City Pizza keeps things simple with slices and pies, but the cost difference between a plain cheese and their specialty toppings matters. If you are looking for a full breakdown of the City Pizza Menu with Prices, you have come to the right spot. We have checked the current board and the online ordering system so you know exactly what to expect before you walk in the door.
Most locations operate as a walk-up counter, but the pricing structure is fairly consistent across the board. You will find that a basic cheese slice is usually around $3.50, while a whole pie starts at about $18.00. The real price jump happens when you start adding premium items like pepperoni or fresh basil.
City Pizza Menu With Prices
Below is the standard pricing guide for a large 18-inch pie. Remember that these prices can shift slightly depending on the neighborhood and local delivery fees, but this gives you a solid baseline for budgeting your order.
Classic Cheese And Tomato Pies
- Plain Cheese (Large) – $18.00
- Margherita (Fresh Mozzarella & Basil) – $22.50
- White Pie (Ricotta & Garlic) – $21.00
- Tomato Basil (No Cheese) – $19.50
If you are feeding a crowd, the plain cheese is the best value. It is a large pie and it fills people up without breaking the bank. You can always add a side of their house dressing for dipping the crust.
Specialty Toppings And Meats
The specialty options are where the cost starts to climb. Each additional topping on a large pie is about $2.75. Here is what you can expect to pay for their signature combinations.
- Pepperoni Classic – $21.00
- Sausage & Onion – $22.50
- BBQ Chicken – $25.00
- Buffalo Chicken (Spicy) – $25.50
- Meat Lovers (Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Ham) – $28.00
I have noticed that the BBQ Chicken pie is often the most popular choice on a Friday night. It comes with a sweet sauce that is not too overpowering. If you like a little heat, go for the Buffalo Chicken, but ask for extra ranch on the side.
Veggie And Light Options
For those who want to keep it lighter, the veggie options are priced a bit lower than the heavy meat pies. The Garden Veggie is a good deal if you like a lot of green peppers.
- Garden Veggie – $23.00
- Spinach & Feta – $23.50
- Mushroom & Olive – $22.00
Slice Prices And Lunch Deals
If you are just stopping in for a quick lunch, the slice prices are the way to go. They usually offer a two-slice deal with a soda for around $10.00 before tax.
- Cheese Slice – $3.50
- Pepperoni Slice – $4.00
- Specialty Slice (Rotates Daily) – $4.75
- Side Salad – $5.50
The lunch rush is between 12:00 PM and 1:30 PM. If you go after 2:00 PM, they often have a few slices left that they will reheat for you, but the selection is limited. I recomend calling ahead if you want a specific specialty slice, because they sell out fast.
One thing to watch out for is the delivery fee. If you order through a third-party app, the prices are marked up by about 15% compared to the in-store menu. It is almost always cheaper to call the store directly and pick it up yourself, if you have the time.
They also have a small selection of desserts and drinks. A can of soda is $1.50, and a chocolate cannoli is $4.00. The garlic knots are a great side order at $6.00 for eight pieces, but they are not included in the pizza pricing above.
Overall, City Pizza offers fair prices for the portion size. A large pie can easily feed three or four hungry adults. Just remember to bring cash if you are spending under $10, because sometimes the card reader has a minimum. Check the board when you walk in, because they sometimes run a Monday special on large cheese pies for $15.00, which is the best deal they offer all week.