Gibs New York Bagels prices their menu by the bagel, the spread, and any additional toppings you choose. That means your final bill depends on how you build your order, so knowing the Gibs New York Bagels Menu with Prices ahead of time helps you plan. This guide breaks down the menu so you can order with confidence.
Gibs New York Bagels Menu With Prices
The menu is simple once you understand the three-part pricing. You pay for the bagel itself, then the spread, then extras like toppings or meat. Most people spend between $4 and $12 depending on how loaded they go.
Bagel Prices
Every order starts with a base bagel. Classic flavors cost the same, so pick what you like.
- Plain Bagel – $1.75
- Sesame Bagel – $1.85
- Poppy Seed Bagel – $1.85
- Everything Bagel – $2.00
- Whole Wheat Bagel – $1.90
- Cinnamon Raisin Bagel – $2.10
- Onion Bagel – $1.85
- Garlic Bagel – $1.90
Prices can vary a little by location, but this is the typical range you will see.
Spread Prices
Spreads are sold separatly from the bagel. You can add one or stack a few if you want more flavor.
- Plain Cream Cheese – $1.50
- Scallion Cream Cheese – $1.95
- Veggie Cream Cheese – $2.10
- Strawberry Cream Cheese – $1.95
- Butter – $0.75
- Peanut Butter – $1.50
- Jelly – $0.90
If you order a bagel with cream cheese, expect to pay around $3.25 to $4.00 total.
Toppings And Extras
This is where your price climbs. Toppings and proteins are added one by one.
- Tomato Slices – $0.75
- Red Onion – $0.60
- Cucumber – $0.60
- Capers – $0.80
- Avocado – $2.00
- Bacon – $2.25
- Turkey – $2.50
- Ham – $2.25
- Egg – $1.50
- Cheese Slice – $1.00
Bagel Sandwiches And Combos
If you do not want to build your own, combo sandwhiches save you a bit of money.
- Bacon, Egg and Cheese Bagel – $6.50
- Turkey and Swiss Bagel – $7.25
- Ham and Cheddar Bagel – $6.95
- Veggie Garden Bagel – $6.25
- Lox and Cream Cheese Bagel – $9.50
Drinks And Sides
Round out your meal with a drink or a side. These prices are pretty standard.
- Regular Coffee – $2.25
- Large Coffee – $2.75
- Iced Coffee – $3.00
- Orange Juice – $3.25
- Bottled Water – $1.75
- Hash Brown – $2.00
- Side of Fruit – $3.50
How To Order And Save
Follow these steps to keep your total low while still getting a full meal.
- Pick a plain or sesame bagel instead of a specialty one.
- Choose one spread instead of two.
- Skip extra toppings if you are watching your budget.
- Order a combo sandwich instead of building your own.
- Ask about daily specials, which often cut $1 to $2 off.
Tax is not included in these prices, and some shops charge a small fee for toasting. A toasted bagel with butter runs about $2.65, while a loaded sandwich can hit $11 or more.
Now you know how the pricing works. Build your bagel the way you like it, check the total before you pay, and you will never be suprised at the register.