Casual pizza nights at Casanova Pizzeria call for checking the menu to see how their Sicilian slices compare in price to the classic pies. Before you head out the door, you want the Casanova Pizzeria Menu with Prices right in front of you so there are no surprises at the register. This guide breaks down the costs, portion sizes, and the best value picks so you can order with confidence.
Casanova Pizzeria Menu With Prices
You will find that Casanova keeps things straightforward. They focus on New York-style slices, whole pies, and a few hearty sides. The prices below reflect the current standard menu, but always check the board for daily specials or lunch combos.
Classic Cheese And Tomato Pies
If you are feeding a group or just want leftovers for tomorrow, a whole pie is the way to go. The regular cheese pizza is the baseline for everything else on the menu.
- Plain Cheese Slice – $3.50
- Whole Regular Cheese Pie (18″) – $18.00
- Whole Sicilian Cheese Pie (half sheet) – $22.00
- Extra Cheese on any slice – $1.00
- Extra Cheese on any whole pie – $3.00
Specialty Toppings And Pies
You can add pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, or onions to any slice for a small upcharge. For whole pies, the topping prices are flat, so loading up two or three toppings gives you more bang for your buck.
- Single Topping Slice – $4.25
- Single Topping Whole Pie – $21.00
- Two Topping Whole Pie – $23.50
- Three Topping Whole Pie – $25.75
- White Pie (ricotta, mozzarella, garlic) – $24.00
- Margherita Pie – $23.00
Signature Specialty Slices
These are pre-made and sitting in the hot case. They are a fast lunch option, but you pay a slight premium over the plain slice.
- Pepperoni Slice – $4.00
- Sausage and Peppers Slice – $4.50
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice – $5.00
- Buffalo Chicken Slice – $5.00
Calzones, Stromboli, And Sides
If you are not in the mood for a flat pie, the folded options are filling. A calzone here is easily two meals for most people.
- Cheese Calzone – $10.50
- Pepperoni Calzone – $12.00
- Chicken Stromboli – $12.50
- Garlic Knots (6 pieces) – $5.50
- Garlic Knots with Mozzarella Dip – $7.00
- Caesar Salad (side) – $6.00
- House Salad (side) – $6.50
Drinks And Desserts
They keep the beverage selection simple. You will find standard sodas and a few canned Italian options.
- Canned Soda – $2.00
- Bottled Water – $1.50
- Italian Soda (San Pellegrino) – $3.00
- Tiramisu (single serving) – $6.50
- Canoli (one piece) – $4.00
How To Save Money On Your Order
You do not have to pay full price every time. The lunch special is the best deal if you are eating alone.
Lunch Combo Deal
From 11 AM to 2 PM on weekdays, you can get two slices and a canned soda for a set price. This is cheaper than ordering them separately.
- Choose any two regular slices (cheese or pepperoni).
- Pick a canned soda from the cooler.
- Pay the flat lunch price of $8.50.
This combo saves you about $1.50 compared to a la carte pricing. If you want a specialty slice in the combo, they will charge a $1.00 upgrade fee.
Whole Pie Versus Slices
For a family of four, buying a whole pie is almost always smarter. Four separate cheese slices will cost you $14.00. A whole cheese pie is $18.00 and gives you eight slices. That is double the food for just four dollars more.
If you are really hungry, the Sicilian pie is the best value per square inch. It is thicker, denser, and the $22.00 price tag feeds more people than a standard round pie.
Ordering Tips For Pickup Or Delivery
Calling ahead is the fastest way to get your food. They do not have an online ordering system on their own website, but they are listed on third-party delivery apps.
Be aware that delivery apps add a service fee and a markup on the menu items. You might pay $2.00 to $3.00 more per pie through DoorDash or Uber Eats. If you live within a ten minute drive, pickup is the better financial choice.
When you call, ask for the “well done” option on your pie if you like a crispy bottom crust. There is no extra charge for this request, but it changes the baking time by about three minutes.
One thing to watch out for is the cash discount. Casanova sometimes offers a 5% discount for cash payments, but this is not always advertised. Ask the cashier when you pick up your order. It is not guaranteed, but it does not hurt to ask.
If you are ordering a calzone, expect a 15 to 20 minute wait during peak hours. They make those fresh to order, unlike the slices which are ready immediately. Plan your pickup time accordingly so you are not standing around the counter.
Finally, check the specials board above the counter. They often have a “slice of the day” that is not listed on the printed menu. This rotating option is usually priced around $3.75 and gives you a chance to try something new without committing to a full pie.
Now you have the full picture on pricing. Grab your cash or card, decide between a slice or a whole pie, and enjoy your meal at Casanova Pizzeria.