Casey’s pizza menu prices make their breakfast pizza and taco pizza surprisingly affordable options. When you look at the full Casey’s pizza prices menu with prices, you will see that their whole pizzas start at a reasonable cost for the quality you get. This guide breaks down every pizza size, topping option, and deal available right now.
Casey’s is not your typical gas station pizza. They make fresh dough daily in each store. Their toppings are generous. And their prices are often lower than national chains like Domino’s or Pizza Hut. Let’s get into the numbers.
Casey’s Pizza Prices Menu With Prices
Here is the complete breakdown of Casey’s pizza menu. These prices may vary slightly by location. But they are accurate for most stores in 2024 and early 2025.
Whole Pizza Prices By Size
Casey’s offers three main pizza sizes. The small is perfect for one person. The medium feeds two. The large is great for a family or group.
- Small (10-inch) cheese pizza: $8.99
- Medium (12-inch) cheese pizza: $11.49
- Large (14-inch) cheese pizza: $13.99
- Extra-large (16-inch) cheese pizza: $16.49
These are the base prices for a plain cheese pizza. Adding toppings will increase the cost. But the base price is already competitive.
One-Topping Pizza Prices
If you want one topping like pepperoni or sausage, here is what you pay.
- Small one-topping: $9.99
- Medium one-topping: $12.49
- Large one-topping: $14.99
- Extra-large one-topping: $17.99
Two-Topping Pizza Prices
Two toppings give you more flavor without a huge price jump.
- Small two-topping: $10.99
- Medium two-topping: $13.49
- Large two-topping: $15.99
- Extra-large two-topping: $18.99
Three Or More Toppings
For three or more toppings, Casey’s charges a flat premium. This makes loaded pizzas a good value.
- Small three-plus toppings: $11.99
- Medium three-plus toppings: $14.49
- Large three-plus toppings: $16.99
- Extra-large three-plus toppings: $19.99
Specialty Pizza Prices
Casey’s has several signature pizzas. These come with pre-selected toppings. They are often the best value because you get multiple toppings for one price.
Breakfast Pizza
This is Casey’s most famous pizza. It has scrambled eggs, sausage or bacon, and melted cheese on a country gravy base. It is available all day.
- Small breakfast pizza: $9.99
- Medium breakfast pizza: $12.49
- Large breakfast pizza: $14.99
- Extra-large breakfast pizza: $17.99
Taco Pizza
The taco pizza comes with seasoned beef, lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese. It also includes a packet of taco sauce. It is a fan favorite.
- Small taco pizza: $10.49
- Medium taco pizza: $12.99
- Large taco pizza: $15.49
- Extra-large taco pizza: $18.49
BBQ Chicken Pizza
This pizza has BBQ sauce, chicken, red onions, and a blend of cheeses. It is sweet and savory.
- Small BBQ chicken: $10.99
- Medium BBQ chicken: $13.49
- Large BBQ chicken: $15.99
- Extra-large BBQ chicken: $18.99
Hawaiian Pizza
Ham and pineapple on a traditional red sauce base. Simple and classic.
- Small Hawaiian: $10.49
- Medium Hawaiian: $12.99
- Large Hawaiian: $15.49
- Extra-large Hawaiian: $18.49
Supreme Pizza
The supreme has pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and black olives. It is the most loaded specialty pizza.
- Small supreme: $11.49
- Medium supreme: $13.99
- Large supreme: $16.49
- Extra-large supreme: $19.49
Pizza By The Slice Prices
If you do not want a whole pizza, Casey’s sells individual slices. This is a great option for a quick lunch or snack.
- Cheese slice: $2.49
- Pepperoni slice: $2.79
- Sausage slice: $2.79
- Specialty slice (breakfast, taco, etc.): $2.99
- Supreme slice: $3.29
Slices are usually available during lunch and dinner hours. But availability depends on the store. Some locations keep slices ready all day.
Topping Prices And Options
Casey’s offers a wide range of toppings. You can mix and match to create your perfect pizza. Here are the standard topping options.
Meat Toppings
- Pepperoni
- Sausage
- Bacon
- Ham
- Ground beef
- Chicken
- Italian sausage
Vegetable Toppings
- Green peppers
- Onions
- Mushrooms
- Black olives
- Jalapenos
- Tomatoes
- Pineapple
- Spinach
Extra Cheese And Premium Toppings
- Extra cheese: $1.00 extra
- Double cheese: $1.50 extra
- Premium toppings (like bacon or chicken): $1.25 extra per topping
Deals And Coupons
Casey’s runs regular promotions. These can save you a lot of money. Here are the most common deals.
Tuesday Taco Pizza Deal
On Tuesdays, many Casey’s stores offer a discount on taco pizza. You can often get a large taco pizza for $12.99 instead of $15.49.
Friday Breakfast Pizza Special
Some locations have a Friday special on breakfast pizza. A large breakfast pizza might be $13.49 on Fridays.
Online Order Coupons
If you order through the Casey’s app or website, you often get exclusive coupons. These can include $3 off a large pizza or a free topping upgrade.
Rewards Program
Casey’s has a rewards program called Casey’s Rewards. You earn points on every purchase. Points can be redeemed for free pizza, drinks, or gas discounts.
Signing up is free. You get a bonus of 500 points just for joining. That is enough for a free slice of pizza.
How To Order Casey’s Pizza
You have several options for ordering. Each method has its own advantages.
- In-store ordering: Walk into any Casey’s location. Order at the counter. Wait about 15-20 minutes for a fresh pizza.
- Phone ordering: Call your local Casey’s. Give them your order. Pick it up when ready.
- Online ordering: Use the Casey’s website or app. Build your pizza. Choose pickup time. Pay online.
- Delivery: Some Casey’s locations offer delivery through third-party apps like DoorDash or Uber Eats. Prices may be slightly higher due to service fees.
Pizza Quality And Ingredients
Casey’s uses fresh dough made in-store daily. They do not use frozen pre-made crusts. This gives their pizza a chewy, crispy texture that many people love.
The cheese is a blend of mozzarella and provolone. It melts evenly and has good flavor. The sauce is made from vine-ripened tomatoes. It is slightly sweet with a hint of garlic.
Toppings are generous. You get a full layer of pepperoni, not just a few scattered pieces. Vegetables are fresh, not canned. The sausage is seasoned well.
One thing to note: Casey’s pizzas are cooked in a conveyor oven. This gives consistent results every time. The crust comes out golden brown with a slight crisp on the bottom.
Comparing Casey’s To Other Pizza Chains
How does Casey’s stack up against competitors? Let’s compare prices for a large cheese pizza.
- Casey’s: $13.99
- Domino’s: $12.99 (but often has coupons for $7.99)
- Pizza Hut: $14.99
- Papa John’s: $15.49
- Little Caesars: $7.99 (Hot-N-Ready)
Casey’s is mid-range in price. But their quality is higher than Little Caesars. And their toppings are more generous than Domino’s. For specialty pizzas like breakfast or taco, Casey’s has no direct competitor. No other chain offers those flavors.
Tips For Saving Money On Casey’s Pizza
You can get Casey’s pizza for less. Here are some practical tips.
- Order a large instead of two mediums. A large feeds 3-4 people for $13.99. Two mediums feed the same number but cost $22.98.
- Use the Casey’s app. There are often app-only deals like “Buy one large, get one for $5.”
- Go on Tuesdays for taco pizza deals.
- Buy slices instead of a whole pizza if you are eating alone. A slice costs $2.49 vs. $8.99 for a small pizza.
- Join the rewards program. You get a free slice after your first purchase.
- Check for local store specials. Some locations have daily deals not advertised nationally.
Nutritional Information
If you are watching your calories, here is the basic nutritional info for Casey’s pizza. These numbers are for a slice of large cheese pizza.
- Calories: 280
- Fat: 12g
- Carbs: 32g
- Protein: 12g
- Sodium: 640mg
A slice of pepperoni adds about 30 more calories. A slice of breakfast pizza has about 350 calories due to the eggs and gravy. Taco pizza is similar at 340 calories per slice.
Keep in mind that these are estimates. Actual values may vary by location and preparation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Casey’s have gluten-free pizza?
No, Casey’s does not currently offer a gluten-free crust. Their dough contains wheat flour. If you have celiac disease or gluten sensitivity, you should avoid their pizza.
Can I order a half-and-half pizza?
Yes, most Casey’s locations allow half-and-half toppings. You can get one half with pepperoni and the other with sausage. There is no extra charge for this.
What time does Casey’s start serving pizza?
Most Casey’s stores start serving pizza at 6:00 AM. Breakfast pizza is available from opening. Regular pizzas are available all day.
Does Casey’s deliver pizza?
Some locations deliver through third-party services like DoorDash. But most Casey’s stores do not have their own delivery drivers. Check your local store for delivery options.
How much is a large Casey’s pizza with three toppings?
A large pizza with three or more toppings costs $16.99. This is the flat rate for any combination of three or more toppings.
Is Casey’s pizza really made fresh?
Yes, Casey’s makes fresh dough in each store every day. They do not use frozen crusts. The toppings are applied by hand. The pizza is cooked to order unless you buy a slice.
Final Thoughts On Casey’s Pizza Prices
Casey’s pizza offers good value for the money. The breakfast pizza at $14.99 for a large is a steal compared to restaurant breakfast prices. The taco pizza at $15.49 is also a great deal for a unique flavor you cannot get elsewhere.
If you are on a budget, stick to cheese or one-topping pizzas. Use the rewards program. Look for weekly deals. You can easily feed a family of four for under $20.
One thing to watch out for: prices can vary by location. A Casey’s in a rural area might be cheaper than one in a city. Always check the menu board or app for your local prices.
Overall, Casey’s pizza is a solid choice for affordable, tasty pizza. Their specialty options set them apart from other chains. And their fresh dough gives them an edge over gas station pizza stereotypes.
Next time you are near a Casey’s, stop in for a slice or a whole pizza. You might be surprised at how good it is for the price.