Black Horse Tavern and Pub brings colonial-era charm to its dining room, with menu prices that reflect the historic setting and quality ingredients. If you are looking for the Black Horse Tavern Pub Menu with Prices before you visit, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down the cost of dining at this well-known Mendham, New Jersey spot.
Black Horse Tavern Pub Menu With Prices
Knowing what you will spend before you sit down helps you plan a relaxed meal. The menu changes with the seasons, but the core pricing structure stays consistent. Below is a current look at what you can expect to pay for popular items.
Appetizers And Small Plates
Start your meal with a shareable plate. These are great for the table or for a light bite at the bar.
- Tavern Pretzel with beer cheese dip – $12.00
- Crispy Brussels sprouts with bacon jam – $14.00
- Jumbo lump crab cake (single) – $19.00
- French onion soup crock – $11.00
- Burrata salad with heirloom tomatoes – $16.00
Main Entrees And Pub Classics
The main menu offers a mix of upscale dishes and traditional pub fare. Portions are generous, so you likely will not leave hungry.
- Fish and chips (beer-battered cod) – $26.00
- Tavern burger with aged cheddar – $19.00
- Half roast chicken with mashed potatoes – $28.00
- Pan-seared salmon with seasonal vegetables – $32.00
- Filet mignon (8 oz) with herb butter – $48.00
- Short rib pot pie – $29.00
Prices here sit slightly above average for the area. You are paying for the atmosphere and the service, not just the food. The dining room feels historic, with exposed beams and a large fireplace.
Desserts And Sweet Endings
Save room for something sweet. The dessert list is short but well chosen.
- Warm apple crisp with vanilla ice cream – $11.00
- Chocolate layer cake – $10.00
- Cheesecake of the day – $10.00
Drinks And The Bar Menu
The pub side of the tavern has its own menu that is slightly cheaper than the dining room. You can order these items only if you sit in the bar area.
- Tavern wings (half dozen) – $13.00
- Pulled pork sliders (two) – $15.00
- Pub nachos with chili – $14.00
- House salad – $9.00
Draft beers range from $7.00 to $12.00 depending on the brand. Cocktails usually cost between $13.00 and $16.00. A glass of house wine starts at $10.00.
Tips For Your Visit
Here are a few practical pointers to make your trip easier.
- Make a reservation on weekends. The tavern fills up fast, especially for dinner.
- Ask about the daily specials. These often offer better value than the regular menu.
- Parking is free but limited. Arrive early to find a spot close to the door.
- Check the website for seasonal prix-fixe menus. They sometimes offer a three-course deal for around $45.00.
The menu prices are not printed on the website as of this writing. That means you should call ahead if you need exact numbers for a specific date. The staff are friendly and will help you over the phone.
One thing to note: the service can be a bit slow when the pub is packed. Plan for a longer meal if you go on a Friday or Saturday night. The food is worth the wait, but you shoud not be in a hurry.
Overall, the Black Horse Tavern delivers a solid dining experience. The prices match the quality of the ingredients and the historic setting. Bring a friend, grab a seat by the window, and enjoy a meal that feels like a step back in time.