Amores Pizzeria’s menu with prices stays true to its Brooklyn roots, offering thin-crust pies that fold perfectly and toppings that don’t skimp. If you are looking for a neighborhood slice or a full sheet for a party, their price list is refreshingly straight forward. You won’t find hidden fees or overpriced gourmet nonsense here, just solid pizza math.
Before you call in your order, it helps to know what things actually cost. The menu is split into classic categories, so you can budget your meal without any guesswork.
Amores Pizzeria Menu With Prices
Below is the current breakdown of their standard offerings. Keep in mind that prices can shift slightly based on the cost of flour and cheese, but these figures are accurate as of this month.
Whole Pies And Large Format
This is where the value lives. If you are feeding two people or a whole block, the whole pie pricing beats buying individual slices every time.
- Plain Cheese Pie (18″) – $16.50
- Pepperoni Pie (18″) – $19.75
- Margherita Pie (18″) – $18.25
- White Pie (Ricotta & Mozzarella) – $18.75
- Supreme Pie (Sausage, Pepperoni, Peppers, Onions) – $22.50
- Grandma Slice Tray (Square, 16 slices) – $24.00
Single Slices And Quick Bites
Walking in for a lunch break? The counter service is fast, and the slices are kept hot under the lamps. You can mix and match without breaking the bank.
- Plain Slice – $3.25
- Pepperoni Slice – $3.75
- Sicilian Slice (Thick Crust) – $3.75
- Calzone (Ricotta & Mozzarella) – $8.50
- Garlic Knots (6 pieces) – $5.00
Build Your Own Toppings
If the house specials don’t fit your mood, you can customize a pie. The pricing is simple per topping, and they do not charge extra for extra sauce.
- Start with a plain cheese pie base.
- Add any vegetable topping for $1.75 each (mushrooms, onions, peppers, olives).
- Add any meat topping for $2.50 each (pepperoni, sausage, bacon, meatball).
- Add fresh mozzarella or extra cheese for $2.25.
Drinks And Sides
You cannot eat pizza without a cold drink. The beverage selection is standard, but the prices are fair for the neighborhood.
- Canned Soda (Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite) – $1.50
- 2-Liter Bottle – $3.75
- Water Bottle – $1.25
- Side Salad (House Dressing) – $6.00
- Chicken Wings (6 pc, Plain or Buffalo) – $9.50
Deals And Combos
They run a few lunch specials during the week that are not always listed on the online menu. If you ask at the counter, you can often get a two-slice deal for under six dollars before 3 PM.
One thing to watch out for is the delivery fee. The in-store prices are good, but if you order through a third party app, the menu prices are marked up about 15%. Calling the store directly and picking up is the cheapest route.
Also, they sometimes run out of the grandma slices by early evening, so if that is what you want, go early. The cashier might also forget to mention the cash discount, so ask if they offer one before swiping your card. It saves you a buck or two sometimes.
For the most accurate pricing on a given day, give them a quick ring. The staff is friendly and will read you the full list over the phone if you ask. That way, you know exactly what your total will be before you leave the house.