Island cafe pricing often reflects both portion size and ingredient sourcing. If you’re searching for the Bay Island Cafe Menu with Prices, you’ve likely noticed that this spot balances casual dining with fresh, local flavors. The menu changes slightly with the seasons, but the core offerings remain consistent throughout the year.
Before you visit, it helps to know what you’re paying for. The cafe focuses on seafood and tropical-inspired dishes, but they also cater to land lovers with burgers and salads. Below, we break down the current pricing structure so you can plan your meal without any surprises.
Bay Island Cafe Menu With Prices
We’ve organized the menu into clear categories. This makes it easier to compare your options based on your budget and appetite. Remember that prices can shift by a dollar or two depending on the market cost of fresh fish.
Starters And Small Plates
These are perfect for sharing or for a lighter lunch. The portions are generous, so you might not need a full entree if you order one of these.
- Coconut Shrimp (6 pieces) – $12.50
- Island Nachos with pulled pork – $14.00
- Conch Fritters (8 pieces) – $10.75
- House Salad with mango vinaigrette – $8.50
- Clam Chowder (cup) – $6.25 / (bowl) – $8.95
Fresh Catch And Seafood Entrees
This is the heart of the menu. The catch of the day is priced daily, but the standard seafood plates have fixed costs. Each entree comes with two sides of your choice.
- Grilled Mahi Mahi – $22.00
- Blackened Grouper Sandwich – $17.50
- Seafood Linguine (shrimp, scallops, mussels) – $24.00
- Fish and Chips (beer-battered cod) – $16.95
- Garlic Butter Shrimp Skewers – $19.50
Burgers And Land Fare
Not everyone wants seafood. The kitchen offers solid alternatives that are just as filling. These options are a bit easier on the wallet too.
- Classic Cheeseburger – $14.50
- Island Chicken Sandwich (grilled or fried) – $15.00
- Black Bean Veggie Burger – $13.25
- Steak Frites (8oz sirloin) – $26.00
Kid’s Menu
Portions are smaller for the little ones, but the quality stays the same. Each kids meal includes a small drink and a side of fries or fruit.
- Mini Corn Dogs – $7.50
- Buttered Noodles – $6.00
- Grilled Cheese – $7.00
- Chicken Tenders (3 pieces) – $8.25
Beverages And Desserts
You’ll want to save room for a drink or a sweet treat. The tropical cocktails are popular, but they also have non-alcoholic options.
- Fresh Squeezed Lemonade – $4.50
- House Made Key Lime Pie – $7.00
- Pina Colada (alcoholic) – $11.00
- Iced Tea or Soda – $3.25
- Chocolate Lava Cake – $8.00
Tips For Ordering On A Budget
You can enjoy a full meal here without overspending. The lunch menu, served until 3 PM, offers the same quality at lower prices. Many locals order the appetizer portions as their main meal.
- Check the daily specials board first. It often features a discounted protein.
- Ask for water instead of a drink to save a few dollars.
- Split a starter and an entree with a friend. The portions are large enough to share.
- Visit during happy hour (4-6 PM) for reduced prices on small plates.
One thing to note is that the prices we listed are base prices. Some locations add a surcharge for certain fish types or for extra sauce. It’s always wise to confirm the price when you order the catch of the day, as it fluctuates.
We also noticed that the menu online might differ slightly from the printed one at the counter. The cafe updates their physical menu more frequently. If you see a price that seems off, just ask the cashier. They are usually happy to clarify the current Bay Island Cafe menu with prices for you.
Overall, the value is decent for the quality. You are paying for fresh ingredients and generous portions. A couple can eat a full dinner with drinks for around $50 to $60. That is reasonable for a sit-down island themed restuarant. We recomend going early on weekends to avoid the rush and to get the best selection of the daily catch.