Pizza shops build loyalty through value perception, and Bartolos Pizza has mastered menu pricing that makes their pies feel like the obvious choice for family dinners. If you are trying to figure out what to order tonight, checking the Bartolos Pizza menu with prices before you call is the smartest move. This guide breaks down the costs, portions, and best deals so you can order with confidence.
Knowing what you will pay before you arrive saves you from sticker shock at the counter. It also helps you compare options when feeding a group with different tastes. Let’s look at the current lineup and what each dollar gets you.
Bartolos Pizza Menu With Prices
The menu is straight forward, focusing on classic pies, specialty slices, and a few sides that round out the meal. Prices are competitive for the portion sizes, which is why regulars keep coming back. Below is the breakdown by category.
Classic Cheese And Pepperoni Pies
These are the building blocks of any good pizza place. Bartolos keeps the base simple but generous with toppings.
- Small Cheese (10-inch) – $8.99
- Large Cheese (16-inch) – $12.49
- Small Pepperoni (10-inch) – $10.49
- Large Pepperoni (16-inch) – $14.99
- Extra Cheese Add-On – $2.00 per pie
You get a hand-tossed crust that holds up well to heavy sauce. The large is easily enough for three hungry adults or two very hungry ones.
Specialty Pies And Combos
If you want something beyond basic, the specialty section is where the value really shows. Each pie comes pre-loaded with premium ingredients, so you do not need to pay extra for add-ons.
- Meat Lovers (Large) – $18.99
- Veggie Supreme (Large) – $16.49
- BBQ Chicken (Large) – $17.99
- Margherita Fresh (Large) – $15.99
- Buffalo Chicken (Large) – $17.49
These pies are priced about three to four dollars higher than a plain cheese, but the topping load is heavy. You won’t need to order a side salad to feel full.
Sides, Wings, And Drinks
No pizza night is complete without something to share. The sides are reasonably priced and sized for two or more people.
- Garlic Knots (8 pieces) – $5.99
- Breadsticks with Marinara – $6.49
- Chicken Wings (8 pieces) – $9.99
- Side Salad (Large) – $7.49
- 2-Liter Soda – $3.49
- Can of Soda – $1.79
The garlic knots come with a good amount of butter and parmesan. They are a solid buy if you are already over the ten dollar mark.
Slice Deals And Lunch Specials
If you are eating alone or on a lunch break, the slice counter is the way to go. They usually have cheese and pepperoni ready to go, plus one or two daily specials.
- Single Cheese Slice – $3.49
- Single Pepperoni Slice – $3.99
- Two Slices + Small Drink (Lunch Combo) – $8.99
- Slice + Side Salad Combo – $9.49
The lunch combo is available weekdays until 3 PM. It is the cheapest way to get a filling meal in that area.
How To Order And Save Money
You can order online, by phone, or at the counter. The online system sometimes has exclusive coupons that are not advertised in the store.
- Check the website for a “Deals” tab before you build your cart.
- Sign up for their text alerts to get a welcome discount code.
- Ask about the large two-topping special if you are paying full price.
- Pick up your order instead of delivery to avoid the service fee.
Delivery fees can add two to three dollars to your total, so pickup is usually the better deal. If you order two large pies, the per-pie cost drops significantly compared to buying two smalls.
One thing to note is that prices can shift slightly based on your location if you order from a third-party app. The in-store menu is the most accurate source. Also, they sometimes run a Tuesday special on large cheese pies, but you have to ask for it at the register.
Overall, the pricing structure is fair for the quality. A large specialty pie with a side of knots will run you about $25, which feeds four people comfortably. That is hard to beat for a weeknight dinner. Just remember to bring cash if you want to avoid the small card fee, and double check your order before you leave the counter.