Carmellas Cafe keeps its coffee and pastry counter simple, yet the lunchtime sandwich board carries prices that feel frozen in time. If you are looking for the Carmellas Cafe Menu with Prices before you visit, you are in the right place. We broke down the full list of options so you know exactly what to order and what it will cost you.
This neighborhood spot does not overcomplicate things. You get fresh bread, quality deli meat, and hot coffee that does not taste burnt. The prices are fair for the portion sizes, and most people walk out full without spending more than fifteen dollars.
Carmellas Cafe Menu With Prices
Below is the current breakdown of the menu. Keep in mind that prices can shift slightly depending on the season or supply costs, but these numbers were accurate at the time of writing.
Hot And Iced Coffee Drinks
The coffee program is straight forward. They use a local roast and offer standard espresso drinks.
- Drip Coffee (12 oz) – $2.25
- Drip Coffee (16 oz) – $2.75
- Espresso (Single) – $2.50
- Americano – $3.25
- Cappuccino – $4.00
- Latte (Vanilla or Caramel) – $4.50
- Iced Latte – $4.75
- Cold Brew (16 oz) – $4.25
Breakfast Sandwiches And Pastries
Breakfast is served all day, which is a big win for the afternoon crowd. The pastries come from a local bakery, not a frozen food distributor.
- Butter Croissant – $2.95
- Blueberry Muffin – $3.25
- Bagel with Cream Cheese – $3.50
- Bacon, Egg, and Cheese on Roll – $6.25
- Sausage, Egg, and Cheese on Croissant – $6.75
- Avocado Toast (2 slices) – $7.50
Lunch Sandwiches And Wraps
This is where the value really shows. Each sandwich comes with a pickle spear and your choice of chips or a small side salad.
- Turkey and Swiss – $8.50
- Ham and Provolone – $8.25
- Roast Beef and Cheddar – $9.00
- Chicken Salad Sandwich – $8.75
- Tuna Melt – $8.50
- BLT with Avocado – $9.25
- Grilled Chicken Wrap – $9.50
- Veggie Hummus Wrap – $8.00
Soup And Salad Combinations
If you want something lighter, you can pair a cup of soup with a half sandwich or a small salad.
- Cup of Soup of the Day – $4.25
- Bowl of Soup of the Day – $5.50
- House Salad (Small) – $5.00
- Caesar Salad (Small) – $5.50
- Soup and Half Sandwich Combo – $9.75
- Soup and Small Salad Combo – $9.25
Extras And Add-Ons
You can customize almost anything on the menu. These are the standard add-on prices.
- Extra Meat – $2.00
- Extra Cheese – $1.00
- Bacon Add-On – $1.50
- Avocado Add-On – $1.75
- Gluten Free Bread – $1.50
How To Order Efficiently
If you are visiting during the noon rush, you want to be ready when you step up to the counter. Here is the best way to do it.
- Decide on your protein first (turkey, ham, roast beef, or veggie).
- Pick your bread type. They offer white, wheat, rye, or a roll.
- Choose your cheese and ask for it toasted if you like it melted.
- Tell them if you want chips or a side salad.
- Pay at the register and grab your drink while you wait.
One thing to note is that they do not take phone orders for pickup during peak hours. You have to order in person or use a third party delivery app, which will add a markup to the menu prices.
Carmellas Cafe does not have a website that lists the menu with live pricing, so it is always a smart move to bring a few extra dollars in case the price of your favorite sandwich went up by fifty cents. The staff is friendly and will let you know if anything is sold out for the day. The seating area is small, so plan to take your food to go if you are with a group larger than four people. Overall, the quality matches the price point, and you will likely become a regular after just one visit.