The Cottage Inn pizza menu with prices highlights their signature thin crust options and generous topping combinations. If you are looking for a quick meal or a family dinner, knowing what each item costs helps you plan better. This guide breaks down every category, from classic pizzas to sides and desserts, so you can order with confidence.
Cottage Inn has been a staple for pizza lovers, especially in the Midwest. Their menu offers variety without overwhelming you. Below, you will find the current prices for popular items, along with tips to save money and customize your order.
Classic Pizzas And Their Prices
Cottage Inn is known for its thin, crispy crust. But they also offer hand-tossed and deep-dish options. Here is the breakdown of their classic pizza prices by size.
Small Pizzas (10 Inch)
- Cheese Pizza: $8.99
- One Topping: $10.49
- Two Toppings: $11.99
- Three Toppings: $13.49
- Specialty Pizzas (like Margherita or Veggie): $12.99
Medium Pizzas (12 Inch)
- Cheese Pizza: $11.99
- One Topping: $13.99
- Two Toppings: $15.99
- Three Toppings: $17.99
- Specialty Pizzas: $16.99
Large Pizzas (14 Inch)
- Cheese Pizza: $14.99
- One Topping: $17.49
- Two Toppings: $19.99
- Three Toppings: $22.49
- Specialty Pizzas: $21.99
Extra Large Pizzas (16 Inch)
- Cheese Pizza: $17.99
- One Topping: $20.99
- Two Toppings: $23.99
- Three Toppings: $26.99
- Specialty Pizzas: $25.99
Prices may vary slightly by location. Always check your local Cottage Inn for any specials or discounts. The thin crust is a fan favorite, but the hand-tossed is also worth trying if you prefer a chewier bite.
Cottage Inn Pizza Menu Prices For Specialty Pizzas
Specialty pizzas come with pre-selected toppings. They are often more expensive than building your own, but they save time. Here are the most popular specialty options.
Meat Lovers Pizza
- Small: $13.99
- Medium: $17.99
- Large: $22.99
- Extra Large: $26.99
This pizza includes pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, and ground beef. It is hearty and filling.
Veggie Pizza
- Small: $12.99
- Medium: $16.99
- Large: $21.99
- Extra Large: $25.99
Topped with green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, and tomatoes. A great choice for lighter eaters.
Margherita Pizza
- Small: $12.99
- Medium: $16.99
- Large: $21.99
- Extra Large: $25.99
Fresh mozzarella, basil, and tomato sauce on a thin crust. Simple but flavorful.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
- Small: $13.99
- Medium: $17.99
- Large: $22.99
- Extra Large: $26.99
Grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, red onions, and cheddar cheese. A sweet and savory option.
Hawaiian Pizza
- Small: $12.99
- Medium: $16.99
- Large: $21.99
- Extra Large: $25.99
Ham and pineapple. Love it or hate it, it is a classic.
Specialty pizzas are a good deal if you like the combination. But if you want to customize, building your own might be cheaper.
Build Your Own Pizza: Toppings And Prices
If you want control over every ingredient, the build-your-own option is for you. You start with a cheese pizza and add toppings. Each topping costs extra.
Standard Toppings (Per Pizza)
- Pepperoni: $1.50
- Sausage: $1.50
- Mushrooms: $1.50
- Onions: $1.50
- Green Peppers: $1.50
- Black Olives: $1.50
- Ham: $1.50
- Bacon: $2.00
- Ground Beef: $2.00
- Anchovies: $2.00
- Jalapenos: $1.50
- Pineapple: $1.50
Premium Toppings (Per Pizza)
- Grilled Chicken: $2.50
- Feta Cheese: $2.50
- Extra Cheese: $2.00
- Fresh Mozzarella: $3.00
- Artichoke Hearts: $2.50
- Sun-Dried Tomatoes: $2.50
If you add three or more toppings, the price per topping often drops slightly. Ask your server about combo deals. A large pizza with three toppings usually costs around $22.49, which is a good value.
Sides And Appetizers: Prices And Options
No pizza meal is complete without sides. Cottage Inn offers a range of appetizers, from breadsticks to wings. Here are the prices.
Breadsticks And Garlic Bread
- Garlic Bread (4 pieces): $4.99
- Cheese Breadsticks (6 pieces): $6.99
- Plain Breadsticks (6 pieces): $5.49
- Garlic Knots (6 pieces): $5.99
Chicken Wings
- 6 Pieces: $8.99
- 10 Pieces: $12.99
- 15 Pieces: $17.99
- 20 Pieces: $22.99
Wings come in flavors like Buffalo, BBQ, Honey Garlic, and Plain. You can also get them boneless for the same price.
Salads
- Garden Salad: $6.99
- Caesar Salad: $7.99
- Greek Salad: $8.99
- Chef Salad: $9.99
Salads are large enough to share. Add grilled chicken for $2.50 extra.
Other Appetizers
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces): $6.99
- Onion Rings (8 pieces): $5.99
- French Fries: $4.99
- Jalapeno Poppers (6 pieces): $7.99
- Popcorn Shrimp (8 pieces): $8.99
Sides are reasonably priced. The cheese breadsticks are a popular choice because they go well with pizza sauce.
Pasta And Dinner Entrees
Cottage Inn also serves pasta dishes. These are good if you want something different from pizza. Prices are moderate.
Pasta Dishes
- Spaghetti with Marinara: $8.99
- Spaghetti with Meatballs: $10.99
- Fettuccine Alfredo: $9.99
- Chicken Alfredo: $12.99
- Baked Ziti: $10.99
- Lasagna: $11.99
All pasta dishes come with garlic bread. You can add a side salad for $2.00 extra.
Dinner Combos
- Pizza and Pasta Combo: $15.99 (includes a small pizza and a pasta dish)
- Wings and Pizza Combo: $18.99 (includes 6 wings and a medium pizza)
- Family Feast: $29.99 (includes a large pizza, 10 wings, and a salad)
Combos are a great way to save money. The Family Feast is perfect for a group of four.
Desserts And Drinks
Finish your meal with a sweet treat. Cottage Inn offers a few dessert options.
Desserts
- Chocolate Chip Cookie (large): $5.99
- Brownie: $4.99
- Cinnamon Sticks (6 pieces): $5.49
- Cheesecake (slice): $4.99
Drinks
- Soft Drinks (2-liter): $2.99
- Soft Drinks (20 oz bottle): $1.99
- Bottled Water: $1.49
- Iced Tea: $1.99
Desserts are simple but satisfying. The cinnamon sticks are a favorite for dipping in icing.
Deals, Coupons, And Special Offers
Cottage Inn often runs promotions. You can save money by checking their website or app. Here are common deals.
- Large 3-Topping Pizza for $14.99 (carryout only)
- Medium 1-Topping Pizza for $8.99 (limited time)
- Buy One Get One Free on select pizzas (check local store)
- Student Discount: 10% off with valid ID
- Military Discount: 10% off for active duty and veterans
- Online Order Discount: $2 off orders over $20
Always ask about daily specials. Some locations have a lunch menu with smaller pizzas for under $10.
How To Order: Online, Phone, Or In-Store
Ordering from Cottage Inn is easy. You have three main options.
- Online: Visit their website or use the mobile app. You can customize your pizza, apply coupons, and pay with a card. Delivery or carryout is available.
- Phone: Call your local store. This is good if you have questions or want to modify an order. Be ready with your address and payment info.
- In-Store: Walk in and order at the counter. You can see the menu and ask about specials. Carryout is usually faster.
Delivery fees vary by location. Typically, it is $2.00 to $4.00. Tip your driver if you can.
Tips For Saving Money On Your Order
Pizza can get expensive if you are not careful. Here are some practical tips.
- Stick to carryout. Delivery fees and tips add up.
- Order a larger size. A large pizza often costs only a few dollars more than a medium.
- Use coupons. Check the website or sign up for emails.
- Skip premium toppings. Stick to standard ones like pepperoni or mushrooms.
- Share a combo. The Family Feast is cheaper than ordering separately.
- Order during lunch hours. Some locations offer smaller pizzas at lower prices.
- Join the loyalty program. Earn points for free pizzas.
These small changes can save you $5 to $10 per order.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cheapest item on the Cottage Inn menu?
The cheapest item is usually the small cheese pizza at $8.99. Garlic bread at $4.99 is also a budget-friendly option.
Does Cottage Inn offer gluten-free crust?
Yes, most locations offer a gluten-free crust for an extra $2.00. It is only available in small size.
Can I get half-and-half toppings on my pizza?
Yes, you can split toppings on any pizza. There is no extra charge, but you may need to pay for the more expensive topping if they differ in price.
Does Cottage Inn have a vegan option?
They do not have vegan cheese, but you can order a pizza with vegetables and no cheese. The thin crust is vegan-friendly.
How much is delivery from Cottage Inn?
Delivery fees range from $2.00 to $4.00 depending on your location. Some stores offer free delivery for orders over $20.
Final Thoughts On The Cottage Inn Menu
The Cottage Inn pizza menu with prices is straightforward. You can get a good meal for under $15 if you choose wisely. Their thin crust is a standout, but the hand-tossed and deep-dish are also solid options. Sides and combos add value, especially for groups.
Remember to check for coupons before you order. A little planning can save you money. Whether you are feeding a family or just yourself, Cottage Inn has something at a fair price. Enjoy your pizza night.