Rutter’s menu with prices is essential for travelers, as their made-to-order food options rival many fast-food chains. Whether you are on a road trip across Pennsylvania or just stopping for gas, knowing what you can get for your money helps you plan a quick, satisfying meal. This guide breaks down everything from breakfast sandwiches to dinner platters, so you can order with confidence.
Rutter’s has grown from a small dairy farm into a chain of convenience stores that takes food seriously. Their kitchens cook fresh food daily, and the menu changes slightly by location. Below, you will find the most common items and their typical costs.
Rutter’s Menu With Prices: Breakfast Options
Breakfast at Rutter’s is served all day, which is great for night shift workers or late risers. The breakfast menu includes sandwiches, platters, and sides. Prices are reasonable for the portion sizes.
Breakfast Sandwiches
These are made to order on your choice of bread. You can pick a croissant, bagel, biscuit, or Texas toast. The base sandwich comes with egg and cheese, plus your choice of meat.
- Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich: $3.99
- Sausage, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich: $3.99
- Ham, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich: $3.99
- Turkey Sausage, Egg, and Cheese: $4.29
- Steak, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich: $5.49
You can add extra egg for $0.75 or extra cheese for $0.50. Some locations offer a double meat option for an additional $1.50.
Breakfast Platters
For a bigger meal, the platters come with two eggs any style, your choice of meat, and either home fries or toast. These are popular with truck drivers who need a filling start.
- Two Egg Breakfast Platter: $6.99
- Breakfast Burrito (scrambled eggs, cheese, meat, and salsa wrapped in a flour tortilla): $5.49
- French Toast Sticks (5 pieces with syrup): $4.29
- Pancake Platter (three pancakes with butter and syrup): $5.79
Breakfast Sides
Smaller items to round out your meal or share.
- Home Fries (regular): $2.49
- Home Fries (large): $3.29
- Toast (white, wheat, or rye): $1.49
- Bacon Strip (2 strips): $2.29
- Sausage Patty: $2.29
- Fresh Fruit Cup: $2.99
Lunch And Dinner Favorites
The lunch and dinner menu is where Rutter’s really shines. They offer burgers, chicken sandwiches, wraps, and hot subs. All items are made fresh while you wait.
Burgers
Rutter’s uses 100% beef patties that are never frozen. The burgers are cooked on a flat-top grill and come with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles on a brioche bun.
- Classic Burger (single patty): $5.49
- Double Classic Burger: $7.29
- Bacon Cheeseburger: $6.99
- Mushroom Swiss Burger: $6.79
- BBQ Bacon Burger: $7.49
Add cheese for $0.50. Add bacon for $1.50. A side of fries is included with most burger combos for an extra $2.00.
Chicken Sandwiches
These are made with all-white meat chicken, either grilled or crispy fried.
- Crispy Chicken Sandwich: $5.29
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich: $5.49
- Buffalo Chicken Sandwich: $5.79
- Chicken Club Sandwich (with bacon, lettuce, tomato): $6.49
Hot Subs And Hoagies
Rutter’s offers a range of hot subs served on a toasted hoagie roll. These are hearty and filling.
- Meatball Sub: $6.49
- Italian Sub (ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone): $6.79
- Philly Cheesesteak Sub: $7.99
- Chicken Philly Sub: $7.49
- Turkey and Cheese Sub: $6.29
Wraps
For a lighter option, the wraps are served in a flour tortilla with fresh veggies.
- Chicken Caesar Wrap: $6.29
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap: $6.49
- Grilled Veggie Wrap: $5.79
- Turkey Club Wrap: $6.59
Pizza And Sides
Rutter’s also sells whole pizzas and slices at many locations. The pizza is made fresh daily with dough from a local bakery.
Pizza
- Cheese Pizza Slice: $2.49
- Pepperoni Pizza Slice: $2.79
- Whole Cheese Pizza (12-inch): $9.99
- Whole Pepperoni Pizza (12-inch): $11.49
- Whole Supreme Pizza (pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions): $13.99
Sides
- French Fries (regular): $2.49
- French Fries (large): $3.29
- Onion Rings: $3.49
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces): $4.99
- Chicken Tenders (3 pieces): $5.49
- Chicken Tenders (5 pieces): $7.29
- Coleslaw (side): $1.99
- Mac and Cheese (side): $2.49
Salads And Healthy Options
If you are watching your intake, Rutter’s has several salads and lighter choices. These are made fresh each morning.
- Garden Salad (with lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, and croutons): $5.49
- Grilled Chicken Salad: $6.99
- Caesar Salad (with croutons and parmesan): $5.79
- Fruit and Yogurt Parfait: $3.49
- Veggie Cup with Ranch Dip: $2.99
Beverages
Rutter’s has a wide drink selection, from fountain sodas to fresh coffee. Prices vary by size.
Fountain Drinks
- Small (16 oz): $1.29
- Medium (22 oz): $1.59
- Large (32 oz): $1.89
- X-Large (44 oz): $2.19
Coffee
- Small (12 oz): $1.49
- Medium (16 oz): $1.79
- Large (20 oz): $2.09
- Iced Coffee (any size): $2.49
- Specialty Coffee (mocha, latte, cappuccino): $3.29
Other Drinks
- Bottled Water: $1.49
- Gatorade/Powerade: $2.49
- Energy Drinks (Monster, Red Bull): $3.29
- Milk (chocolate or white, pint): $1.99
- Orange Juice (fresh squeezed, small): $2.79
Desserts And Snacks
Finish your meal with something sweet. Rutter’s bakery items are made in-store daily.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie: $1.29
- Brownie: $1.79
- Apple Turnover: $2.49
- Donut (glazed, chocolate, or powdered): $1.49
- Muffin (blueberry, chocolate chip): $2.29
- Ice Cream Cup (vanilla or chocolate): $2.99
- Milkshake (vanilla, chocolate, strawberry): $4.49
How To Order At Rutter’s
Ordering at Rutter’s is simple. Here is a step-by-step guide.
- Find a location. Use the Rutter’s website or app to find a store near you. Most are along highways in Pennsylvania, Maryland, and West Virginia.
- Use the kiosk or counter. Many newer Rutter’s have touchscreen kiosks where you can customize your order. You can also order at the deli counter directly.
- Customize your meal. Choose your bread, toppings, and sauces. You can request no salt, extra cheese, or any modifications.
- Pay. You can pay with cash, credit card, or the Rutter’s loyalty app. The app sometimes has exclusive coupons.
- Wait for your food. Most items are ready in 5-10 minutes. You will hear your name called or see your order number on a screen.
- Grab condiments and napkins. There is a station near the register with ketchup, mustard, mayo, and hot sauce.
Tips For Saving Money At Rutter’s
Rutter’s menu with prices can add up if you are not careful. Here are some ways to keep costs down.
- Check the app for daily deals. Many locations offer a free drink with a sandwich purchase on Tuesdays.
- Order a combo meal. Adding fries and a drink to a sandwich usually saves about $1.00 compared to buying separately.
- Share a large side. The large fries are big enough for two people.
- Skip the premium toppings. Bacon and extra cheese cost extra, so only add them if you really want them.
- Look for the “Value Menu” at some locations. Items like a small burger or a hot dog can be under $3.00.
- Use your loyalty points. Every purchase earns points that can be redeemed for free food or drinks.
Rutter’s Vs. Other Convenience Store Menus
How does Rutter’s compare to competitors like Sheetz or Wawa? Here is a quick breakdown.
- Food quality: Rutter’s uses fresh, never frozen beef and chicken. Sheetz also uses fresh ingredients, but Wawa’s sandwiches are pre-made and heated.
- Price: Rutter’s is generally slightly cheaper than Sheetz for similar items. Wawa is often the cheapest but has fewer options.
- Customization: Rutter’s and Sheetz both offer extensive customization through kiosks. Wawa has limited customization.
- Breakfast: Rutter’s breakfast is available all day, which is a big plus. Sheetz also offers all-day breakfast, but Wawa stops serving breakfast at 11 AM.
- Pizza: Rutter’s has whole pizzas and slices, which Sheetz and Wawa do not offer at most locations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Rutter’s have a secret menu?
Rutter’s does not have an official secret menu, but you can customize almost any item. For example, you can ask for a burger with a fried egg on top or a breakfast sandwich on a pizza crust. The staff is usually happy to accommodate.
Are Rutter’s menu prices the same at all locations?
Prices can vary slightly by location due to local taxes and operating costs. Urban stores or stores along major highways may be a bit more expensive than rural ones. The prices listed here are averages.
Can I order Rutter’s food online?
Yes, many Rutter’s locations accept online orders through their website or app. You can pay ahead and pick up your food without waiting in line. Some locations also offer delivery through third-party apps.
Does Rutter’s offer any vegetarian or vegan options?
Yes, Rutter’s has a veggie wrap, garden salad, and grilled cheese sandwich. They also offer a veggie burger at some locations. However, vegan options are limited. The fries are cooked in shared oil, so they may not be suitable for strict vegans.
What is the most popular item on Rutter’s menu?
The Philly Cheesesteak sub is one of the best-selling items. It is made with shaved steak, melted provolone, and grilled onions on a toasted hoagie roll. The breakfast burrito is also very popular.
Final Thoughts On Rutter’s Menu With Prices
Knowing Rutter’s menu with prices helps you make smart choices whether you are in a hurry or want a sit-down meal. The food is fresh, the portions are generous, and the prices are fair for the quality. Next time you see a Rutter’s sign, pull in and try one of their made-to-order sandwiches or a slice of pizza. You might be surprised how good convenience store food can be.
Remember to check the app for deals before you order, and do not be afraid to ask for modifications. The staff is trained to make your meal exactly how you like it. With this guide, you can navigate the menu like a regular and get the best value for your money.