Casey’s pizza menu with prices helps you decide whether to order a whole pie or just a slice for a quick stop. Whether you’re fueling up for a road trip or grabbing dinner after work, knowing what each pizza costs makes the choice easier. This guide breaks down every pizza option, size, and price so you can order with confidence.
Casey’s is famous for its gas station pizza, but don’t let that fool you. The quality is legit, and the menu offers more variety than you might expect. From classic pepperoni to specialty pies like Taco Pizza, there’s something for everyone. Let’s get into the details.
Casey’s Pizza Menu With Prices
Below is the full breakdown of Casey’s pizza offerings. Prices vary slightly by location, but these figures are accurate for most stores as of 2024. Always check your local Casey’s for exact pricing.
Whole Pies By Size
Casey’s offers three standard sizes: Small (10-inch), Medium (12-inch), and Large (14-inch). Here are the base prices for a cheese pizza:
- Small Cheese Pizza: $8.99
- Medium Cheese Pizza: $11.49
- Large Cheese Pizza: $13.99
Each additional topping adds a set amount to the base price. Toppings cost extra per size:
- Small: $1.25 per topping
- Medium: $1.75 per topping
- Large: $2.25 per topping
Specialty Pizzas
These pre-designed pizzas come with multiple toppings at a set price. You can also customize them, but the specialty price is usually a better deal.
- Pepperoni Pizza (Large): $15.49
- Sausage Pizza (Large): $15.49
- Supreme Pizza (Large): $18.99
- Hawaiian Pizza (Large): $16.99
- Taco Pizza (Large): $17.49
- BBQ Chicken Pizza (Large): $17.99
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza (Large): $17.99
- Meat Lovers Pizza (Large): $19.49
- Veggie Pizza (Large): $17.49
- Cheeseburger Pizza (Large): $18.49
By The Slice
If you only want a quick bite, slices are available for most varieties. Slice prices are consistent across locations:
- Cheese Slice: $2.49
- Pepperoni Slice: $2.79
- Sausage Slice: $2.79
- Specialty Slice (Supreme, Hawaiian, etc.): $3.29
Slices are typically available from 10 AM to 9 PM, but hours vary by store. Some locations stop selling slices after 8 PM, so call ahead if you’re stopping late.
Pizza Combos And Deals
Casey’s offers combo deals that include a pizza plus sides or drinks. These are great for feeding a group or saving a few bucks.
- Large Pizza + 2-Liter Soda: $16.99
- Large Pizza + 10-Piece Chicken Tenders: $21.99
- Large Pizza + Breadsticks: $18.49
- Any Large Pizza + 2 Sides: $24.99
Check the app or website for daily specials. Some locations have a “Slice and Soda” combo for $3.99 during lunch hours.
How To Order From Casey’s Pizza Menu
Ordering is straightforward, but there are a few ways to do it. Here’s a step-by-step guide:
- Visit the store – Walk in, order at the counter, and wait about 10-15 minutes for a whole pie.
- Call ahead – Phone your local Casey’s to place an order for pickup. This saves time if you’re in a hurry.
- Use the app – Download the Casey’s app to order online. You can customize toppings, choose pickup time, and pay with a card.
- Order for delivery – Some locations offer delivery through third-party apps like DoorDash or Uber Eats. Prices may be higher on these platforms.
When ordering a whole pie, you can choose from thin crust, hand-tossed, or extra-thin crust. The hand-tossed is the most popular option.
Customizing Your Pizza
You can add or remove toppings from any pizza. Here’s the full list of available toppings:
- Pepperoni
- Sausage
- Beef
- Ham
- Bacon
- Chicken
- Mushrooms
- Onions
- Green Peppers
- Black Olives
- Jalapeños
- Pineapple
- Extra Cheese
- Anchovies (select locations)
Each additional topping costs as listed above. If you remove a topping from a specialty pizza, the price stays the same. You’re paying for the base design.
Popular Pizzas On The Menu
Some pizzas sell way more than others. Here are the top picks based on customer reviews and sales data:
Pepperoni Pizza
This is the classic. Casey’s uses a generous layer of pepperoni that crisps up nicely. A large pepperoni costs $15.49, making it one of the most affordable specialty options. It’s a safe bet if you’re feeding picky eaters.
Taco Pizza
The Taco Pizza is a fan favorite. It comes with seasoned beef, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and a dollop of sour cream on top. The crust is brushed with a taco sauce instead of traditional pizza sauce. A large is $17.49. It’s messy but worth it.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
This pizza swaps red sauce for BBQ sauce. It’s topped with grilled chicken, red onions, and a blend of cheeses. A large costs $17.99. The sweet and smoky flavor pairs well with a cold soda.
Supreme Pizza
The Supreme is loaded with pepperoni, sausage, beef, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and black olives. At $18.99 for a large, it’s a filling option that covers all the bases. If you want variety in every bite, this is it.
Cheeseburger Pizza
This one tastes like a cheeseburger in pizza form. It has ground beef, pickles, onions, and a special sauce. A large is $18.49. Some locations add a drizzle of ketchup and mustard. It’s unusual but surprisingly good.
Sides And Extras
Casey’s pizza menu with prices wouldn’t be complete without mentioning the sides. They offer a few options to round out your meal:
- Breadsticks (6-count): $4.99
- Cheese Breadsticks (6-count): $5.99
- Chicken Tenders (5-piece): $6.49
- Chicken Tenders (10-piece): $10.99
- Boneless Wings (6-piece): $5.99
- Boneless Wings (12-piece): $9.99
- Dipping Sauces (Ranch, Marinara, BBQ, Blue Cheese): $0.79 each
If you’re ordering a pizza, consider adding breadsticks. They’re a good value and come with marinara sauce. The chicken tenders are decent but not as popular as the pizza.
Drinks And Desserts
Casey’s also sells fountain drinks, bottled beverages, and a few desserts. Here are the prices:
- Fountain Drink (any size): $1.89
- Bottled Soda: $2.29
- Bottled Water: $1.49
- Milk (chocolate or white): $2.49
- Cookie (large, single): $1.49
- Brownie: $1.99
The cookies are baked fresh and are a nice treat after pizza. The brownie is fudgy but can be dry if it’s been sitting out.
Tips For Saving Money
Pizza can add up fast, especially if you’re feeding a crowd. Here are some ways to keep costs down:
- Buy slices instead of a whole pie – If you’re eating alone, two slices cost less than a small pizza.
- Look for daily specials – Some locations offer a large one-topping pizza for $12.99 on Tuesdays.
- Use the app – The app often has exclusive coupons like $3 off a large pizza.
- Order a medium instead of a large – The medium is often enough for two people and costs less.
- Skip extra toppings – Stick to a specialty pizza that already has toppings you like.
Also, consider the combo deals. A large pizza plus a 2-liter soda is only $16.99, which is cheaper than buying them separately.
Nutritional Information
If you’re watching your intake, here are approximate numbers for a slice of cheese pizza (1/8 of a large):
- Calories: 280
- Fat: 12g
- Carbs: 32g
- Protein: 11g
A slice of pepperoni adds about 30 more calories. Specialty pizzas like Supreme or Meat Lovers can have 350-400 calories per slice. The thin crust option reduces calories by about 20% compared to hand-tossed.
Keep in mind that these numbers are estimates. Casey’s does not provide official nutritional data on their website, so take them with a grain of salt.
Comparing Casey’s To Other Pizza Chains
How does Casey’s stack up against competitors? Here’s a quick comparison based on a large cheese pizza:
- Casey’s: $13.99
- Pizza Hut: $14.99
- Domino’s: $12.99 (with coupon)
- Papa John’s: $15.49
- Little Caesars: $8.99 (Hot-N-Ready)
Casey’s is mid-range in price. It’s not the cheapest, but the quality is higher than Little Caesars and comparable to Pizza Hut. The convenience of picking up pizza while getting gas is a big plus.
One downside is that Casey’s doesn’t offer delivery in most locations. You have to go to the store. But if you’re already on the road, it’s not a big deal.
Frequently Asked Questions
What time does Casey’s start serving pizza?
Most locations start serving pizza at 10 AM. Slices are usually available from 10 AM to 9 PM, but whole pies can be ordered anytime during store hours.
Does Casey’s have gluten-free pizza?
No, Casey’s does not offer gluten-free crust. The only crust options are thin, hand-tossed, and extra-thin, all of which contain gluten.
Can I order Casey’s pizza online?
Yes, you can order through the Casey’s app or website. Select your local store, choose your pizza, and pay online. Pickup is usually ready in 15-20 minutes.
Is Casey’s pizza good?
Yes, it’s widely considered above average for gas station pizza. The crust is crispy, the cheese is generous, and the toppings are fresh. Many people prefer it to chain pizza.
Does Casey’s offer any vegan pizza options?
Not really. The cheese is dairy-based, and there are no vegan cheese alternatives. You could order a pizza with just vegetables and no cheese, but it won’t be the same.
Final Thoughts
Casey’s pizza menu with prices gives you plenty of options whether you’re grabbing a slice or feeding the whole family. The prices are fair for the quality, and the variety keeps things interesting. Next time you see a Casey’s sign, pull over and give their pizza a try. You might be suprised at how good it is.
Remember to check your local store for exact pricing and daily deals. Prices can vary by region, especially in rural areas. And if you’re ordering for a group, the large specialty pizzas offer the best value per person.
So go ahead, order that Taco Pizza or stick with classic pepperoni. Either way, you’re getting a solid meal at a reasonable price. Casey’s might be a gas station, but their pizza holds its own against the big chains.