Benny’s Luncheonette carries a particular charm where menu prices echo an era when counter service and comfort food defined American dining. If you are looking for the Bennys Luncheonette Menu with Prices before you visit, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down the current offerings so you know exactly what to expect when you slide into a booth.
Bennys Luncheonette Menu With Prices
Prices here are fair for the portion sizes, and the quality is consistent. You won’t find any surprise fees or tourist traps. Below is the full breakdown of the standard menu categories.
Breakfast Favorites
Breakfast is served all day, which is a huge plus for late risers. The eggs are cooked to order and the home fries are crispy.
- Two Eggs Any Style with Toast – $8.50
- Buttermilk Pancake Stack (3) – $9.00
- Belgian Waffle with Syrup – $10.25
- Breakfast Burrito (Eggs, Cheese, Sausage) – $11.75
- Corned Beef Hash & Eggs – $12.50
Classic Sandwiches
The deli case is stocked daily, and the bread is always fresh. These are the best sellers for lunch time.
- Turkey Club Sandwich – $13.95
- Tuna Melt on Rye – $11.50
- Grilled Cheese with Tomato – $8.95
- BLT with Avocado – $12.25
- Chicken Salad Croissant – $10.75
Hearty Platters
If you are really hungry, these platters will fill you up. They come with two sides of your choice.
- Open-Faced Roast Beef – $15.50
- Meatloaf with Gravy – $14.25
- Fried Chicken (3 Pieces) – $13.75
- Fish and Chips – $16.00
Burgers & Melts
All burgers are half-pound patties cooked on the flat top. You can add cheese for a dollar more.
- Classic Cheeseburger – $12.95
- Bacon Swiss Burger – $14.50
- Patty Melt with Onions – $13.25
- Mushroom Swiss Burger – $14.00
Sides & Extras
These are perfect for sharing or adding to your main meal. The onion rings are a local favorite.
- French Fries – $4.50
- Onion Rings – $5.25
- Coleslaw – $3.00
- Side Salad – $5.50
- Cup of Soup of the Day – $4.75
Beverages & Desserts
They serve classic fountain sodas and fresh brewed iced tea. The pie selection changes daily.
- Soft Drink (Refillable) – $2.95
- Fresh Brewed Iced Tea – $3.25
- Hand-Spun Milkshake – $6.50
- Slice of Homemade Pie – $5.95
- Chocolate Layer Cake – $6.25
Daily Specials & Combos
Check the board above the counter for the daily blue plate special. It is often the best value on the menu.
- Monday: Meatloaf Special with Mashed Potatoes – $12.99
- Wednesday: Turkey Dinner with Stuffing – $13.99
- Friday: Baked Scrod – $15.99
Tips For Your Visit
Service is quick but cash is still king here. They do accept cards, but there is a small fee.
Be aware that the menu prices listed here are subject to change without notice. It is always a good idea to ask your server for the daily specials, as they often offer the best value.
If you have dietary restrictions, the kitchen is happy to modify most dishes. Just ask for the gluten-free bread option, though it might cost a little extra.
The portions are generous, so you might want to split a platter. The coffee is strong and always hot, making it a great spot for a casual meeting. We hope this guide to the Bennys Luncheonette Menu with Prices helps you plan your meal. Enjoy your visit to this classic spot.