Brothers Bagels charges differently for hand-rolled varieties versus their machine-made counterparts, a distinction visible only in the fine print. If you are looking for a clear breakdown of the Brothers Bagels Menu with Prices, you have landed in the right spot. This guide cuts through the clutter so you know exactly what to expect before you walk up to the counter.
Most locations keep the pricing structure simple, but the toppings and spreads add up quickly. Below, we break down the core items, the combos, and the drinks. You will also learn a few tricks to keep your total lower without skipping the good stuff.
Brothers Bagels Menu With Prices
Before we get into the specifics, remember that prices vary slightly by state and franchise owner. The figures below reflect the average national cost at the time of writing. Always check the board at your local shop for the final number.
Plain And Specialty Bagels
The base price is for a single bagel with no cream cheese. The hand-rolled “Artisan” line costs more because of the extra proofing time. The machine-made “Classic” line is your budget option.
- Classic Bagel (Plain, Everything, Sesame): $1.29
- Artisan Bagel (Sourdough, Jalapeno Cheddar): $1.89
- Sweet Bagel (Cinnamon Raisin, Blueberry): $1.59
- Gluten-Free Bagel: $2.49
Cream Cheese And Spreads
You can buy a schmear on the side or get it pre-schmeared. The pre-schmeared option is usually cheaper than buying a tub.
- Pre-Schmeared Plain Cream Cheese: $0.75
- Flavored Schmear (Veggie, Lox Style): $1.25
- Whipped Butter: $0.50
- Peanut Butter Packet: $1.00
Sandwiches And Melts
These are the hot items. They come on your choice of bagel. Upgrading to an Artisan bagel adds $0.60 to the price.
- Egg And Cheese: $4.29
- Bacon, Egg And Cheese: $5.49
- Nova Lox Sandwich (With Capers, Onion, Tomato): $9.99
- Tuna Melt: $6.79
Meal Deals And Combos
The combos are where you save money. The “Breakfast Combo” includes a coffee and a classic bagel with plain schmear.
- Bagel And Coffee Combo: $3.99
- Deluxe Breakfast Box (4 Bagels, 2 Schmears, 4 Coffees): $18.99
Drinks And Extras
They serve local roasters in most regions. Cold brew is pricier than the regular drip.
- Drip Coffee (Small / Large): $2.19 / $2.69
- Cold Brew: $3.49
- Fresh Orange Juice: $3.29
- Bagel Chips (Half Pound): $4.99
How To Order To Save Money
You can easily spend $15 on a single meal if you are not careful. Here is the step-by-step process to get the best value.
- Ask for the “Day Old” bagels. They are half price and perfect for toasting at home.
- Order the pre-schmeared bagel instead of a side cup of cream cheese. You get the same amount for less.
- Skip the bottled water and get tap water. They have a self-serve station.
- Check the app for a “First Time” discount code. Most locations offer 10% off.
Hidden Charges To Watch For
There are a few fees that catch people off guard. Slicing is free, but toasting is not always included.
- Toasting Fee (If Ordered Hot): $0.30
- Extra Toppings (Onion, Tomato, Capers): $0.50 each
- Credit Card Fee (Under $5 Purchase): $0.25
One time I ordered a bacon egg and cheese and forgot to ask for it on a classic bagel. The cashier defaulted to the artisan sourdough, and my total jumped by almost a dollar. Always specify the base bagel type when ordering a sandwich.
The prices here are accurate for the standard menu, but seasonal specials like the Pumpkin Bagel in October will run about $2.10. Also, the “Brothers” rewards program gives you a free classic bagel after every ten purchases, which is a decent deal if you go weekly.
Keep an eye on the digital menu board, as they update prices without changing the paper menus. The final total is always displayed before you pay, so you can remove an item if it feels too high. Now you know the full breakdown, so you can order with confidence and no surprises at the register.