New York-style pizza has a reputation to uphold, and Dons Ny Pizza sets its prices to match the quality of its hand-tossed pies. If you are looking for the full Dons Ny Pizza Menu with Prices, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down every category so you can plan your order before you even walk through the door.
Knowing what things cost ahead of time helps you avoid sticker shock. It also lets you compare slices, whole pies, and sides to get the best value for your group. Here is the complete rundown of the current menu and what you can expect to pay.
Dons Ny Pizza Menu With Prices
The menu is pretty straight forward. You have your classic cheese slices, specialty pies, and a few non-pizza options for picky eaters. Below is the exact pricing structure as of the latest update.
Individual Slices And Sides
If you are eating alone or just want a quick bite, the slice counter is your best friend. Prices here are per slice, and you can usually mix and match toppings.
- Plain Cheese Slice – $3.50
- Pepperoni Slice – $4.00
- Extra Topping Slice (mushroom, onion, sausage) – $4.25
- Garlic Knots (6 pieces) – $5.50
- Side Salad – $6.00
- Chicken Wings (6 pieces) – $8.50
Whole Round Pies
For a full pie, you are looking at better value per square inch. The small is good for one person, but the large is the sweet spot for two or three people.
- Small Cheese Pie (12″) – $12.00
- Large Cheese Pie (18″) – $18.50
- Small Pepperoni Pie – $14.00
- Large Pepperoni Pie – $21.00
- Large Specialty Pie (Margherita, Veggie, Meat Lovers) – $25.00 to $28.00
Specialty Pies Worth Trying
Dons has a few house specials that go beyond the standard toppings. These are pre-made and ready to order, but you can ask for modifications if you want.
- The Don Classic (pepperoni, sausage, extra mozzarella) – $26.00
- Brooklyn Bridge (ricotta, spinach, garlic) – $24.50
- Spicy SoHo (soppressata, hot honey, chili flakes) – $27.50
Calzones And Stromboli
These are folded and baked, so they take a few extra minutes. They come with a side of marinara sauce.
- Cheese Calzone – $10.50
- Pepperoni Stromboli – $12.00
- Chicken Parmesan Stromboli – $13.50
Drinks And Desserts
You can grab a can of soda or a bottled water to wash it all down. They also have a few sweet options if you have room left.
- Canned Soda – $1.75
- Bottled Water – $2.00
- Tiramisu (single serving) – $6.50
- NY Cheesecake Slice – $5.75
How To Save Money On Your Order
Pizza prices add up fast, but there are a few tricks to keep the total lower. Here is what regulars do to stretch their dollar.
- Order the large pie instead of two smalls. The large is almost always a better deal per slice.
- Skip the delivery app. Calling the store directly often gives you access to in-house deals that apps do not show.
- Check for a lunch special. Between 11 AM and 2 PM on weekdays, you can get a slice and a drink for $5.00.
- Buy garlic knots with your pie. Sometimes they bundle them for a discount when you ask.
One thing to note is that prices can shift slightly based on supply costs. The menu above is accurate as of this writing, but the chalkboard behind the counter is the final authority. If you see a price that seems off, just ask the cashier. They are usually happy to confirm.
Also, they do charge a small fee for extra dipping sauce. It is only $0.50 per cup, but that can catch you off guard if you are not expecting it. The cashier will ask you if you want sauce with your order, so be clear about what you need.
For large catering orders, it is best to call a day ahead. They can prepare party trays that are not listed on the regular menu. Those trays serve about 10 people and start around $45.00 for a basic cheese tray. You can add toppings for an extra charge.
If you are gluten sensitive, they do have a gluten-free crust option. It costs an additional $3.00 on any pie. The texture is a bit different from the regular crust, but it holds up well under the toppings. Just let them know when you order so they can prep the separate prep area.
Overall, the prices are fair for the portion sizes. A large cheese pie at $18.50 feeds three people easily, which puts you at about $6.00 per person. That is hard to beat for a filling meal. Next time you are in the neighborhood, grab a menu from the counter or just snap a photo of the board. That way you always know what you are paying for.