This is the kind of menu where the sauce recipe has been guarded longer than the family’s best-kept secret. You are probably looking for the Brothers Pizza Menu with Prices because you want to know exactly what you will spend before you call. We have broken down the full list so you can order like a regular without the guesswork.
Brothers Pizza focuses on classic pies, hearty subs, and crispy wings. They do not overcomplicate things, which is why the place stays busy on weekends. Below is the full breakdown of what you can expect to pay for your next meal.
Brothers Pizza Menu With Prices
Prices here are fair for the portion size you get. A standard large cheese pie will feed two hungry people or three light eaters. Keep in mind that toppings are priced individually, so stacking five meats will raise the total fast.
Pizza Sizes And Base Prices
- Small (10″) Cheese – $8.99
- Medium (12″) Cheese – $11.49
- Large (14″) Cheese – $13.99
- X-Large (16″) Cheese – $16.49
- Gluten-Free Small Crust – Add $3.00
Every pizza comes with a light layer of mozzarella and their signature sauce. You can swap the red sauce for a garlic white sauce on any pie at no extra cost. That is a smart move if you are tired of the usual tomato base.
Specialty Pies You Should Try
These are the pre-set combos that usually save you a dollar or two compared to building your own. The “Brothers Supreme” is the crowd favorite.
- Brothers Supreme (Pepperoni, Sausage, Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms) – Med $16.99 / Lg $19.99
- BBQ Chicken (Grilled Chicken, Red Onion, BBQ Swirl) – Med $15.49 / Lg $18.49
- Veggie Delight (Spinach, Tomato, Feta, Black Olives) – Med $14.99 / Lg $17.99
- Meat Lovers (Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Ground Beef) – Med $17.99 / Lg $21.49
Build Your Own Toppings Pricing
If you want to go custom, each topping is charged per pizza size. Standard toppings include pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, sausage, and green peppers.
- Small – $1.25 per topping
- Medium – $1.75 per topping
- Large – $2.25 per topping
- X-Large – $2.75 per topping
- Premium Toppings (Chicken, Steak, Shrimp) – Add $1.00 extra per size
Subs, Wings, And Sides
Do not sleep on the rest of the menu. The chicken parm sub is huge and comes with fries on the side. Wings are fried hard and tossed in your choice of sauce.
- Classic Cheese Sub – $7.99
- Chicken Parm Sub – $9.49
- Philly Cheesesteak Sub – $10.99
- Bone-In Wings (10 pcs) – $11.99
- Boneless Wings (10 pcs) – $10.49
- Garlic Knots (8 pcs) – $5.99
- Side of Fries – $3.49
Deals And Combo Offers
If you are feeding a group, the combo boxes are the best value on the board. They usually run these specials all week, not just on Tuesday.
- One Large 1-Topping Pizza + 10 Wings + 2-Liter Soda – $24.99
- Two Medium 2-Topping Pizzas + Garlic Knots – $27.99
- X-Large Pizza + 20 Wings + 4-Liter Soda – $39.99
One thing to note: delivery fees are not included in these prices. The store adds a flat $2.50 delivery charge for orders under $20. If you pick up your order, you can sometimes get a 10% discount if you mention the online special.
Prices might shift slightly depending on your location or if the franchise owner adjusts for local costs. The menu we listed above is accurate for the main branch as of last month. It is always a good idea to call ahead if you are ordering a large party tray, because those are priced by the foot and not listed on the standard paper menu.
For a family of four, grabbing a large specialty pizza and a side of wings will run you about $32 before tax. That is a decent deal compared to other delivery chains in the area. Stick to the combo deals if you want leftovers for lunch the next day.
Now you know exactly what to expect when you open the Brothers Pizza menu with prices. Go ahead and pre-order on the app to skip the Friday night rush. Your stomach will thank you later.