Sub shops build loyalty through portion size, and Caseys Pizza And Sub Shop prices match generous servings with fair costs. If you are looking for a full breakdown of the Caseys Pizza And Sub Shop Menu with Prices, you have landed in the right spot. This guide covers the most popular items so you know exactly what to expect before you walk in or call ahead.
Caseys is not a fancy sit-down place. It is a grab-and-go spot that focuses on big subs, hot pizza by the slice, and simple sides. The menu is easy to navigate, but the prices can vary slightly by location. Below is a realistic look at what you will pay today.
Caseys Pizza And Sub Shop Menu With Prices
Most customers come for the cold cuts and the hand-tossed pizza. The portions are large, so do not over-order on your first visit. Here is the core menu structure you will see at the counter.
Pizza Selections And Costs
Pizza is sold by the slice or as a whole pie. The whole pies are a better deal if you are feeding two or more people.
- Cheese Slice – $2.75
- Pepperoni Slice – $3.25
- Specialty Slice (Meat Lovers or Veggie) – $3.75
- Small Cheese Pie (10-inch) – $9.99
- Large Cheese Pie (16-inch) – $13.99
- Large Pepperoni Pie – $15.49
- Large Specialty Pie – $17.99
You can add extra toppings for about $1.50 each on a large. The crust is medium-thick and holds up well for delivery.
Sub Sandwiches And Pricing
The subs are the real reason people line up. They use fresh bread baked every morning. You can get a half or a full sub, but the full size is massive.
- Half Cold Cut Sub – $6.49
- Full Cold Cut Sub – $9.99
- Half Italian Sub – $6.99
- Full Italian Sub – $10.99
- Half Meatball Parm Sub – $7.49
- Full Meatball Parm Sub – $11.49
- Full Chicken Cheesesteak – $11.99
All subs come with lettuce, tomato, onion, and your choice of dressing. Cheese is included on hot subs only. Cold subs get cheese for an extra $0.75.
Sides, Drinks, And Extras
If you are building a meal, the sides are straightforward and cheap. They do not have a huge variety, but what they have is solid.
- French Fries (Regular) – $2.99
- French Fries (Large) – $3.99
- Onion Rings – $3.49
- Mozzarella Sticks (6 pc) – $4.99
- Chicken Wings (6 pc) – $6.99
- Can Soda – $1.50
- Bottled Water – $1.99
- Cookie (Homemade) – $1.25
Combo Deals And Value Options
If you want to save a bit, look for the daily lunch special. It usually runs from 11 AM to 2 PM on weekdays only.
- Pick any half sub
- Choose one side (fries or onion rings)
- Add a can of soda
- Total cost is just $8.99
That combo is the best value on the board. Also, they offer a large two-topping pizza for $15.99 on Tuesday nights. That deal is not advertised much, so ask at the register.
Payment And Ordering Notes
Caseys is cash-friendly, but they do accept cards. There is a small fee of $0.50 if you use a card for orders under $10. You can call ahead for pickup, which is faster than waiting in line during the lunch rush.
Delivery is available within a three-mile radius. The delivery fee is $2.99 and there is a $15 minimum order. Tips are not required but are appreciated by the drivers.
One thing to note is that the menu prices can shift by a few cents depending on the cost of supplies. The prices above are accurate as of this month, but always confirm at the counter if you are on a strict budget.
Overall, the portions are generous and the pricing is fair. If you are hungry for a big sub or a hot slice, this shop delivers on both quantity and taste. Bring cash if you can, and do not skip the homemade cookies for dessert.