Burgatory Menu With Prices

This is the kind of place where the burger patties are hand-formed every morning, and the menu’s pricing structure makes it clear that quality beef costs a little more. You want to know exactly what you are paying for before you walk in the door. So, here is a clear breakdown of the Burgatory menu with prices so you can plan your order without any surprises.

Burgatory is known for their custom blends and creative toppings. But the price point sits a bit above fast food, which is expected when you are getting fresh, never frozen meat. Below, we have listed the core items you will find on the board, along with the average cost you should expect to pay in 2024.

We have organized this guide by category so you can quickly find the cost of your favorite burger, shake, or side. Remember that prices can shift slightly based on your specific location, but these figures are accurate for most standard franchise stores.

Signature Burgers And Costs

The main event is the burger selection. You will see a lot of “build your own” options, but the signature creations are where the value lies. Here is what you will likely spend:

The Good Burger: A classic cheddar cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato, and their signature sauce. Expect to pay around $14.99.
Shroom Burger: Loaded with sautéed mushrooms and swiss cheese. This usually runs about $15.49.
Bison Burger: A leaner option that often costs a premium. You are looking at roughly $17.99 for this one.
Turkey Burger: A healthier choice, usually priced at $13.99.

Most burgers come with a side of their famous “Burgy” chips, but you can upgrade to fries for a small additional fee.

Shakes And Drinks Pricing

You cannot go to Burgatory and skip the “Burgy Shakes.” These are thick, spiked, and often served with a shot on the side. The pricing here is very specific because of the alcohol content.

Regular Shakes: These are alcohol-free and cost about $7.99.
Spiked Shakes: These include a liquor shot and are priced higher, usually around $11.99.
Fountain Drinks: Standard sodas are priced at $3.49 with free refills.

Appetizers And Sides

If you are sharing or just want a starter, the pricing is fairly standard for a gastropub. The portions are generous, so you might want to split these.

Burgy Chips: These are their signature house-made chips. A basket costs $5.99.
Sweet Potato Fries: A solid choice at $6.49.
Deviled Eggs: A unique appetizer that comes in at $7.49.

How To Save Money Here

Dining here can get expensive if you add a shake and appetizer to your burger. Here are a few practical ways to keep the bill down:

Skip the upgrade: Stick with the free chips instead of paying extra for fries.
Check for happy hour: Many locations offer discounted spiked shakes and appetizers during weekday afternoons.
Share a shake: The shakes are massive. Ordering one for two people is often the smartest move.

One thing to note is that the menu changes seasonally. If you are looking for a specific limited-time offer, you might see a slight price difference. The core items listed above are your safest bet for budgeting.

Also, they charge a small fee for extra sauces, so ask for them on the side when you order your burger if you want to avoid the upcharge. The quality of the beef is high, and the service is usually quick, so the price feels justified for a treat night.

If you are watching your spending, aim for the Turkey Burger or the standard Good Burger. They offer the best value for the amount of food you recieve. Just be aware that the “Burgatory Menu with Prices” can vary slightly if you order through a third-party delivery app, as those platforms often mark up the items by a dollar or two.

Go hungry, bring a friend to share with, and you will leave satisfied without breaking the bank.