Holey Bagel focuses on fresh-baked rings and sandwiches, with menu prices that reward an early start. If you want the full Holey Bagel Menu with Prices before you head out, this quick guide breaks down the bagels, sandwiches, spreads, and drinks so you know exactly what to expect at the counter.
The shop keeps things simple. You pick a bagel, pick a spread or filling, and pay a fair price. Morning regulars get the best value because some combo deals end before 11 a.m.
Holey Bagel Menu With Prices
Prices vary a little by location, but most stores stay close to the numbers below. Tax is not included. Card minimums may apply on small orders.
Classic Bagels
- Plain Bagel — $1.75
- Sesame Bagel — $1.85
- Poppy Seed Bagel — $1.85
- Everything Bagel — $1.95
- Cinnamon Raisin Bagel — $1.95
- Whole Wheat Bagel — $1.85
- Onion Bagel — $1.85
- Garlic Bagel — $1.85
A half dozen runs about $8.50. A full dozen is around $15.99, and that is the better deal if you have a family to feed.
Spreads And Schmears
- Plain Cream Cheese — $1.50
- Scallion Cream Cheese — $1.95
- Veggie Cream Cheese — $2.25
- Strawberry Cream Cheese — $1.95
- Butter — $0.90
- Peanut Butter — $1.50
- Jelly — $1.25
Breakfast Sandwiches
- Egg And Cheese — $4.50
- Bacon, Egg And Cheese — $5.75
- Sausage, Egg And Cheese — $5.75
- Ham, Egg And Cheese — $5.95
- Western Omelet Bagel — $6.50
- Bagel With Lox And Cream Cheese — $10.95
Lunch Sandwiches
- Turkey And Swiss — $8.25
- Ham And Cheddar — $8.25
- Tuna Salad — $7.50
- Chicken Salad — $7.75
- BLT — $7.25
- Roast Beef And Provolone — $9.50
All lunch sandwiches come on your choice of bagel or a roll. Lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles are free. Add avocado for $1.50.
Drinks And Sides
- Small Coffee — $2.25
- Large Coffee — $3.25
- Iced Coffee — $3.50
- Hot Tea — $2.00
- Orange Juice — $3.25
- Bottled Water — $1.75
- Soda Can — $1.95
- Hash Brown — $2.50
- Side Of Fruit — $3.75
How To Order And Save Money
- Go before 11 a.m. for the breakfast combo. It usually includes a bagel, egg, and small coffee for under $7.
- Buy a dozen instead of singles if you eat bagels all week. It cuts the per-bagel price almost in half.
- Ask about the day-old basket. Day-old bagels sell for around $0.75 each and taste fine toasted.
- Skip bottled drinks. A large coffee refill is cheaper then most sodas.
- Check the app or email list. Members often get a free coffee on their birthday and a dollar off any sandwich.
What Affects The Final Price
City stores charge more than suburban ones. A bagel in a big downtown shop may cost $2.50 instead of $1.75. Airport and mall spots add another markup.
Delivery apps also raise prices. You pay the menu price plus a service fee and tip. Pick up in person if you want the numbers listed here.
Now you have the whole picture. Check your local Holey Bagel for small changes, then order with confidence and save a few bucks along the way.