Cooling off with ice cream is easier when you know the flavors available and their exact prices. Checking the Bruster’s menu with prices before you go saves you time and helps you budget for that perfect treat. Whether you are a first-time visitor or a regular, having the cost details handy makes your visit smoother.
Bruster’s Real Ice Cream is famous for its handcrafted flavors made fresh daily in each shop. The menu changes slightly by location, but the core items and pricing stay pretty consistent. Let’s break down everything you can order, from classic cones to giant sundaes, with the most current prices available.
Bruster’s Menu With Prices
This is the complete breakdown of what you can expect to pay at Bruster’s. Prices may vary a little by state or franchise, but these figures are based on average 2024-2025 data from multiple locations. Always check your local shop for exact numbers.
Ice Cream Cones And Cups
The simplest way to enjoy Bruster’s is a cone or a cup. You choose your flavor, and they scoop it fresh. Portion sizes are generous here.
- Kids Scoop: $2.79
- Small (One Scoop): $3.49
- Medium (Two Scoops): $4.79
- Large (Three Scoops): $5.99
Cones come in cake or sugar style. Waffle cones cost a little extra, usually around $0.75 more. You can also get a waffle bowl for about $1.00 extra.
Milkshakes And Malts
Bruster’s shakes are thick and creamy. They use real ice cream and mix it with milk and your choice of syrup or fruit. Malts add malted milk powder for a richer taste.
- Small Shake: $4.99
- Medium Shake: $5.99
- Large Shake: $6.99
- Malt (any size): add $0.50
You can also order a “thick shake” which is basically a shake with less milk. Same price, just denser.
Sundaes
Sundaes are a step up from a plain cup. They come with hot fudge, caramel, or strawberry topping, plus whipped cream and a cherry. You can choose your ice cream base.
- Small Sundae: $4.49
- Medium Sundae: $5.49
- Large Sundae: $6.49
- Brownie Sundae: $6.99
- Banana Split: $7.49
The banana split is a full meal. It comes with three scoops of ice cream, banana, three toppings, and all the fixings.
Floats And Freezes
Floats are a classic soda fountain treat. Bruster’s uses root beer or Coke with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Freezes are blended drinks similar to a slushy but with ice cream mixed in.
- Float: $4.29
- Freeze: $4.99
Ice Cream Cakes
Bruster’s makes custom ice cream cakes for birthdays and events. You pick the flavor, the filling, and the design. They need 24 hours notice.
- 8-inch Round Cake (serves 8-10): $24.99
- 10-inch Round Cake (serves 12-15): $32.99
- Quarter Sheet Cake (serves 15-20): $39.99
- Half Sheet Cake (serves 25-30): $54.99
You can also order ice cream pies or cookie sandwiches. Those run about $18.99 to $28.99 depending on size.
Novelties And Take-Home Items
If you want to bring Bruster’s home, they sell pints and quarts. They also have pre-made novelties like ice cream sandwiches and pops.
- Pint: $5.49
- Quart: $8.99
- Ice Cream Sandwich: $3.49
- Chocolate-Dipped Cone: $3.99
- Push-Up Pop: $2.79
Popular Flavor Categories
Bruster’s rotates flavors based on season and location. But they always have a core set of favorites. Here is what you can usually find.
Classic Flavors
These are the staples that never leave the menu. Vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry are always available. But Bruster’s also keeps these on hand.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
- Mint Chocolate Chip
- Cookies and Cream
- Butter Pecan
- Pistachio
- Coffee
Fruit And Sorbet Options
For lighter choices, Bruster’s offers sorbets and fruit-based ice creams. These are dairy-free for the most part.
- Mango Sorbet
- Raspberry Sorbet
- Lemon Sorbet
- Strawberry Ice Cream
- Peach Ice Cream
- Blueberry Cheesecake
Seasonal And Limited-Time Flavors
Bruster’s loves to experiment. You will see flavors like Pumpkin Pie in fall, Peppermint in winter, and fresh peach in summer. These change every few weeks.
- Pumpkin Pie (September-November)
- Eggnog (December)
- Peppermint Bark (December)
- Fresh Peach (June-August)
- Watermelon Sorbet (Summer)
- Caramel Apple (Fall)
How To Order At Bruster’s
Ordering is straightforward, but there are a few tips to make it faster and get exactly what you want.
- Decide your format first: cone, cup, shake, or sundae.
- Pick your size: kids, small, medium, or large.
- Choose your flavor from the board or ask for a sample.
- Add any toppings or extras like sprinkles, nuts, or extra sauce.
- Pay at the register. They accept cash, credit, and sometimes mobile pay.
You can always ask for a sample before committing. Bruster’s staff are usually happy to give you a small taste on a tiny spoon.
Tips For Saving Money At Bruster’s
Ice cream can add up fast, especially if you are bringing the family. Here are a few ways to keep costs down.
- Order a kids scoop for smaller appetites. It is half the price of a small.
- Share a large sundae between two people. It is plenty of ice cream.
- Look for daily specials. Some locations have “Two-for-Tuesday” or “Senior Discount Wednesday.”
- Join the Bruster’s loyalty program. You earn points for free scoops.
- Buy a pint instead of a cone if you want more ice cream for your money.
Dietary Options And Allergen Info
Bruster’s does offer some choices for people with dietary restrictions. But they are not a dedicated allergen-free facility.
Dairy-Free Options
Sorbets are the main dairy-free choice. They are made from fruit puree and sugar. Some locations also carry a non-dairy chocolate or vanilla made with coconut milk. Ask at your shop.
- Mango Sorbet
- Raspberry Sorbet
- Lemon Sorbet
- Coconut Milk Vanilla (select locations)
- Coconut Milk Chocolate (select locations)
Gluten-Free Options
Ice cream itself is gluten-free, but cones and mix-ins may contain gluten. Stick to cups if you are sensitive. Some flavors like cookie dough contain gluten.
- All sorbets are gluten-free
- Most plain ice creams are gluten-free
- Avoid any flavor with cookie, brownie, or cake pieces
- Use a cup instead of a cone
Nut Allergies
Bruster’s uses nuts in many flavors and toppings. Cross-contamination is possible. If you have a severe allergy, speak to the manager before ordering.
- Butter Pecan contains tree nuts
- Pistachio contains tree nuts
- Peanut Butter Cup contains peanuts
- Some toppings like almonds or walnuts are present
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are common questions people have about Bruster’s menu and prices.
Does Bruster’s have a secret menu?
Not officially, but you can ask for a “kitchen sink” sundae which includes every topping they have. Price varies by location, usually around $8.99.
Can I get a Bruster’s menu with prices online?
Yes, many locations post their menu on their website or social media. But prices can change, so calling ahead is best.
Does Bruster’s offer military or first responder discounts?
Some franchise locations do. It is not a company-wide policy. Always ask at the register if you qualify.
How much is a gallon of Bruster’s ice cream?
Gallons are not always listed on the menu, but you can order them. Expect to pay around $14.99 to $18.99 depending on the flavor.
What is the cheapest item on Bruster’s menu?
The kids scoop is the most affordable at $2.79. A push-up pop is also a budget-friendly choice at $2.79.
Seasonal Promotions And Deals
Bruster’s runs promotions throughout the year. Knowing when they happen can save you money.
Summer Specials
During summer, many locations offer a “Buy One Get One Free” on certain days. They also introduce new fruit flavors weekly.
- BOGO Sundaes on select Tuesdays
- Free scoop on your birthday (join the rewards program)
- Student discounts with valid ID
Holiday Events
On National Ice Cream Day (third Sunday in July), some shops give away free scoops. Halloween often brings spooky-themed sundaes.
- National Ice Cream Day: free small scoop
- Halloween: monster sundaes with gummy worms
- Christmas: peppermint shakes and holiday cakes
Comparing Bruster’s To Other Ice Cream Shops
Bruster’s sits in a mid-range price point. It is cheaper than boutique shops but more expensive than grocery store brands. Here is how it stacks up.
- Cold Stone Creamery: slightly higher prices, mix-in options
- Dairy Queen: cheaper but less variety in flavors
- Baskin-Robbins: similar pricing, more locations
- Local creameries: often more expensive but unique flavors
Bruster’s wins on freshness. They make ice cream on site, which most chains do not do.
How To Find Your Nearest Bruster’s
Use the store locator on the Bruster’s website. You can also search Google Maps for “Bruster’s near me.” Most locations are in the eastern and midwestern United States.
- Go to brusters.com
- Click on “Find a Store”
- Enter your zip code or city
- View hours, phone number, and directions
Some locations have drive-thrus. Others are walk-up only. Check before you go.
Final Thoughts On Bruster’s Menu And Prices
Bruster’s offers a solid value for handcrafted ice cream. The Bruster’s menu with prices shows that you can get a quality treat without breaking the bank. Whether you want a simple cone or a loaded sundae, the cost is fair for the portion size.
Remember that prices vary slightly by location. Always confirm with your local shop before ordering. And don’t forget to ask about daily specials or loyalty rewards.
Next time you are looking to cool off, you have all the info you need. Grab a scoop, enjoy the flavor, and know exactly what you are paying for.