Homemade pies take center stage at Elsies Plate Pie, where the menu extends beyond dessert to include savory comfort dishes at fair prices. If you are planing a visit, this Elsies Plate Pie Menu with Prices guide breaks down the full lineup so you know exactly what to order and what you will pay.
The shop keeps things simple. You get flaky crusts, hearty fillings, and a cozy diner feel without a big bill at the end.
Elsies Plate Pie Menu With Prices
Prices are approximate and can shift by location or season. Always confirm with your local shop before you go, since small bakeries adjust costs when ingredient prices change.
Savory Pies And Comfort Plates
These are the heart of the menu. Most people come for a slice, but a full plate with sides is the better deal if your hungry.
- Classic Chicken Pot Pie – $9.50
- Beef and Gravy Pie – $10.25
- Shepherds Pie Plate – $11.00
- Turkey and Dressing Pie – $9.75
- Vegetable Pot Pie – $8.95
- Quiche Lorraine Slice – $7.50
Sweet Pies By The Slice
Sweet slices run cheaper than whole pies, which makes trying two flavors easy. Fruit pies sell out fast on weekends, so call ahead if you want a specific one.
- Apple Crumb Pie – $5.75
- Cherry Lattice Pie – $5.95
- Southern Pecan Pie – $6.50
- Chocolate Cream Pie – $6.25
- Lemon Meringue Pie – $6.00
- Sweet Potato Pie – $5.50
Whole Pies To Take Home
A whole pie costs less per slice then buying singles. Order 24 hours ahead for holiday weekends.
- Fruit Pies (Apple, Cherry, Peach) – $22.00
- Cream Pies (Chocolate, Coconut, Banana) – $24.00
- Pecan Pie – $26.00
- Seasonal Special Pie – $27.00
Sides, Drinks, And Extras
Sides keep a savory plate filling. Drinks are refillable in most stores.
- Mashed Potatoes and Gravy – $3.50
- Green Beans – $3.25
- Mac and Cheese – $4.00
- Side Salad – $3.75
- Sweet Tea or Lemonade – $2.75
- Coffee – $2.25
Daily Specials And Combos
Specials change daily and offer the best value. Look for them on the board near the register.
- Slice and Side Combo – $12.50
- Two Slice Dessert Deal – $10.00
- Family Pot Pie (Serves 4) – $32.00
- Kids Plate with Drink – $7.25
How To Order And Save
- Check the daily special board first.
- Buy a whole pie instead of slices for events.
- Visit at lunch for lower combo pricing.
- Call ahead for holiday orders.
Final Thoughts
The menu stays affordable across the board. Savory plates land between $9 and $11, slices sit near $6, and whole pies start around $22. That balance of price and portions is why regulars keep coming back. If you plan around the specials, you can feed a family for less then a fast food run. Just remember that small shops sometimes run out of popular flavors, so a quick phone call before you drive over saves you a wasted trip.