A proper bagel should have a shiny crust and a chewy interior, but the price tag attached to that perfection varies more than you might expect at this shop. When you look at the Bagel Supreme Menu with Prices, you will notice that the cost depends heavily on the type of dough, the toppings, and the size of the sandwich you build. Before you walk in, you need a clear picture of what a single bagel costs versus a full meal deal.
This guide breaks down the current pricing structure so you can order without any surprises at the register. We will cover the classic flavors, the specialty schmears, and the combo boxes that feed a crowd. You will also learn which days offer the best value for your morning routine.
Bagel Supreme Menu With Prices
The core menu is simple to navigate once you understand the three main categories. You have the plain baked goods, the toasted sandwich options, and the beverage add-ons. Here is the exact breakdown for the most popular items on the board.
Single Bagels And Bakers Dozen
If you just want the bread, the price is very reasonable. A single plain or flavored bagel will cost you about $1.25. However, the price drops significantly when you buy in bulk.
- Plain Bagel (single): $1.25
- Everything or Cinnamon Raisin: $1.45
- Bakers Dozen (13 plain): $11.99
- Bakers Dozen (mixed premium): $14.50
You save almost three dollars by ordering the dozen instead of thirteen singles. This is the best route if you plan to freeze them for the week.
Schmear And Spread Selections
The cream cheese is where the menu gets interesting. You can get a standard tub or ask for a hand-packed portion on the side. The flavored options always cost a little extra.
- Plain Cream Cheese (2 oz): $0.75
- Veggie or Chive (2 oz): $1.10
- Lox Spread (2 oz): $1.75
Ask for the spread on the side if you are taking the bagel to go. This prevents the bread from getting soggy during your commute.
Breakfast Sandwich Combos
The hot sandwiches are the real value on the Bagel Supreme Menu with Prices. You can build a custom egg and cheese for under five dollars. Adding meat changes the total.
- Egg and Cheese on Plain: $3.75
- Bacon, Egg, and Cheese: $5.25
- Sausage, Egg, and Swiss: $5.50
- Nova Lox Sandwich (with capers): $12.95
These sandwiches come with lettuce and tomato if you ask nicely. They do not include a drink or a side of potatoes.
Meal Deals And Coffee Bundles
You can save a bit more if you pair your food with a hot beverage. The combo pricing is clearly marked on the register menu.
- Bagel with Spread + Coffee: $3.99
- Egg Sandwich + Small Coffee: $6.25
- Deluxe Box (12 bagels, 2 tubs): $21.99
The deluxe box is perfect for an office meeting. It feeds about twelve people comfortably without breaking your budget.
Price Changes And Specials
Keep in mind that the prices listed above are the standard retail rates. The shop often runs a “Happy Hour” from 2 PM to close where bagels are half price. Also, they charge an extra $0.50 for toasting if you order a plain bagel with no spread. That fee is waived if you buy a schmear.
I noticed the menu board had a typo last week listing the lox sandwich at $12.50, but the cashier charged the correct amount. Check your reciept before you leave the counter. The prices are subject to change during holidays, so call ahead if you need a large order for a specific date.
Overall, the pricing is fair for the quality. You will pay a little more than a chain bakery, but the bagels are boiled and baked fresh every morning. Bring cash if you can, as the card reader sometimes has a minimum purchase limit of five dollars.