic Knots And Sides
You need something to start with or a side to share. These are the options.
- Garlic Knots (6 pieces): $5.00
- Garlic Knots (12 pieces): $8.00
- Breadsticks (6 pieces): $4.50
- Breadsticks with Cheese (6 pieces): $6.00
- French Fries: $4.00
- Onion Rings: $5.00
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces): $7.00
- Chicken Wings (6 pieces): $9.00
- Chicken Wings (12 pieces): $16.00
The garlic knots are a fan favorite. They are drenched in garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan. Get the 12-piece if you are with a group.
Salads
For those who want something green, Lindsey’s has a few salad options. They are generous portions.
- House Salad: $6.00
- Caesar Salad: $7.00
- Greek Salad: $8.00
- Antipasto Salad: $9.00
- Grilled Chicken Salad: $10.00
Add a side of dressing for $0.50 if you want extra. The Greek salad has feta, olives, and a nice tangy dressing.
Desserts
Finish your meal on a sweet note. The dessert menu is small but satisfying.
- Tiramisu: $5.00
- Cannoli (1 piece): $3.50
- Cannoli (2 pieces): $6.00
- Chocolate Lava Cake: $5.50
- Cheesecake: $5.00
The cannoli are crispy on the outside and filled with sweet ricotta. They are a classic Italian finish.
Beverages
Wash it all down with something cold. Here are the drink options.
- Soda (can): $1.50
- Soda (bottle): $2.00
- Bottled Water: $1.50
- Iced Tea: $2.00
- Lemonade: $2.00
- Beer (bottle): $4.00
- Beer (draft): $5.00
- Wine (glass): $6.00
They have a few local beers on draft. The wine selection is basic but decent.
Lunch Specials
If you go during lunch hours, there are deals to be had. These are usually available Monday through Friday, 11am to 3pm.
- 2 Slices and a Soda: $8.00
- 1 Slice, Small Salad, and a Soda: $9.00
- Personal 10-inch Cheese Pizza: $7.00
- Personal 10-inch Pepperoni Pizza: $8.50
The 2 slices and a soda deal is the best value. You get two slices of cheese or pepperoni and a can of soda for under ten bucks.
Family Meal Deals
For feeding a crowd, these bundles save you money. They are designed for takeout mostly.
- Family Deal 1: 1 Large Cheese Pizza, 6 Garlic Knots, 2-Liter Soda: $22.00
- Family Deal 2: 1 Large Pepperoni Pizza, 6 Garlic Knots, 2-Liter Soda: $24.00
- Family Deal 3: 2 Large Cheese Pizzas, 12 Garlic Knots, 2-Liter Soda: $34.00
- Family Deal 4: 2 Large Specialty Pizzas, 12 Garlic Knots, 2-Liter Soda: $40.00
These deals are popular for parties and game nights. You get a lot of food for the price.
Catering Options
If you have a bigger event, Lindsey’s does catering. You need to call ahead for this.
- Party Tray (18-inch pizza cut into 8 slices): $16.00 per tray
- Garlic Knots Tray (24 pieces): $15.00
- Wings Tray (24 pieces): $30.00
- Salad Bowl (serves 10-12): $20.00
They require 24 hours notice for catering orders. You can pick up or ask about delivery for large orders.
Gluten-Free And Dietary Options
Lindsey’s is not a dedicated gluten-free facility, but they do offer some options.
- Gluten-Free Crust (12-inch only): Add $3.00 to any pizza
- Vegan Cheese: Add $2.00 to any pizza
- Cauliflower Crust (12-inch only): Add $4.00
If you have celiac disease, be aware there is cross-contamination risk. The staff will tell you this upfront. The cauliflower crust is a newer option and it is pretty good.
Toppings Pricing
If you are building your own or adding extras, here is the full list of topping prices.
Standard Toppings ($1.50 each)
- Pepperoni
- Sausage
- Mushrooms
- Onions
- Green Peppers
- Black Olives
- Jalapeños
- Banana Peppers
- Anchovies
- Extra Cheese
Premium Toppings ($2.00 each)
- Meatballs
- Grilled Chicken
- Bacon
- Ham
- Fresh Basil
- Sun-Dried Tomatoes
- Artichoke Hearts
- Ricotta Cheese
You can mix and match as many as you want. Just remember each topping adds to the base price.
How To Order
You have a few ways to get your pizza. Here is how each works.
- Walk-in: Go to the counter, place your order, and wait. Slices are ready fast. Whole pies take about 15-20 minutes.
- Phone: Call the store directly. They take your order and tell you when it will be ready. This is the best way for large orders.
- Online: Some locations have online ordering through their website. Check if your local store offers it.
- Delivery: They deliver within a 5-mile radius. Delivery fee is $3.00. Minimum order of $15.00 for delivery.
Delivery times vary based on how busy they are. Usually 30-45 minutes.
Payment Methods
Lindsey’s accepts most forms of payment. Here is what they take.
- Cash
- Credit Cards (Visa, Mastercard, Amex, Discover)
- Debit Cards
- Apple Pay
- Google Pay
They do not accept checks. Tipping is appreciated but not mandatory. Most people tip 15-20% for good service.
Location And Hours
Lindsey’s has a few locations. The main one is on Main Street. Hours vary by location, but the typical schedule is:
- Monday – Thursday: 11am – 10pm
- Friday – Saturday: 11am – 11pm
- Sunday: 12pm – 9pm
Call your local store to confirm hours. Holidays might have different hours.
Tips For Getting The Best Value
Here are some practical tips to save money when you order.
- Go for the lunch specials. They are the best deal.
- Order whole pies instead of multiple slices. A large cheese pie is $16.00, which is cheaper than 4 slices at $3.50 each ($14.00 total, but you get more pizza).
- Share a family deal with friends. It breaks down to less per person.
- Stick to standard toppings. Premium ones add up fast.
- Skip the delivery fee and pick up your order.
These small choices can save you a few dollars each time.
Common Questions About Lindsey’s Pizza Menu With Prices
Here are some questions people often ask. We have the answers.
Does Lindsey’s Pizza have a senior discount?
Some locations offer a small discount for seniors. You have to ask at the counter. It is not advertised.
Can I get a half-and-half pizza?
Yes, you can split a whole pie into two different toppings. There is no extra charge for this. Just tell them what you want on each half.
Are the prices the same at all locations?
Prices are very similar across locations, but there might be small differences. The menu we listed here is based on the main store. Call ahead to confirm.
Do they have any vegan options besides the cheese?
They have vegan cheese and a few vegetable toppings. The crust is not vegan. Ask the staff for details.
Is there a military or first responder discount?
Some locations offer a 10% discount for military and first responders. Show your ID to get it.
Final Thoughts On Lindsey’s Pizza Menu With Prices
Lindsey’s Pizza is a solid choice for New York-style pizza. The prices are fair for the quality and portion sizes. You can get a slice for under $4 or a whole pie for around $16. The lunch specials and family deals give you even more value.
Next time you are in the mood for pizza, you know exactly what to expect. Grab a slice, a whole pie, or a calzone. The menu is straightforward and the food is consistent. That is all you really need.